6 votes

Jeremy Clarkson in defense of the car

10 comments

  1. [4]
    deciduous
    Link
    This video seems a bit all-over-the-place with its arguments, but it's main argument, that cars aren't that bad for the environment compared to other factors, is pretty widely accepted as true....

    This video seems a bit all-over-the-place with its arguments, but it's main argument, that cars aren't that bad for the environment compared to other factors, is pretty widely accepted as true.

    That being said, it's obviously still better to not cause any pollution than to cause a bit of pollution, so using a car less or using an environmentally friendly one is a better choice. It's also a choice that the consumer can make on their own directly. Coal is a bigger problem and I'm outspoken against coal, but I can't really stop power companies from using coal. I can control what I drive or if I drive at all.

    7 votes
    1. [2]
      papasquat
      Link Parent
      Additionally, just because one thing is a smaller problem than another doesn't mean that it's not a problem. Coal power plants are a completely separate issue from cars that can be solved by...

      Additionally, just because one thing is a smaller problem than another doesn't mean that it's not a problem. Coal power plants are a completely separate issue from cars that can be solved by completely separate policies and people. There's no reason to not work on both issues at the same time. There are almost eight billion people on the planet. We can work on more than one thing at a time.

      1 vote
      1. deciduous
        Link Parent
        Agreed. I feel like I'm missing some context to this piece, because as far as I was aware, the criticisms against cars were generally measured and appropriate for the impact they have. I'd never...

        Agreed. I feel like I'm missing some context to this piece, because as far as I was aware, the criticisms against cars were generally measured and appropriate for the impact they have. I'd never even heard the "cars cause asthma" argument until this video. It seems like the creaters of the segment are blowing the dislike of cars out of proportion.

        It's possible, given that this piece is old and from the UK, that there really was a need for a "Defense of The Car", but it comes off as a bit pointless today.

    2. annadane
      Link Parent
      It's also better for conservation of resources to not use a car. That gas/oil/whatever won't last forever.

      It's also better for conservation of resources to not use a car. That gas/oil/whatever won't last forever.

  2. [4]
    annadane
    Link
    I should mention I'm not posting this because I'm a climate denalist, it's just an interesting take on things.

    I should mention I'm not posting this because I'm a climate denalist, it's just an interesting take on things.

    4 votes
    1. [3]
      TenThousandSuns
      Link Parent
      I'm not here to start any kind of beef or a discussion or anything, but do you have a few quick bullet points for your climate change denial? I'm just curious :)

      I'm not here to start any kind of beef or a discussion or anything, but do you have a few quick bullet points for your climate change denial? I'm just curious :)

      1 vote
      1. [2]
        annadane
        Link Parent
        No, sorry, you misunderstood my point. I'm not a denialist. I am saying I'm not posting this as proof that climate change is a myth, the idea of it.

        No, sorry, you misunderstood my point. I'm not a denialist. I am saying I'm not posting this as proof that climate change is a myth, the idea of it.

        6 votes
        1. TenThousandSuns
          Link Parent
          Ha! Woops, English language can be a bit vague sometimes about the subject and predicates :D

          Ha! Woops, English language can be a bit vague sometimes about the subject and predicates

          :D

  3. [2]
    zptc
    Link
    Given that this video is 9 years old, I wonder how much of it is still valid.

    Given that this video is 9 years old, I wonder how much of it is still valid.

    1 vote
    1. annadane
      Link Parent
      Probably more than 9 years old.

      Probably more than 9 years old.