25 votes

First time building a PC, need some advice

I'm looking at starting to do a PC build and I'm a bit lost on which way to go CPU wise.

Proposed use case: linux, some gaming (usually older games), possibly trying to learn home lab/self hosting types of things probably in a VM but nothing really heavy. I do want to run Starfield when it comes out and maybe be able to try VR some time in the future.

I'd like to have a bit of a future proof system while getting value for my money, as in I'd like to spend less but I will spend more if it matters. This is where I'm sort of getting lost.

I tend to lean towards Intel because VM's and multitasking should work better (I think) but people seem to believe that AMD is better bang for the buck?

I feel like I'm likely not going to swap CPU's, but RAM, GPU, and storage are easy to swap so I'm not to worried.

10 comments

  1. [5]
    cstby
    Link
    https://pcpartpicker.com/ is a good resource for getting good deals, ensuring compatibility, and seeing others' builds. Trying to future proof is a fool's errand. Think of what you'll...
    • Exemplary

    https://pcpartpicker.com/ is a good resource for getting good deals, ensuring compatibility, and seeing others' builds.

    Trying to future proof is a fool's errand. Think of what you'll realistically use the PC for over the next few years and build for that. Otherwise you'll end up buying a much more than you need.

    I won't weigh in on AMD vs Intel, but I will say that AMD's entire AM4 platform is good value right now.

    18 votes
    1. [4]
      mild_takes
      Link Parent
      I guess that's fair. I just feel that certain old systems are still usable for stuff today even if that isn't gaming. I'd like to have that rather than a computer that's garbage in a few years

      Trying to future proof is a fool's errand. Think of what you'll realistically use the PC for over the next few years and build for that. Otherwise you'll end up buying a much more than you need.

      I guess that's fair. I just feel that certain old systems are still usable for stuff today even if that isn't gaming. I'd like to have that rather than a computer that's garbage in a few years

      6 votes
      1. [3]
        cstby
        Link Parent
        That makes good sense to me. I'll assure you that whatever PC you build today is highly unlikely to become garbage anytime soon. For example: if you got a Ryzen 5600X (which is a fairly budget...

        That makes good sense to me. I'll assure you that whatever PC you build today is highly unlikely to become garbage anytime soon.

        For example: if you got a Ryzen 5600X (which is a fairly budget option), it would meet your use cases above (including playing starfield) for many years to come. (Don't just trust me though, do the research.) Maybe if you get a 7600 you'll be able to upgrade a few years later. Maybe not. You can save somewhere around $300 total (given cheaper mobo and ram) by going with the 5600X. So would you bet $300 on the longevity of the 7600?

        You mentioned somewhere else in the thread that you have a 6600xt. If you're buying a new processor today, your GPU will almost certainly be your next upgrade point.

        One part that's worth future proofing though is your PSU. They are impossible to sell used. It won't cost that much more to get a fairly powerful one with a 10 year warranty.

        3 votes
        1. [2]
          mild_takes
          Link Parent
          Ya... its really easy to double the budget by small increments. I didn't mention earlier, but I have 16gb or ddr4 memory (probably not fast stuff, i'm not sure) so buying something with ddr4 also...

          Ya... its really easy to double the budget by small increments. I didn't mention earlier, but I have 16gb or ddr4 memory (probably not fast stuff, i'm not sure) so buying something with ddr4 also saves me $100 on RAM in the short term.

          I started looking more at am4 processors and maybe I'll do either the 5600g or the 5700g. The 5700 isn't tons more money but I'll be able to reuse my RAM and buy a cheaper motherboard. On board graphics would give me some flexibility in the future for using it in other systems. Then I can consider decent power supplies and just spend less money overall.

          1 vote
          1. Rich3yy
            Link Parent
            Don't buy the 5700G if you want to pair it with a dedicated GPU. It is significantly worse than the non-G equivalents, as it has less L3-cache and worse boost speeds.

            Don't buy the 5700G if you want to pair it with a dedicated GPU.

            It is significantly worse than the non-G equivalents, as it has less L3-cache and worse boost speeds.

            2 votes
  2. [4]
    Eji1700
    Link
    https://www.logicalincrements.com/ is probably the best thing ever to happen to PC building if you aren't aware of it already. VR and Starfield are pretty high bars compared to the rest of your...

    https://www.logicalincrements.com/ is probably the best thing ever to happen to PC building if you aren't aware of it already.

    VR and Starfield are pretty high bars compared to the rest of your supposed use case, and not sure how easy those are/will be with linux.

    No matter what, it helps to know your budget. For $2000 you can easily build something future proof, but that's pretty damn pricey. For $1000 it's less clear. GPU's are also a major pain in the ass cost wise right now.

    22 votes
    1. aphoenix
      Link Parent
      If you pair logicalincrements with pcpartpicker.com it's hard to go wrong.

      If you pair logicalincrements with pcpartpicker.com it's hard to go wrong.

      11 votes
    2. mild_takes
      Link Parent
      I forgot to add, I have a 6600xt currently. As far as starfield goes, that GPU should barely run it, most new CPU's should be fine. On Linux hardware requirements should be the same and getting it...

      I forgot to add, I have a 6600xt currently.

      As far as starfield goes, that GPU should barely run it, most new CPU's should be fine. On Linux hardware requirements should be the same and getting it to run... we'll see what it looks like a few months after launch.

      I'm looking to spend < 1000 CAD and to get there by cutting corners where I can: stock CPU cooler for the time being, re-using my current SSD, buying a used case.

      Logical increments looks solid, that will help a lot, thanks.

      2 votes
    3. boon
      Link Parent
      It is possible. A second hand 12700K i7 set me back £250, and a brand new RTX 4060 is currently £280 on Amazon. Paired with a: £120 motherboard £60 1TB NVMe drive £65 700W PSU £60 case £35 cpu...

      It is possible. A second hand 12700K i7 set me back £250, and a brand new RTX 4060 is currently £280 on Amazon. Paired with a:

      • £120 motherboard
      • £60 1TB NVMe drive
      • £65 700W PSU
      • £60 case
      • £35 cpu cooler

      Cost about £835 for a Starfield-compatible build, or $1,076 - just over budget.

      2 votes
  3. NaraVara
    Link
    I just built my first PC since the 90s so I have some thoughts! These involve less the parts and more the physical quality of life of building the thing. 1.) You're gonna want a good ratcheting...

    I just built my first PC since the 90s so I have some thoughts! These involve less the parts and more the physical quality of life of building the thing.

    1.) You're gonna want a good ratcheting screwdriver.

    2.) You're also probably going to want a right-angle screwdriver. Especially if you have a smaller case or a bigger GPU.

    3.) Put your GPU in last. Make sure everything else is hooked up properly beforehand. I made the mistake of putting it in before I put the MoBo in and it made the entire rest of the build a giant pain in the butt to work around the GPU.

    2 votes