11 votes

Why aren't IUDs used more for birth control?

19 comments

  1. [7]
    Kiloku
    Link
    My women friends tell me that a lot of doctors flat out refuse to set up IUDs for women who have no children yet, or without a parent's or husband's permission (even though they're adults). This...

    My women friends tell me that a lot of doctors flat out refuse to set up IUDs for women who have no children yet, or without a parent's or husband's permission (even though they're adults).

    This is in Brazil. To make it clear, there's no law saying the doctors are supposed to act like this, they just do.

    6 votes
    1. MimicSquid
      Link Parent
      My wife grew up in a small town and her gyno refused to give her an IUD on the same grounds. So she went to Planned Parenthood and they helped her. Still, it's ludicrous to block a personal choice...

      My wife grew up in a small town and her gyno refused to give her an IUD on the same grounds. So she went to Planned Parenthood and they helped her. Still, it's ludicrous to block a personal choice like getting and IUD on moral grounds.

      6 votes
    2. zaluzianskya
      Link Parent
      It's definitely the same in the U.S.

      It's definitely the same in the U.S.

      2 votes
    3. [4]
      Catt
      Link Parent
      What's the reasoning? Are they be offered other types of family planning options?

      What's the reasoning? Are they be offered other types of family planning options?

      1 vote
      1. [3]
        Kiloku
        Link Parent
        No other options are given. They just say that they might "change their minds about having kids" and reverting the IUD isn't too simple. In essence, it's the traditional sexist idea that women are...

        No other options are given.
        They just say that they might "change their minds about having kids" and reverting the IUD isn't too simple.

        In essence, it's the traditional sexist idea that women are meant to have children and working against that is somehow wrong.

        4 votes
        1. Catt
          Link Parent
          Yeah it just sounds really sexist. Reversing an IUD is simple.

          Yeah it just sounds really sexist. Reversing an IUD is simple.

          2 votes
        2. StellarTabi
          Link Parent
          Probably said by the same people who say they don't want to be baby-sat by the government when a regulation requires fast food companies to put chicken (both real and lead-free) in the meat they...

          they might "change their minds about having kids"

          Probably said by the same people who say they don't want to be baby-sat by the government when a regulation requires fast food companies to put chicken (both real and lead-free) in the meat they call "chicken".

          2 votes
  2. [7]
    MimicSquid
    Link
    Purely anecdotal, but in the SF Bay Area most of the women I've ever talked to about birth control use an IUD, though they're split on copper vs. hormonal. A good number of the ones who didn't use...

    Purely anecdotal, but in the SF Bay Area most of the women I've ever talked to about birth control use an IUD, though they're split on copper vs. hormonal. A good number of the ones who didn't use one had never heard of them and were interested in getting one once they'd gotten an explanation on how they work. I know exactly one woman who specifically opts for the packet of pills and the daily dose, but everyone else wants a solution they have to think about less often.

    5 votes
    1. [6]
      Catt
      Link Parent
      I think women may be moving more towards IUDs too. I know when I was in school, doctor's just sort of handed out birth control prescriptions and never really talked about IUDs. Talking to other...

      I think women may be moving more towards IUDs too. I know when I was in school, doctor's just sort of handed out birth control prescriptions and never really talked about IUDs. Talking to other women now, the IUDs does seem like the preferred method in my circles too.

      1 vote
      1. [5]
        demifiend
        Link Parent
        I think that some early IUDs marketed in the US back in the 1970s caused a shitload of problems, and older ob/gyns have been wary of them ever since.

        I think that some early IUDs marketed in the US back in the 1970s caused a shitload of problems, and older ob/gyns have been wary of them ever since.

        4 votes
        1. [3]
          MimicSquid
          Link Parent
          Yeah, I've got a family friend who was left sterile because of the Dalkon Shield. It caused inadvertent sterilization in more than 100,000 women.

          Yeah, I've got a family friend who was left sterile because of the Dalkon Shield. It caused inadvertent sterilization in more than 100,000 women.

          4 votes
          1. [2]
            zaluzianskya
            Link Parent
            Sign me up.

            Sign me up.

            4 votes
            1. MimicSquid
              Link Parent
              Yeah, that was my wife's response. Sterility and thousands of dollars in a settlement? Sounds good!

              Yeah, that was my wife's response. Sterility and thousands of dollars in a settlement? Sounds good!

              2 votes
        2. Catt
          Link Parent
          I can see that. I believe they weren't regulated or properly tested back then.

          I can see that. I believe they weren't regulated or properly tested back then.

  3. [2]
    sublime_aenima
    Link
    My wife tried using an IUD after she got pregnant from failing to take the pill as prescribed, but her body rejected it. We would have loved something semi-permanent but reversible like the IUD....

    My wife tried using an IUD after she got pregnant from failing to take the pill as prescribed, but her body rejected it. We would have loved something semi-permanent but reversible like the IUD. Instead, she got pregnant again and I ended up getting a vasectomy.

    4 votes
    1. MimicSquid
      Link Parent
      Good news! Vasectomies are reversable. They charge $10k for them, but that's a drop in a bucket next to having a kid, so it's not that bad.

      Good news! Vasectomies are reversable. They charge $10k for them, but that's a drop in a bucket next to having a kid, so it's not that bad.

      3 votes
  4. [3]
    Autoxidation
    Link
    Also anecdotal, my wife used one for a bit but it was very uncomfortable for her with cramping during her period. She ended up going back to pills.

    Also anecdotal, my wife used one for a bit but it was very uncomfortable for her with cramping during her period. She ended up going back to pills.

    4 votes
    1. [2]
      clem
      Link Parent
      My wife also found it quite painful to use. The doctor removed it, but dismissed and belittled her pain (this female doctor's attitude was that, yes, periods are painful), thinking she was foolish...

      My wife also found it quite painful to use. The doctor removed it, but dismissed and belittled her pain (this female doctor's attitude was that, yes, periods are painful), thinking she was foolish to remove it. We've had great experiences with doctors...

      4 votes
      1. saphirayne
        Link Parent
        Unfortunately, this is a super common attitude among doctors. I couldn't get any to take me seriously until I went to a private gyno - turns out I had endometriosis the whole time. Never picked up...

        (this female doctor's attitude was that, yes, periods are painful)

        Unfortunately, this is a super common attitude among doctors. I couldn't get any to take me seriously until I went to a private gyno - turns out I had endometriosis the whole time. Never picked up on previously because 'hurr durr periods are painful.'

        3 votes