A fascinating essay exploring how Kurdish cooperatives have manifested Rojava starting in 2014, and how it has restored some normalization of peace in a region still undergoing active warfare.
A fascinating essay exploring how Kurdish cooperatives have manifested Rojava starting in 2014, and how it has restored some normalization of peace in a region still undergoing active warfare.
Upon my arrival, what I found most immediately striking was not the scale of the project but the transformation of everyday time. In Rojava, people typically work until 2.30 pm, return home to eat and rest, then go out again at 5 pm – not to work more hours, but to take part in an assembly: of the cooperative, the commune, the women’s congress or the municipality, where everyone debated and made decisions about their neighbourhood, their communities, their families. Almost no one chose to stay at home.
Equally central to the project was its feminist dimension. Rojava’s social economy is based on a principle that mainstream economics – and most Left movements – have historically ignored: reproductive and care work, performed predominantly by women, is not a secondary complement to the economy, but its foundation.
The rhythm of life I observed in Rojava – working until 2.30-3 pm, then going to the assemblies – is precisely what capitalism denies to most people in the world, not just those living in conflict zones. The urban worker who leaves home before dawn and returns at night, too exhausted to speak with their children; the woman whose care work is invisible to the economy and the state, who never rests because her work never ends; the debt-ridden professional who works to pay for what they need to keep working; the young person who sees no horizon in the future; the children who grow up without spaces to play. All of them experience forms of violence that have no name in peace debates but are deeply felt in daily life.
I’ve always appreciated the distinction of “positive peace.” This is a thoughtful article. I’m curious how generationally rooted the Rojavan cooperative model is at scale. A cohort of dutiful,...
I’ve always appreciated the distinction of “positive peace.” This is a thoughtful article.
This organisation of time was a radical departure from the exhaustion that capitalism imposes seemingly everywhere else, where punishing schedules and precarity systematically prevent people from having any say over their own lives, leaving the state or the market as the only actor capable of making decisions about the collective.
Karl Marx called it alienated labour: work that doesn’t express human capacities but instead exhausts them, that turns both body and time into commodities. This form of violence produces no visible corpses, no headlines, but something essential is destroyed all the same: the possibility of deciding over one’s own life.
I’m curious how generationally rooted the Rojavan cooperative model is at scale. A cohort of dutiful, self-motivated workers is admirable. At the same time, I struggle to conceive of a society where their children would appreciate this degree of labor for self-governance, especially once the most pressing issues (relearning to bake bread) are understood and resolved. Even marginally more abstract or specialized questions are presumably not appealing to young people who would rather be off in their own company.
Municipal management is staggeringly boring—it’s tiring, but it’s mostly just mundane. In a large society (there are 2 million+ Kurds) that finds (or will find) itself reliant on infrastructure and all sorts of mind-numbing administrative functions, this seems impossible to escape. This is not strictly a problem of capitalism. In contrast, modern technology, even when not operated under a profit-seeking framework, is attentionally captivating; for some portion of society, it’s so much easier to stay at home and engage in some media (film, video game, phone call) than to bother going to a presumably dull meeting which requires even moderate social interaction. The article implies much about cultural and economic duty at these meetings but says nothing of fun, and the human brain is lazy.
In Pennsylvania, the Amish maintain a distinctive, peaceable agricultural society in part through a rejection of certain technology. That’s presumably not the specific intention of the Kurds’ communal model, which sounds more concerned with land use and resource distribution. How do the Kurds manage encroachment of the capitalistic environ?
The depth of social organization required to reinforce communal participation across age groups seems almost impossibly vast. I genuinely cannot comprehend it. In my experience in semi-communal settings in the West, quorum to attend to business matters is hard to achieve even when people have nothing better to do and are minimally exhausted. Government attracts a specific kind of person. How can whole-community meeting bodies avoid slowly delegating specialized decision-making in a way that obscures the communal process? And there must be a physical element as well. How big are these meetings? How are communities literally constructed to accommodate attendance? Will not the population naturally grow and make transportation into a spatially difficult problem, as it has throughout the world? How can this model be extended beyond isolated or mountainous agricultural communities and to more complex and urbanized formations of society? What lessons can the rest of us take from this approach while continuing to administer the ridiculously complicated bureaucracy of scaled-up farming, electricity transmission, medical technology, shipping, etc.?
I love the concept here and I’m glad it seems to be working. It is absolutely essential to address the underlying problems of conflict to create durable peace. You’ll have to pardon my skeptical nature. I’m reminded of the adage that “it’s easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism.”
In this case, quite literally. Unlike most revolutionary revolts of the past, this is literally people forging something from the ashes of decades of war.
In this case, quite literally. Unlike most revolutionary revolts of the past, this is literally people forging something from the ashes of decades of war.
Perhaps she's assuming that her readers are all aware, but it seems like a very odd omission for her not to mention that the PKK is designated as a terrorist organization by the EU (and other...
Cooperativism is also central to democratic confederalism, a political theory put forth by Abdullah Öcalan, one of the PKK’s founding members. It was through reading Öcalan that I became interested in the emancipatory potential of cooperatives.
Perhaps she's assuming that her readers are all aware, but it seems like a very odd omission for her not to mention that the PKK is designated as a terrorist organization by the EU (and other groups), given that her argument is that the PKK's ideology is necessary for positive peace.
Even if she would argue that the PKK is justified (which I suspect she would), fine - but you still have to make that argument!
I don't think it's necessary. The term terrorist is a way of delegitimizing organizations, demonizing the violence of those without statehood, and justifying violence against them. It's been used...
I don't think it's necessary. The term terrorist is a way of delegitimizing organizations, demonizing the violence of those without statehood, and justifying violence against them. It's been used against any group that has fought for sovereignty or against colonial powers. Looking at Kurdish history, I'm not sure what their alternative option to violence is. So rather than derail and delegitimize in the eyes of common folks a unique in depth look at alternative methods of peace building, he just stated who was involved, their political affiliation.
I know many people are uncomfortable with groups like the PKK or with the IRA or with ETA or whatever group is labelled a terrorist organization. But when you have little to no means to representation or self determination, violence is often the only option left. This is different than organizations that strictly exist to terrorize marginalized classes, like the KKK. But on the geopolitical stage, they are most often local or indigenous groups pushing back against the oppression of a nation state.
The PKK aren't designated as a terrorist group because they fought the Turkish state, they're designated as a terrorist group for As well as using child soldiers and suicide bombers, but those are...
The PKK aren't designated as a terrorist group because they fought the Turkish state, they're designated as a terrorist group for
frequently kill[ing] Kurdish villagers taking no part in the conflict, as well as civil servants. Teachers have been a particular target; 90 have been killed by the PKK since 1984.
As well as using child soldiers and suicide bombers, but those are both more defensible for an insurgency vice terror group. The reference to killing Kurdish villagers is confusing on the face, since the PKK is a Kurdish nationalist movement, but they aggressively targeted Kurds who they viewed as collaborators and violently suppressed other Kurdish groups with differing ideologies.
The obvious foil is the YPG, which is also a Kurdish nationalist group in armed conflict with turkey but which is not recognized as a terror group by any international organizations. (Turkey calls it one, naturally.)
A fascinating essay exploring how Kurdish cooperatives have manifested Rojava starting in 2014, and how it has restored some normalization of peace in a region still undergoing active warfare.
I’ve always appreciated the distinction of “positive peace.” This is a thoughtful article.
I’m curious how generationally rooted the Rojavan cooperative model is at scale. A cohort of dutiful, self-motivated workers is admirable. At the same time, I struggle to conceive of a society where their children would appreciate this degree of labor for self-governance, especially once the most pressing issues (relearning to bake bread) are understood and resolved. Even marginally more abstract or specialized questions are presumably not appealing to young people who would rather be off in their own company.
Municipal management is staggeringly boring—it’s tiring, but it’s mostly just mundane. In a large society (there are 2 million+ Kurds) that finds (or will find) itself reliant on infrastructure and all sorts of mind-numbing administrative functions, this seems impossible to escape. This is not strictly a problem of capitalism. In contrast, modern technology, even when not operated under a profit-seeking framework, is attentionally captivating; for some portion of society, it’s so much easier to stay at home and engage in some media (film, video game, phone call) than to bother going to a presumably dull meeting which requires even moderate social interaction. The article implies much about cultural and economic duty at these meetings but says nothing of fun, and the human brain is lazy.
In Pennsylvania, the Amish maintain a distinctive, peaceable agricultural society in part through a rejection of certain technology. That’s presumably not the specific intention of the Kurds’ communal model, which sounds more concerned with land use and resource distribution. How do the Kurds manage encroachment of the capitalistic environ?
The depth of social organization required to reinforce communal participation across age groups seems almost impossibly vast. I genuinely cannot comprehend it. In my experience in semi-communal settings in the West, quorum to attend to business matters is hard to achieve even when people have nothing better to do and are minimally exhausted. Government attracts a specific kind of person. How can whole-community meeting bodies avoid slowly delegating specialized decision-making in a way that obscures the communal process? And there must be a physical element as well. How big are these meetings? How are communities literally constructed to accommodate attendance? Will not the population naturally grow and make transportation into a spatially difficult problem, as it has throughout the world? How can this model be extended beyond isolated or mountainous agricultural communities and to more complex and urbanized formations of society? What lessons can the rest of us take from this approach while continuing to administer the ridiculously complicated bureaucracy of scaled-up farming, electricity transmission, medical technology, shipping, etc.?
I love the concept here and I’m glad it seems to be working. It is absolutely essential to address the underlying problems of conflict to create durable peace. You’ll have to pardon my skeptical nature. I’m reminded of the adage that “it’s easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism.”
In this case, quite literally. Unlike most revolutionary revolts of the past, this is literally people forging something from the ashes of decades of war.
Perhaps she's assuming that her readers are all aware, but it seems like a very odd omission for her not to mention that the PKK is designated as a terrorist organization by the EU (and other groups), given that her argument is that the PKK's ideology is necessary for positive peace.
Even if she would argue that the PKK is justified (which I suspect she would), fine - but you still have to make that argument!
I don't think it's necessary. The term terrorist is a way of delegitimizing organizations, demonizing the violence of those without statehood, and justifying violence against them. It's been used against any group that has fought for sovereignty or against colonial powers. Looking at Kurdish history, I'm not sure what their alternative option to violence is. So rather than derail and delegitimize in the eyes of common folks a unique in depth look at alternative methods of peace building, he just stated who was involved, their political affiliation.
I know many people are uncomfortable with groups like the PKK or with the IRA or with ETA or whatever group is labelled a terrorist organization. But when you have little to no means to representation or self determination, violence is often the only option left. This is different than organizations that strictly exist to terrorize marginalized classes, like the KKK. But on the geopolitical stage, they are most often local or indigenous groups pushing back against the oppression of a nation state.
The PKK aren't designated as a terrorist group because they fought the Turkish state, they're designated as a terrorist group for
As well as using child soldiers and suicide bombers, but those are both more defensible for an insurgency vice terror group. The reference to killing Kurdish villagers is confusing on the face, since the PKK is a Kurdish nationalist movement, but they aggressively targeted Kurds who they viewed as collaborators and violently suppressed other Kurdish groups with differing ideologies.
https://www.refworld.org/reference/countryrep/amnesty/1996/61077
The obvious foil is the YPG, which is also a Kurdish nationalist group in armed conflict with turkey but which is not recognized as a terror group by any international organizations. (Turkey calls it one, naturally.)