21 votes

Undead Girl Murder Farce | Discussion thread - all episodes

Alternative title(s) Undead Murder Farce, Andeddo Garu Mada Farusu
Genre(s) Fantasy, Mystery, Supernatural
No. Episodes 13
Information MyAnimeList AniList AniDB

Synopsis

The end of the 19th century—a vampire's wife is murdered, and the detective known as the "cage user" is called in to solve the crime. But there's more to the detective and the curtained birdcage he carries...after all, when solving a case involving a monster, it might just take one to know one!

(from MyAnimeList)

Discussion rules

BEWARE OF SPOILERS. Since all episode discussions are within a single thread, here are some rules to help ensure revisits are safe from spoilers.

1. How this thread is organized
  • Each top-level comment is a mini-thread for each episode discussion. A new top-level comment will be added whenever another episode is released.
  • All discussions must be posted as replies within the appropriate mini-threads only. No discussions should be posted as top-level comments.
  • Anything without dedicated mini-threads can be posted under "General chat".
2. How to navigate and avoid spoilers
  • Use the "Collapse replies" button to find the appropriate episode discussions more easily, and to make potential spoilers less visible.
  • You can also use the links at the bottom to jump directly to each episode discussion.
3. When and how to hide spoilers
  • Within each mini-thread, discussions about the current and previous episodes are freely allowed.
  • But, details about subsequent episodes and source materials are spoilers and must be hidden.
  • To hide spoilers, you can follow the "Expandable sections" part of the formatting guide.
Tips on using "Expandable" format for spoilers

Currently there's a flaw where if the comment is collapsed (by using "Collapse replies" or other ways), the hidden parts can still be seen in the small blurbs.

A workaround is by further enclosing the spoilers in quote block. Check under "General chat" for an example comment here.

Direct links to each mini-thread

Episode discussion (main)

| Ep1 | Ep2 | Ep3 | Ep4 | Ep5 | Ep6 | Ep7 )

General discussion (extra)
| General chat || Source material,


P/S: See here for more ongoing show discussion threads this season.

24 comments

  1. [4]
    unknown user
    (edited )
    Link
    EPISODE 2 "Vampire"

    EPISODE 2 "Vampire"

    2 votes
    1. Muis
      Link Parent
      Enjoyable second episode, again storyboarded by Hatakeyama. We had a little time skip and now it looks like we're setting up for a classic detective type series. I'm curious to see how this story...

      Enjoyable second episode, again storyboarded by Hatakeyama. We had a little time skip and now it looks like we're setting up for a classic detective type series. I'm curious to see how this story will play out, I'm personally hoping for a wacky twist, but at the very least from the tone of the series I expect it to be self-aware enough not to make this a 'it was the butler' kind of reveal.

      As for the characters, the dynamic between Aya and Tsugaru is fantastic, and I'm looking forward to seeing more of Annie the reporter, I hope she'll play a major role.

      I guess my enjoyment of the series will depend a lot on if it will lean towards the creative weirdness of episode one or towards the more 'tame' mystery aspects we're seeing in this second episode.

      2 votes
    2. aniMayor
      Link Parent
      I really enjoy how the format they're going with. I guess some people will be pretty surprised by the combination of a timeskip and pivoting to a pseudo-episodic detective story form, but it looks...

      I really enjoy how the format they're going with. I guess some people will be pretty surprised by the combination of a timeskip and pivoting to a pseudo-episodic detective story form, but it looks to me like that was always the intent here. The serial detective format is the story - episode 1 was just a prologue. I find a lot of detective stories can weigh themselves down with too much flashback and history of the detective characters stuck in the middle of cases, so I'm all for spending a whole episode getting the backstory out of the way so that the rest of the show can mainly focus on the cases.

      As for this particular case, seems like there's a lot of detail left to cover in the next episode, but so far...

      Raoul is the only one who seems to have a solid motive (he was obviously dissatisfied with how his father is being peaceful with the humans, and the murder is driving a rift between his father and the community), so I'm expecting him to be the culprit, but there's definitely a lot more ground to cover. -

      2 votes
    3. asterisk
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      My screenshot are on mastodon as usually. Some theses: we have another a 14-year-old girl which is (sic!) a journalist; another a cute maid; a blond loli in red dress, don't scare her; some very...

      My screenshot are on mastodon as usually.

      Some theses:

      I waited this anime as semi-adventure and compared with animes such as Dororo or Mugen no Jūnin. Well, they travelled in several countries indeed, but it hadn't been shown. It turned almost into 100 % detective. Now I'm comparing a little with Kyokou Suiri where:

      • one body is immortal,
      • one [here is two] can fight, one cann't,
      • banters included, but without Iwanagi's super horny-mode,
      • detective + supernatural.

      I'm as Shitlock:

      • the killer is father who want to make stronger influence among humans, therefore use detectives just as intruments,
      • his youngest son doesn't agree with father's politic,
      • a forest-ass didn't kill the mother, but he come after this here, reason: news + just want to kill some vampires [the loli is in danger! or not?].

      I ended here.

      1 vote
  2. [2]
    unknown user
    (edited )
    Link
    EPISODE 3 "The Immortal and the Oni"

    EPISODE 3 "The Immortal and the Oni"

    2 votes
    1. asterisk
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      Sherlock Holmes was mentioned here as a real person. I remember that at the first episode there was a person this the ring with M-letter, so… I guess he's Moriarty then. More kawaii or kowai,...
      • Sherlock Holmes was mentioned here as a real person. I remember that at the first episode there was a person this the ring with M-letter, so… I guess he's Moriarty then.

      • More kawaii or kowai, depend on your taste, loli. Still, don't scary her!

      • As I guessed, the man with a hand-crossbow didn't kill the mummy. Btw, he's German and couldn't kill the daddy. But his words in this episode bring another person who could kill the mummy. But as we know, even in this case, he wouldn't be alone here, because he need some help from inside anyway. This scene was also good [at least for me] for showing actions and wording, especially the daddy's.

      • The case isn't closed. I'm not against it, because I like the anime which has, if we believe to AniDB or MAL, only 13 episodes… which's not so much for me. Will the anime cover all the novel? Or, do we get some checkpoint and will wait the rest in new season(s)?

      • The episode was focused on gathering info. For the start, we know by Aya's eyes that any vampir in this house has hands without scratch.

      • Only the butler and the older son were without alibi. The latter even made a threat to our lovely pair, because he doesn't like when they sus also family.

      • The cute house's maid was apart from loli in one-two minute, because of bathroom. Also, we know that she's kinda novice, but at this time she already can blow blood.

      • The younger son, which I suspected in the previous episode, has partly alibi: we don't know so much what he did before walking with the father. I still sus him, because he was nervous in this time too. I remind that he was also the one with the father and butler who know where the silver were.

      • What about the loli, she wanted to sing with the older son which refused therefore the maid came to help.

      There're many theories from different minds, where even the loli which tagged with the maid could be a killer, yeah. But still stay with the youngest son, where he's motives don't changed here. But I can dig a tree heere: the older is a killer, the younger and maid know and may even help him, because they afraid him or support his idea in some way. In this case, the young doesn't support father idea because the older said so.

      The night is full of darkness, but it's your turn to share your thoughts: who is bad one(s) here?

      2 votes
  3. [7]
    unknown user
    (edited )
    Link
    General chat & misc discussion

    General chat & misc discussion


    1 vote
    1. [2]
      unknown user
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      Welcome everyone to our 2nd community watchthrough! It's not quite like last time since we're doing ongoing shows now, but the format is for the most part still the same. For this season, there...

      Welcome everyone to our 2nd community watchthrough! It's not quite like last time since we're doing ongoing shows now, but the format is for the most part still the same.

      For this season, there will be 4 more discussion threads like this posted in the next few days. Feel free to participate in any of them.

      Here's the list of shows and links to their discussion threads for your convenience,

      If you have any question or suggestion, do let me know.

      4 votes
      1. Muis
        Link Parent
        Thanks for posting! I really hope there will be some activity in these threads, to get the discussions going.

        Thanks for posting! I really hope there will be some activity in these threads, to get the discussions going.

        2 votes
    2. [3]
      asterisk
      Link Parent
      Influence of Japanese culture [mostly rakugo] on the anime.

      Influence of Japanese culture [mostly rakugo] on the anime.

      3 votes
      1. [2]
        unknown user
        Link Parent
        That's fascinating! I only knew about rakugo from Akane-banashi manga. Sadly cultural references like this is often lost to translation (literally and figuratively). Do you know where can we go to...

        That's fascinating! I only knew about rakugo from Akane-banashi manga. Sadly cultural references like this is often lost to translation (literally and figuratively).

        Do you know where can we go to find the Japanese discussions? Could be interesting to see the similarity and difference in opinions.

        1. asterisk
          Link Parent
          I'm not the author of the blog. But I guess you can search by two keywords as アンデッドガール・マーダーファルス Undead Girl Murder Farce and 落語 rakugo on Twitter included.

          I'm not the author of the blog. But I guess you can search by two keywords as アンデッドガール・マーダーファルス Undead Girl Murder Farce and 落語 rakugo on Twitter included.

          1 vote
    3. unknown user
      Link Parent
      Collapse this comment and - you'll notice that - this part is still visible, but - ... and that's how to hide spoilers.

      Collapse this comment and -

      you'll notice that -

      this part is still visible, but -

      this part isn't.

      ... and that's how to hide spoilers.

      1 vote
  4. unknown user
    (edited )
    Link
    EPISODE 1 "Oni Slayer"

    EPISODE 1 "Oni Slayer"

    1 vote
  5. [2]
    unknown user
    Link
    Source material corner (novels and manga) For discussion and questions about the source materials (WARNING Contain spoilers for anime-only)

    Source material corner (novels and manga)


    For discussion and questions about the source materials (WARNING Contain spoilers for anime-only)

    1. asterisk
      Link Parent
      I didn't read both but I saw manga is very shōjo. Here's an example from one discord server. Yeah, you can get some shōjo vibes from anime openning because of bisēnens, but this is too much.

      I didn't read both but I saw manga is very shōjo. Here's an example from one discord server. Yeah, you can get some shōjo vibes from anime openning because of bisēnens, but this is too much.

      1 vote
  6. [3]
    unknown user
    (edited )
    Link
    EPISODE 4 "The Headliner Appears"

    EPISODE 4 "The Headliner Appears"

    1. [2]
      asterisk
      Link Parent
      In this episode the case was finally closed. Looks like I predicted who's killer from the story start. I'm a detective! I kinda know that blody's going into the forest is false alibi, and he can...
      • In this episode the case was finally closed.

        Looks like I predicted who's killer from the story start. I'm a detective! I kinda know that blody's going into the forest is false alibi, and he can regenerate. But I didn't understand the bottle moment which was… kinda easy, heh, because all important information was already given.

      • I waited this moment when the a toy house was shown before.

      • The maid is too cute for this family case.

      • The loli is innocent. SHe's cute too, but in this moment I guessed that she could break the fingers. Scary, scary.

      • The fight had some problem with animation. Well, it's kinda understandable, this's not Mappa level money.

      • At the end we get some new persons, siblinging between the oni and our maid, and a gag with the father's name.

      1 vote
      1. [2]
        Comment deleted by author
        Link Parent
        1. asterisk
          Link Parent
          I dunno. Maybe it was problem with server at this time. Did/do you always have a such problem?

          I dunno. Maybe it was problem with server at this time. Did/do you always have a such problem?

          1 vote
  7. unknown user
    (edited )
    Link
    EPISODE 5 "The Immortal of London"

    EPISODE 5 "The Immortal of London"

  8. [3]
    unknown user
    (edited )
    Link
    EPISODE 6 "The Phantom Thief and the Detective"

    EPISODE 6 "The Phantom Thief and the Detective"

    1. [2]
      venerablemonster
      Link Parent
      I think I was enjoying this in the beginning a lot more. When it was Holmes inspired vs having him literally be a character. As for this episode specifically, our main team is shown to be grossly...

      I think I was enjoying this in the beginning a lot more. When it was Holmes inspired vs having him literally be a character.

      As for this episode specifically, our main team is shown to be grossly incompetent. I'm assuming in the next episode, we'll maybe see this as a ruse or not as it all appeared to be? That's my hope at least, as I can't say I like the idea of them actually being this chaotic.

      All in all, I'm really liking the ideas behind this setting so far, but feel like the execution has felt a bit lacking. Also, rushed as a whole, as I didn't expect M(oriarty) to be an active character in the plot so early. I'm curious if these gripes would be addressed checking out the source material. Any readers of the manga out there?

      2 votes
      1. ricewind
        Link Parent
        I've tried the manga but the latest translated chapter I could find only goes up to the previous episode so it doesn't help. I'm with you on hoping that the next episode would be better. Kind of...

        I've tried the manga but the latest translated chapter I could find only goes up to the previous episode so it doesn't help.

        I'm with you on hoping that the next episode would be better. Kind of disappointed with their depiction of Holmes so far too.

        2 votes
  9. unknown user
    (edited )
    Link
    EPISODE 7 "Free for All"

    EPISODE 7 "Free for All"