7
votes
Weekly US politics news and updates thread - week of August 30
This thread is posted weekly - please try to post all relevant US political content in here, such as news, updates, opinion articles, etc. Extremely significant events may warrant a separate topic, but almost all should be posted in here.
This is an inherently political thread; please try to avoid antagonistic arguments and bickering matches. Comment threads that devolve into unproductive arguments may be removed so that the overall topic is able to continue.
One in five Republicans say they think Donald Trump will be reinstated as president this year
I wish I could find these people and get them to bet on it. Really these polls aren’t useful when talk is cheap.
United States Education Department probing 5 states over mask mandate bans
Whoop, embarrassing for my home state.
Fourteen Republican state lawmakers have filed a new lawsuit challenging Pennsylvania’s mail-in voting law, calling it unconstitutional and asking for it to be thrown out.
this general story is nothing new, Republicans trying to change voting laws to suppress the vote.
but, this one is extra stupid:
from 2019:
it gets worse.
here are the names of the 14 state legislators who filed the lawsuit
and here is the roll call vote from 2019
of the 14:
2 (Bonner and Twardzik) only took office in 2020 and weren't around for the vote
1 (Zimmerman) voted no on the bill
the other 11 of them voted Yes on a bill, then less than two years later decided the bill should be thrown out as unconstitutional
it's a reminder that "compromise" between Democrats and Republicans is not a worthwhile goal when one side of the compromise will do a 180 the moment it suits their interests.
and a reminder that "unconstitutional" has become a meaningless term, too often weaponized to dress up "we don't like this law" as "the founding fathers would not have liked this law, and therefore it's objectively bad".
The Atlantic: Biden deserves credit, not blame, for Afghanistan
I found the linked Washington Post article interesting: The numbers behind the Kabul airlift.
While it’s an enormous effort, the fact that civilian evacuations didn’t really start until mid-August kind of undercuts the argument that they did a good job.
I know little about Afghanistan, but I have read more than once that historically, soldiers in Afghanistan very commonly switch sides rather than fighting. There is apparently a saying, “you can never buy an Afghan, only rent him.”
So, shifting allegiances seem common. I believe many people involved were in some way aware of this and know a lot more about it than us, enough that an immediate collapse was foreseeable as a possibility by many.
But I’m wondering if, institutionally, the US government would allow itself to admit this and take appropriate precautions. It’s sort of like how many people knew and planned for a possible pandemic, so in some sense we knew it was coming, but not really?
So it wouldn’t surprise me if there were people in the US government who knew this would happen but weren’t able to do anything about it.
This is speculative though. I don’t know how it really happened. But maybe we will read stories about it soon.
I kind of like the fact that when a democratic president is in power, we can all sort of agree when his administration has been incompetent.
Last U.S. Troops Leave Afghanistan After Nearly 20 Years
House panel backs requiring women to register for the draft (if the US govt decides to use the draft again, as of right now it's apparently a contingency plan and has been so since 1973.)
(Republicans claiming to support women is a new one, lol.)
My personal opinion in this is basically that a gender-neutral draft is better than a male only draft, but worse than keeping the volunteer only force the US army is, and I do think that this can be a "more female drone pilots" situation.
I’d prefer a new bill permanently banning drafts. It’s the best way to keep things gender neutral.