51 votes

A list of independent internet forums

12 comments

  1. [3]
    Ganymede
    Link
    With Tildes going officially maintenance mode there's been a lot of talk about alternatives, successors, etc. I realize Tildes is going to continue on as-is for the foreseeable future, but I...

    With Tildes going officially maintenance mode there's been a lot of talk about alternatives, successors, etc. I realize Tildes is going to continue on as-is for the foreseeable future, but I thought I'd drop this list here anyway for people who are interested in exploring other parts of the slower social web. Forums are still out there, and while in general they're past their heyday they're still imo the best way to socialize online.

    Disclosure: I maintain this list myself, and I also run the platform that hosts it.

    12 votes
    1. IndieGamesCafe
      Link Parent
      I summoned up some courage to ask this: what's the criteria to be listed on your list? Do you accept new forums at all or there has to be a certain amount of activity. I've been building a...

      I summoned up some courage to ask this: what's the criteria to be listed on your list? Do you accept new forums at all or there has to be a certain amount of activity. I've been building a Reddit-like forum for a while now but haven't done enough to get a steady pace of users.

      If you do accept new ones, happy to send you a link to evaluate. If not, all is good. I'm glad more forums are out there. I'm of the value that instead of 1 or 2 platforms, people should frequent a few that way there's always healthy competition and pushes each forum to be better.

      3 votes
    2. ogre
      Link Parent
      How did you find all these? Almost all of these I’ve never heard of before, and they have active communities. Must have taken some serious web spelunking

      How did you find all these? Almost all of these I’ve never heard of before, and they have active communities. Must have taken some serious web spelunking

      1 vote
  2. [2]
    pseudolobster
    Link
    I can think of a few off the top of my head that are still active and are missing from this list. xdaforums - android development avsforum - audio/video enthusiasts endless-sphere - diy ebikes

    I can think of a few off the top of my head that are still active and are missing from this list.

    • xdaforums - android development
    • avsforum - audio/video enthusiasts
    • endless-sphere - diy ebikes
    7 votes
    1. just_my_imagination
      Link Parent
      hackernews - mostly tech-centric discussion board rcgroups - radio-controlled vehicles of all kinds (primary focus on aircraft) discuit has been a good replacement for the mindlessness of reddit;...

      hackernews - mostly tech-centric discussion board

      rcgroups - radio-controlled vehicles of all kinds (primary focus on aircraft)

      discuit has been a good replacement for the mindlessness of reddit; it's still small enough that I can browse the new stuff daily without wasting hours, and relevant enough to keep me checking in on a daily basis.

      Lots more that won't come to mind at the moment; many niche topics have thriving forums still. It is diminishing rapidly though; when my older bookmarks lead to a site-wide 404 I die a little inside.

      3 votes
  3. [5]
    moonwalker
    Link
    Anyone on Lobste.rs? Good or bad experiences?

    Anyone on Lobste.rs? Good or bad experiences?

    3 votes
    1. [3]
      secretfire
      Link Parent
      For some reason I've always been blocked from the site on my Linux desktop, whereas I can access it just fine on my emergency 10-year old Macbook Air. This has persisted through multiple IP...

      For some reason I've always been blocked from the site on my Linux desktop, whereas I can access it just fine on my emergency 10-year old Macbook Air. This has persisted through multiple IP addresses and different VPN connections (including no VPN connection at all). Given the highly tech-oriented focus of the forum, blocking Linux connections is... A choice.

      But from the little I've seen of it, it seems pretty good; basically the same vibe as ~comp here on Tildes, though somewhat more opinionated (a very common vibe in tech forums).

      2 votes
      1. [2]
        shu
        Link Parent
        FYI: I use Linux and can access the site just fine (with KDE & Firefox on Opensuse Tumbleweed). It would be very unusual for a website to try to block Linux as an OS.

        Given the highly tech-oriented focus of the forum, blocking Linux connections is... A choice.

        FYI: I use Linux and can access the site just fine (with KDE & Firefox on Opensuse Tumbleweed). It would be very unusual for a website to try to block Linux as an OS.

        5 votes
        1. secretfire
          Link Parent
          I figure there's probably something with my setup that's triggering an antispam response, but I can't figure out what it is. I'm using Arch, SwayWM, Firefox with default ublockorigin. I normally...

          I figure there's probably something with my setup that's triggering an antispam response, but I can't figure out what it is. I'm using Arch, SwayWM, Firefox with default ublockorigin. I normally use a (paid) VPN via wireguard for general browsing but not exclusively.

          It's not common for me to get blocked by sites but it happens every now and then, hence the emergency Macbook Air for when I need to do something really important - The worst offender in my experience is airline booking, they basically all block Linux connections in some way (at least the airlines in my area), normally letting you get halfway through the booking process before throwing a generic error. In terms of forums and 'less important' websites though, lobste.rs is basically the only one I can't get onto at all, which is a bit bizarre. I'll occasionally get gated by Cloudflare or anti-DDOS protections on sites like xcancel but normally that's a VPN thing, and I can understand that; when the issue persists without a VPN active then I really don't know what the problem is. Probably I could contact the site admins and see what's up but it's not worth the hassle, it's just an internet forum. It's all par for the course with Linux these days, but hopefully that's changing as it gets more popular.

          1 vote
    2. Toric
      Link Parent
      Im on there, but its a distinctly different purpose than tildes. I can post cool technical stuff I have done on both of them, as well as interesting technical articles I found, but I cant really...

      Im on there, but its a distinctly different purpose than tildes. I can post cool technical stuff I have done on both of them, as well as interesting technical articles I found, but I cant really post about my personal life there. I didnt post this article over there, for example, because it was more about dealing with loss than it was about the technical aspect. I dont post anything about mental health, with the possible future exception of workplace burnout. Lobsters is for technical discussion and more recently discussion around the culture of tech. Its not a place to build a support network or talk about our personal lives and problems, really.

      2 votes
  4. lostwax
    Link
    I don't use it anymore but metafilter is missing

    I don't use it anymore but metafilter is missing

    2 votes