15 votes

A new study should be the final nail for open-plan offices

13 comments

  1. [6]
    Comment deleted by author
    Link
    1. Omnicrola
      Link Parent
      This to me is the crux of what makes open offices work in some places and not others. Or more to the point, what makes any office better. Trust. If there aren't trusting relationships between...

      This to me is the crux of what makes open offices work in some places and not others. Or more to the point, what makes any office better.

      Trust.

      If there aren't trusting relationships between coworkers, between developers and managers, between design and marketing, r etc etc, an open office won't fix it. If a manager doesn't trust thier workers and is using the open office to keep a closer eye on them, that feels terrible and will only breed resentment and more distrust.

      Rearranging the furniture doesn't create trust. Hiring people who are try to assume the best not the worst, will admit when they are wrong it they don't know something, those are the kinds of coworkers that generate a good environment to work in. And sadly a few toxic people can ruin it, especially when a business or team is just starting.

      8 votes
    2. Algernon_Asimov
      Link Parent
      ... or when you're on Tildes!

      especially during the ten minutes of the day when you're checking personal email.

      ... or when you're on Tildes!

      5 votes
    3. [3]
      Catt
      Link Parent
      I'm pretty lucky. I work in an open office, but there's an understanding that you'll have a non work related screen up somewhere. Unless it's actually hindering your work, nobody cares. There have...

      I'm pretty lucky. I work in an open office, but there's an understanding that you'll have a non work related screen up somewhere. Unless it's actually hindering your work, nobody cares.

      There have been some things I wouldn't do, but others have and nobody cares, such as have wow up on one of their monitors all day, or check Reddit during a meeting while their screen was shared. Sports have been a given, hockey is just expected to be streaming on everyone's computer, to the point where someone suggested we should just put it up on a big screen somewhere for everyone. Too bad our layout doesn't really allow for that.

      Still, my personal favourite set up is about two to four in a room with a door.

      3 votes
      1. [2]
        a_wild_swarm_appears
        Link Parent
        Seriously?? That is a bit much, pretty rude if nothing else. I feel the same about people using mobile phones during meetings, not such a big deal during meetings where stuff might not be relevant...

        or check Reddit during a meeting while their screen was shared.

        Seriously?? That is a bit much, pretty rude if nothing else. I feel the same about people using mobile phones during meetings, not such a big deal during meetings where stuff might not be relevant to you I suppose, in larger meetings, but if there's only 3 or 4 people in the meeting then I find using phones pretty rude.
        My job is the same though, lots of trust between employees and management, there's always some form of social media or youtube or something on most people's monitors.

        3 votes
        1. Catt
          Link Parent
          Yeah, I was already from a pretty casual company, but these things were a bit awkward for me. I find it rude too. Phone things a bit different. A lot of is, me included, take notes on our phones,...

          Yeah, I was already from a pretty casual company, but these things were a bit awkward for me. I find it rude too.

          Phone things a bit different. A lot of is, me included, take notes on our phones, so they're always out.

          1 vote
  2. [3]
    IncreaseTheDosage
    Link
    It probably won't, because anything else is too costly for all those cheapskate companies.

    It probably won't, because anything else is too costly for all those cheapskate companies.

    7 votes
    1. rkcr
      Link Parent
      Yup. The real reason companies do it is so save money. They just say they're doing it for other reasons.

      Yup. The real reason companies do it is so save money. They just say they're doing it for other reasons.

      8 votes
    2. Catt
      Link Parent
      I was about to comment on this too. Open offices is super cost and space effective.

      I was about to comment on this too. Open offices is super cost and space effective.

      2 votes
  3. [3]
    EightRoundsRapid
    Link
    I've never had an office job, but the few open plan offices I've visited for meetings have had a weird atmosphere. Sort of like a malevolent paranoia permeating through the entire place. Perhaps...

    I've never had an office job, but the few open plan offices I've visited for meetings have had a weird atmosphere.

    Sort of like a malevolent paranoia permeating through the entire place. Perhaps it has to do with unnatural lighting and workers constantly on edge because someone is always able to observe them and what they're doing.

    Hopefully I can make it to retirement without ever having to be a desk jockey under flourescent light strips.

    4 votes
    1. [2]
      a_wild_swarm_appears
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      I think it has as much to do with the work culture as anything else. Where I work has really nice lighting (we can order extra lighting, or have lighting removed if we want), we can organise our...

      I think it has as much to do with the work culture as anything else. Where I work has really nice lighting (we can order extra lighting, or have lighting removed if we want), we can organise our height stand-up desks pretty much however we like within our space, and the company has a very relaxed atmosphere.
      The only thing I don't like about it is my tendency to look up from my screen sometimes if someone walks past my desk, that can be annoying if I lose my train of thought. Also, it can be a bit noisy, but I solved that with Bose QC35's.

      Edit: Having said that, at my previous employer I had my own office, you can't beat it.

      3 votes
      1. Catt
        Link Parent
        That's my issue too. Also if people walk behind me they make me jump sometimes. I was in a pretty high traffic spot and mentioned it was uncomfortable for me and got move next to a window, so it's...

        The only thing I don't like about it is my tendency to look up ...

        That's my issue too. Also if people walk behind me they make me jump sometimes. I was in a pretty high traffic spot and mentioned it was uncomfortable for me and got move next to a window, so it's pretty good now.

        Edit: I also had a private office before and it was the best. If nothing else, I liked being about to blast my music.

        2 votes
  4. patience_limited
    Link
    I work in a company that's adopted a mix of open stand-up shared desks, cubicles, time-share meeting rooms, private offices, lab rooms, and remote work arrangements over the last couple of years....

    I work in a company that's adopted a mix of open stand-up shared desks, cubicles, time-share meeting rooms, private offices, lab rooms, and remote work arrangements over the last couple of years. It's usually possible to create the type of productive space you need, at least some of the time.

    Is it always comfortable or efficient? No.

    2 votes
  5. crius
    Link
    This is unfortunately nothing new and, once again, is the fruit of not giving importance to the "quality". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-p6WWRarjNs (6.31)

    This is unfortunately nothing new and, once again, is the fruit of not giving importance to the "quality".

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-p6WWRarjNs (6.31)

    2 votes