Grayscail's recent activity
-
Comment on Determinism and Back To The Future in ~talk
-
Comment on Determinism and Back To The Future in ~talk
Grayscail (edited )LinkI believe in compatibilism, or the idea that free will and determinism are not mutually exclusive and its not a contradiction to have both. If you could rewind time and asked me what my favorite...- Exemplary
I believe in compatibilism, or the idea that free will and determinism are not mutually exclusive and its not a contradiction to have both.
If you could rewind time and asked me what my favorite flavor of ice cream is a million different times, erasing my memory every time Memento style, Im going to say chocolate ever single time. Thats not a lack of free will, thats just having a consistent personality. Maybe every one in a billion times I have a stroke at just the right moment and blurt out vanilla instead, but thats not really a true representation of my opinion, and Im not really choosing to do it in that case.
Doing stuff completely at random would be just as much a nonchoice as doing stuff the same way as making the same choice every single time, but neither of those I think are a good way of thinking about the concept of a choice to begin with.
The idea that "free will" needs to mean that a choice cant be explained deterministically I believe is derivative of the Christian idea that God exists and has absolute control everything, but at the same time humans can defy Gods will, which requires that humanity have some special ability to choose that transcends natural law. It needs to be the case that Free Will cannot follow any consistency, because otherwise you could conceive of a form of Free Will where everyone still somehow consistently chooses to be good every time, and therefore there is an apparent paradox of why a benevolent God wouldnt do this.
But if you dont believe in a perfectly benevolent omnipotent God, then this particular conception of free will doesnt need to be the case, because there are other ways to explain the existence of Evil.
-
Comment on Dox with Grok in ~tech
Grayscail (edited )LinkI tried the following prompt: Using my reddit account which I deleted recently. This is what I got back: It then followed with a pretty detailed breakdown of my writing style and activities on the...I tried the following prompt:
Given the writing and posting style from this user, can you figure out the real identity of reddit user _________
Using my reddit account which I deleted recently. This is what I got back:
Based on an extensive search across web sources, archived Reddit threads, and related discussions on X (formerly Twitter), the real identity of the Reddit user u/_____________ remains anonymous and not publicly linked to any specific individual. Their account has been deleted (resulting in 404 errors when attempting to access their user page directly), which occurred sometime after their last visible activity around 2020. No personal details like name, location, profession, or age were explicitly revealed in their posts or comments, and no credible sources connect the username to a real-world person.
It then followed with a pretty detailed breakdown of my writing style and activities on the site, despite me having deactivated the account. So apparently it can still figure out what your old posts and comments were to some extent. I also found out that I had been quoted in a couple buzzfeed lists over the years.
-
Comment on Survey reveals almost 50% of California teachers may quit teaching soon in ~life
Grayscail Link ParentI dont really understand why this needs to be an external action. Are teachers not allowed to ban cellphones? Is there a law or school ordinance that prevents them from doing so?I dont really understand why this needs to be an external action. Are teachers not allowed to ban cellphones? Is there a law or school ordinance that prevents them from doing so?
-
Is intervening in Iran actually justified?
8 votes -
Comment on Third spaces: What do we want, and how do we get them? in ~life
Grayscail LinkI dont really think there is a lack of third spaces, there are lots of parks and libraries and public squares and such. Its just that people arent there. When I hear talk about the need for third...I dont really think there is a lack of third spaces, there are lots of parks and libraries and public squares and such. Its just that people arent there.
When I hear talk about the need for third spaces it usually sounds like people wanting a place they can go to meet new people and make friends. Which requires a bunch of other people decide to start frequenting those particular free spaces and turning it into a social venue.
I think what is really lacking is a cultural norm of just going to hang out with strangers. Thats not a common thing to do, its more a thing you do when you need to fix a lack of friendships in your life, and then you are done with it.
-
Comment on Fix your hearts or die: The path to liberation for lonely men is feminism in ~life
Grayscail Link ParentI have thought about that. Ive thought about the fact that most of my apprehension towards activism of all types is due to the fact that I mostly see it online, and people online are often way...I have thought about that. Ive thought about the fact that most of my apprehension towards activism of all types is due to the fact that I mostly see it online, and people online are often way shittier than they would be in real life, especially if they can tell themselves they are being shitty in service of a greater good.
But its much more precarious a situation to dip my toes into conversations with real people. Online I can and often do write out all my thoughts and post them, and then quickly realize I dont want to be involved so I delete my comment and move on. Its much harder to cut and run if I risk having a real life conversation and it goes bad.
As for reading books, I dont think I have the patience for that. Just reading this one article took me a good while because I kept getting sidetracked with all my thoughts and objections and frustrations. It was a real slog to get through, I dont think Im up for hundreds of pages of that.
-
Comment on Fix your hearts or die: The path to liberation for lonely men is feminism in ~life
Grayscail (edited )LinkI dont think I would ever be able to earnestly engage with feminism, to be honest. The writer is not hostile, per se, but I sense a general feeling of exasperation and resentment at the...I dont think I would ever be able to earnestly engage with feminism, to be honest.
The writer is not hostile, per se, but I sense a general feeling of exasperation and resentment at the expectation of sympathizing or empathizing with men at all. When they talk about the "male loneliness epidemic" thing its framed exclusively as a men not being able to get girlfriends thing. But from what Ive seen online this buzzword describes more of a broader social disconnection which is occuring that includes regular nonsexual friendships. However, because wanting a friend doesnt come off as entitled as wanting to own a woman, its not really relevant here. Only the aspects which you ought to feel ashamed of yourself for are worth discussing.
I would also add that the characterization of what "men" are supposed to be like seems to be exclusively derived from alpha male podcasts that dont reflect average male sentiment very well, so it sounds like a strawman based on youtube personalities that are playing an exaggerated character role and therefore these conversations dont actually apply to me so much as an abstraction of male sexism that Im supposed to assume responsibility for.
I feel it would be very difficult for me to ever openly explore my thoughts and motivations, or expose amy vulnerabilities that might be underlying my thought processes, because I just would not be able to trust the dialogue as a safe place to engage with those things. I would fear that doing so would only open me up to being manipulated by people who seek to weaponize shame and guilt as a means of controlling others. I would feel compelled to bury my feelings and just pretend to engage, so as to not risk voicing an actual opinion that might not be received well.
But then again, Im not particularly bothered by the "male loneliness epidemic" so if I never get liberated I guess it doesnt matter.
-
Comment on Slop and guilt in ~talk
Grayscail LinkPeople often feel pressure to do something important or productive with their time no matter what theyre doing. But recreation is just for fun, you shouldnt have to feel bad for not challenging...People often feel pressure to do something important or productive with their time no matter what theyre doing. But recreation is just for fun, you shouldnt have to feel bad for not challenging yourself. If you feel like you enjoyed yourself watching the show, you have successfully recreated.
-
Comment on The physics of dub techno — a musicologist explains in ~music
Grayscail Link ParentI guess that makes sense, Im just used to "-ologies" sounding more exotic.I guess that makes sense, Im just used to "-ologies" sounding more exotic.
-
Comment on The physics of dub techno — a musicologist explains in ~music
Grayscail LinkThey really call the study of music "musicology"? Theres no greek or latin root that means music?They really call the study of music "musicology"? Theres no greek or latin root that means music?
-
Comment on She graduated from high school with honors but can’t read or write. Now she’s suing. in ~society
Grayscail LinkGood thing she can hire a lawyer to draft the lawsuit.Good thing she can hire a lawyer to draft the lawsuit.
-
Comment on What are your architectural hot takes? in ~design
Grayscail Link ParentI dont know how Id feel about mound type landscapes where the earth has totally reclaimed them, but I think itd be cool to have something like mayan pyramids or terraced hillsides, where the sides...I dont know how Id feel about mound type landscapes where the earth has totally reclaimed them, but I think itd be cool to have something like mayan pyramids or terraced hillsides, where the sides are concrete but the tops have plants and stuff. Standing from the top itd be like youre just seeing grass and plants, but from the base it looks like a brutalist building.
-
Comment on What are your architectural hot takes? in ~design
Grayscail Link ParentI see what you're getting at, but I think that look still is tied to our culture, if not cultural heritage. The aesthetic is certainly very modern and eschews the kind of embellishments you might...I see what you're getting at, but I think that look still is tied to our culture, if not cultural heritage.
The aesthetic is certainly very modern and eschews the kind of embellishments you might see in an old European town, but thats because America is a modern country which was shaped by modernist ideals.
Back in the 50s or whenever this style developed America was building lots of cheap affordable housing and suburban development because thats what the society of the time saw as their ideal of the American dream: a simple goal of a humble home for you and your family.
During World War II America emerged as a leading world power through mass production and logistics, and so started applying that same philosophy to peacetime development as well.
When people talk about the past now they romanticize that time when you could support a family and buy a house off a grocery clerk salary. That was the case back then because society went out of its way to prioritize simplicity and efficiency, and the minimalist aesthetic of suburbia is a reflection of that.
Granted, you might not like McDonalds, but its undeniable that its a part of American culture. Its one of the most recognizable cultural exports in the world.
-
Comment on What are your architectural hot takes? in ~design
Grayscail LinkI like it when all the buildings in a place have a consistent aesthetic. When I see a neighborhood where all the houses look the same I dont think its dystopic or depressing, I just think its a...I like it when all the buildings in a place have a consistent aesthetic. When I see a neighborhood where all the houses look the same I dont think its dystopic or depressing, I just think its a pattern, and sometimes patterns can be appealing.
Conversely when a neighborhood is filled with houses that are all trying to look unique and distinctive it can come across as gaudy and discordant.
It also gives the area as a whole a distinctive look that emphasizes cultural unity instead of individualistic style.
-
Comment on Pokémon FireRed and Pokémon LeafGreen releasing February 27th on Nintendo Switch in ~games
Grayscail (edited )Link ParentYes, thats true. I will admit that the later games have done a better job of having some differences between versions, but Im thinking more about the overarching theme of the games. Ruby and...Yes, thats true. I will admit that the later games have done a better job of having some differences between versions, but Im thinking more about the overarching theme of the games.
Ruby and Sapphire having two antagonist teams is relevant because the teams are superficially opposites but are bad in the same way, in that they are both recklessly meddling with the environment based on their own arbitrary preferences. The fact that the bad guy in one game is your ally in the other highlights how this stems from narcissism, Archie can recognize the flaws of this mindset when Maxie is doing it and vice versa, but they both fail to beleive they themselves could make such a mistake. Having this parallel between them adds something to the theme.
What happens in all the other games?
In Gen 1+2 you are just fighting a crime syndicate with no differences.
In Gen 4 Cyrus is either capturing the Time or Space pokemon, but his overarching goal is to eradicate all spirit, which apparently is something you can do with their time or space powers, so the distinction is meaningless.
In Gen 5 you choose between Truth and Ideals, but regardless of which you choose N picks the opposite and comes to the same conclusion either way. This is the one time where its ok that the difference is meaningless, because the resolution of the plot comes from N recognizing how arbitrary it is and realizing he was manipulated into his conclusions.
In Gen 6 Lysandre wants to make him and his gang immortal and kill everyone else in PokeFrance. To do this he either captures the Life pokemon or the Death pokemon. But the Death pokemon still makes you immortal, and the life pokemon still kills everyone, so theyre basically the same thing.
In Gen 7 Cosmoem either evolves into a Sun pokemon or a Moon pokemon, but Cosmog already had dimensional travel powers before evolving, so which one he evolves into has no bearing on anything.
I didnt play the games after this point, but from what I understand in Gen 8 one legendary Pokemon has a Sword and the other has a Shield... and thats it. I dont even know if they matter to the plot that much?
In Gen 9, you either get a Futuristic motorcycle pokemon or a Prehistoric motorcycle pokemon, and beyond the fact that thats dumb and makes no sense, I dont actually know what the plot is because I didnt play this one either.
-
Comment on Pokémon FireRed and Pokémon LeafGreen releasing February 27th on Nintendo Switch in ~games
Grayscail LinkGeneration 3 was close to peak in my opinion. The Pokemon games have their peak at different times for different game aspects. I think the Generation 4 era was the peak in terms of gameplay, as...Generation 3 was close to peak in my opinion.
The Pokemon games have their peak at different times for different game aspects. I think the Generation 4 era was the peak in terms of gameplay, as that is when they incorporated physical and special attacks of every type. Generation 5 is arguably where Id say the peak in terms of narrative is, with N being a cool character and team Plasma having a genuinely reasonable goal, even though it was a lie.
But Generation 3 is special because Ruby and Sapphire are I think the only games in the whole franchise to do something even remotely interesting with the whole "dual game" concept. I know this is a post about FRLG but I am particularly fond of this generation for that reason.
-
Comment on ‘Sonic 4’: Kristen Bell to voice Amy Rose in ~movies
Grayscail Link ParentThe Unraveled episode about Sonic mentioned his old name. And some other stuff. Theres actually a ton of stuff on youtube about the Sonic comics. Real insane stuff out there in the canon. Mostly...The Unraveled episode about Sonic mentioned his old name. And some other stuff.
Theres actually a ton of stuff on youtube about the Sonic comics. Real insane stuff out there in the canon. Mostly coming from Ken Penders, apparently.
-
Comment on Even when youre right, you lose in ~humanities
Grayscail (edited )LinkThis showed up on my youtube feed today and I think it closely parallels my own thoughs on the matterThis showed up on my youtube feed today and I think it closely parallels my own thoughs on the matter
-
Even when youre right, you lose
4 votes
I agree that the concept of free will as I describe it is not particularly useful. I think the concept as a whole ultimately isnt that important, and is more of a paradox to be resolved than anything.
For the concept of free will as you describe it, I think is still reconcilable with physical determinism. Because our modern scientific understanding contains inherent randomness due to quantum uncertainty.
Lets say you have a super advanced EEG and can see every neuron in a brain. You ask the test subhect to choose between two identical cubes, one on the left and one on the right. You see on the EEG that there is a train of neurons firing that are associated with that choice. In both cases the train of neurons starts the same, but the second half is different depending on whether you pick left or right. From this, you isolate a single neuron, or a single cluster of neurons, that ultimately decides which choice you make. Whether or not you choose Left depends on that one neuron firing, and whether that neuron fires depends on it crossing a particular voltage threshold.
In that scenario, if you are truly ambivalent, the first half of the train should put the voltage right on the cusp of firing, and whether or not it crosses is based on the random noise associated with that voltage, which will be based on the random motion of electrons around it. This is an inherently random process that we could not possibly predict.
I dont really know how that would work with time travel, do quantum effects change if you go back in time? Who can say?
I think in that case you could say free will has been achieved, because there is a way for your brain to follow determiniatic patterns but you still could choose either one with a 50/50 chance. I just dont think thats any more meaningful a choice than if it was 100%. Thats like making a choice based on a coin flip, its kind of a non-choice to me.