12 votes

Advice on contact lenses causing red eyes

Hi, I started trialing contact lenses (toric lenses, specifically) about a month ago, and have had a problem with them making my eyes seriously red. I've tried 3 different brands of contacts now, and the issue has persisted across all three. Has anyone else had a similar experience and figure out how to manage it? Thank you!

15 comments

  1. [5]
    stu2b50
    Link
    You should really talk to your optometrist about this. As a layperson guess just as someone that uses contacts, you probably have dry eyes. Consider trying brands that have better oxygen...

    You should really talk to your optometrist about this.

    As a layperson guess just as someone that uses contacts, you probably have dry eyes. Consider trying brands that have better oxygen permissibility. Dailies Total 1 is considered the king or at least one of the best in this regard.

    But you should bring this up to an eye care professional if you want definitive answers.

    14 votes
    1. [3]
      Greg
      Link Parent
      This is exciting! I’ve been wearing the same two brands for years and I hadn’t thought to check how the technology had moved on recently. My go-tos have been Dailies Aquacomfort Plus for normal...

      Dailies Total 1 is considered the king or at least one of the best in this regard.

      This is exciting! I’ve been wearing the same two brands for years and I hadn’t thought to check how the technology had moved on recently.

      My go-tos have been Dailies Aquacomfort Plus for normal use, and then PureVision 2 for the few times a year (music festivals, long trips, etc.) that I’d rather sleep in them for a week than swap them out.

      After a bit of digging, it looks like the PureVision ones I’ve been using that are rated for up to 30 days continuous wear have 130 Dk/t permeability and 36% water content - I personally wouldn’t go more than a week and I don’t particularly enjoy the concept of sleeping in them, but for me they’re barely noticeable until you pass 48+ hours of wear. The Aquacomfort daily ones I wear are fine, but definitely feel tiring on the eyes after a normal work day. It looks like they’re 69% water, but the O2 permeability is only 26 Dk/t!

      The higher end modern daily lenses I’m seeing (Dailies Total 1, Bausch + Lomb Ultra) pass way more oxygen than my current monthly extended wear ones, have a higher overall water content, and apparently have some dark magic anisotropic materials science going on to pull that moisture to the surface. Having that in something cheap enough to swap out every day is amazing - the numbers for my current dailies are barely even on the chart.

      6 votes
      1. [2]
        stu2b50
        Link Parent
        Dailies Total 1 have been around for a while - they released all the way back in 2013 (although, the toric versions only came out late last year - lucky for OP). The thing is more that somehow or...

        Dailies Total 1 have been around for a while - they released all the way back in 2013 (although, the toric versions only came out late last year - lucky for OP). The thing is more that somehow or another Alcon got WAY ahead of their competitors back then. At best, contacts released in the last few years from J&J or Baush and Lomb are as good at the DT1 in terms of comfort and dryness.

        The tradeoff is that the "competitors" like the Oasys Max and Infuse have more "features" - they have UV protection, blue eye blockers, anti-reflective coatings, etc. All that because for a decade they couldn't beat the DT1 in comfort.

        But yeah, contact technology has gone a long way. DT1s have a 156 DK/t oxygen rating. 26 DK/t use to be state of art back when contacts were still being made of hydrogel.

        5 votes
        1. Greg
          Link Parent
          Oh wow, that’s even more impressive, and in that case I’m thoroughly pleased to have found out about it now rather than even further down the line! Looking forward to trying them out in a month or...

          Oh wow, that’s even more impressive, and in that case I’m thoroughly pleased to have found out about it now rather than even further down the line! Looking forward to trying them out in a month or so when my current box is used up.

          2 votes
    2. a_sharp_soprano_sax
      Link Parent
      Yup, I have talked to my optometrist about it, he's who had me try the different brands, but he seemed unsure of what else to tell me. I have another appointment coming up later in the week. Thank...

      Yup, I have talked to my optometrist about it, he's who had me try the different brands, but he seemed unsure of what else to tell me. I have another appointment coming up later in the week. Thank you!

      1 vote
  2. [2]
    Athing
    Link
    I used to wear toric contacts before getting eye surgery. If you work on a computer, you tend to stop blinking. Not a character flaw, just how we work. This is especially bad if you wear contacts....

    I used to wear toric contacts before getting eye surgery. If you work on a computer, you tend to stop blinking. Not a character flaw, just how we work. This is especially bad if you wear contacts.

    Try the rewetting drops. There are special lubricating drops specifically for contacts. Clean your contacts well each night after you remove them if you wear them more than one day consecutively. Torics try to rotate in your eye, that's how they correct astigmatism, so what might be happening is they are getting dry, and they are irritating your eye as they try to rotate as they rewet. Keeping them better lubricated, both with drops and, if you are reading or looking at computer screens, taking more frequent breaks, will help.

    8 votes
    1. a_sharp_soprano_sax
      Link Parent
      I'm in IT, so my whole job is basically staring at a screen, and when I'm coding I get totally locked in. Didn't even really click that it could be contributing. I'm hoping that this helps. Thank you!

      I'm in IT, so my whole job is basically staring at a screen, and when I'm coding I get totally locked in. Didn't even really click that it could be contributing. I'm hoping that this helps. Thank you!

      3 votes
  3. [2]
    smithsonian
    Link
    Is your astigmatism so bad that you need toric lenses? I had a new opthalmologist who wanted me to try toric lenses (after 20 years of standard spherical lenses). I didn't like them and went back...

    Is your astigmatism so bad that you need toric lenses?

    I had a new opthalmologist who wanted me to try toric lenses (after 20 years of standard spherical lenses). I didn't like them and went back to spherical, but just with a higher strength then the toric.

    It might be worth exploring it to see if it's something specific to the toric lenses or just a sensitivity to contact lenses.

    5 votes
    1. a_sharp_soprano_sax
      Link Parent
      Not sure, I've never worn spherical lenses so I can't say whether they would work well enough. If some of the other advice doesn't work out maybe I'll ask my optometrist if he thinks I should try...

      Not sure, I've never worn spherical lenses so I can't say whether they would work well enough. If some of the other advice doesn't work out maybe I'll ask my optometrist if he thinks I should try using spherical lenses. Thank you!

      2 votes
  4. hobblyhoy
    Link
    My first few years in contacts I had a lot of dry eye and irritation. I switched to Bausch infuse dailys and it went away entirely, I can wear them all day no trouble. You just have to find the...

    My first few years in contacts I had a lot of dry eye and irritation. I switched to Bausch infuse dailys and it went away entirely, I can wear them all day no trouble. You just have to find the brand/type that works for you. Most the optometrists I've been to will give you samples of different options too. I've also improved habits with frequently using lubricating drops (never rub your eyes, just do drops!) and that has definitely helped as well.

    2 votes
  5. [2]
    Kiwibird
    Link
    A few other thoughts just to add to the great comments you've already had: Some optometrists have more experience with contact lenses than others. Especially if you are seeing quite a young...

    A few other thoughts just to add to the great comments you've already had:

    • Some optometrists have more experience with contact lenses than others. Especially if you are seeing quite a young optometrist it could be worth asking (nicely) if there is a more senior optometrist who could have a look at your case and make some suggestions. Failing that, have a look round to see if there are any other practices in your area that position themselves as 'contact lens specialists'
    • Sometimes the problem isn't actually the lens itself but the solution you're using. The big clue for this is stinging on insertion of the lens. If the redness happens more at the end of the day it's more likely to be a dry eye problem.
    • Some people (including me) just can't tolerate contacts no matter what you do. In this case it's worth considering laser vision correction. It seems like a big cost up front but if you add up 10 years worth of contact lenses or spectacles it's really not that bad.
    2 votes
    1. Astrospud
      Link Parent
      I would also add - be careful of some optometrists. Some get free ones or get commissions when they recommend some brands. I went to one for an eye exam because my eyesight had changed a bit, and...

      I would also add - be careful of some optometrists. Some get free ones or get commissions when they recommend some brands. I went to one for an eye exam because my eyesight had changed a bit, and he recommended I try a new brand since my contacts were an old outdated brand. He gave me 4 different kinds and each were terrible and dried out before the sun went down. The last time I went to his office I looked around at how much sponsored material was in his office. I later read up that this can be common practice for some. Some countries might have conflict of interest laws but I can say from experience Canada does not.

  6. maeyples
    Link
    I have trouble with contacts and my optometrist diagnosed me with dry eye. Here's some things that worked for me on and off. Warm moist compress daily or a few times a week, this takes 5 to 10...

    I have trouble with contacts and my optometrist diagnosed me with dry eye. Here's some things that worked for me on and off.

    • Warm moist compress daily or a few times a week, this takes 5 to 10 minutes per day
    • Tear suppliments, I used EyePromise EZ tears and it worked but it was expensive at $30.00 to $60.00/per month
    • Prescription dry eye medication, there are 2 types and 3 brands last time I checked. Used it once or twice a day. Note it does sting the first month but worked very well and got better after the acclimation period. Beware you may have a bad reaction to the medication. I had very good success with Xiidra and a bad reaction to Restasis that gave me blackouts and headaches. I stopped Xiirdra due to trouble with insurance.
    • I work on a computer, don't blink often, and don't close my eyes fully when I blink (didn't know that was a thing till my optometrist told me) so I have to be more conscious of blinking fully to compensate
    • I use preservative free artificial tears with my contacts though I mostly wear glasses for convenience and comfort
    • my optometrist measured my eye diameter and switched me from a 9.0 to 8.5 diameter, this moves around less on my eye which might help the irritation. I only learned this recently after wearing contacts over 15 years and having them not stick to my eye sometimes.

    I hadn't heard about the oxygen rating. That sounds interesting to check out.

    2 votes
  7. Plik
    Link
    I have worn contacts forever (torics). I don't usually get completely red eyes, but after a long day or too many FPS hours I get red areas on the....nose side of my eyes. Some things that have...

    I have worn contacts forever (torics). I don't usually get completely red eyes, but after a long day or too many FPS hours I get red areas on the....​nose side of my eyes.

    Some things that have helped, or I have noticed issues with:

    • Dailies tend to be thinner and dry out faster
    • Weeky/biweekly/monthly tend to be thicker and dry out slower
    • Different solutions do make a difference, try all of them to find one you like
    • Squirt your eyes first, then add a drop or two to a contact, then insert when you put them in.
    • Contacts will dry out and stick to your eyeball. You can squirt your eye with solution, then pinch the contacts to "un-suction cup" them from your eye, so they float/rotate better
    • Store reusable contacts in a container with fresh solution each night...​Don't like just put them back in the package they came in (apparently people actually do this, and was part of some corporate sponsored experiment justifying why you must throw out dailies every day [you don't,​ they last multiple days with care, and it's cheaper])
    • Rohto (Japanese?) or V.​ Rohto (Vietnamese knockoff?) eye drops are amazing for red eyes. I like the V. Rohto Vitamin drops (orange bottle), slightly minty, but clears up small red veins in minutes (https://rohto.com.np/product/v-rohto-vitamin/).
    1 vote
  8. [2]
    Comment removed by site admin
    Link
    1. a_sharp_soprano_sax
      Link Parent
      Yeah I'm wearing disposables, I basically just wear them for the work day, so like 8.5 hours. I do have some contact-safe rewetting drops that I haven't really used much, maybe I'll try using them...

      Yeah I'm wearing disposables, I basically just wear them for the work day, so like 8.5 hours. I do have some contact-safe rewetting drops that I haven't really used much, maybe I'll try using them more frequently and see if that makes a difference. I'd really like to be able to wear contacts instead of my glasses so I hope it's not a matter of my body just rejecting them. Thank you!

      2 votes