trobertson's recent activity

  1. Comment on The case for left-handed representation in gaming in ~games

    trobertson
    Link
    Pathfinder: Kingmaker offers this. It's not really mechanically relevant, but it's right there when you make your character. Interestingly, the following games from that same studio don't include...

    Pathfinder: Kingmaker offers this. It's not really mechanically relevant, but it's right there when you make your character.

    Interestingly, the following games from that same studio don't include handedness for characters.

    3 votes

  2. Comment on A freeze dryer is not a reasonable purchase in ~tech

    trobertson
    Link
    For someone else using a freeze dryer, here's SteveMRE1989 making (and enjoying!) a freeze dried homemade Thanksgiving MRE. https://youtu.be/9183p7iJ5E0

    For someone else using a freeze dryer, here's SteveMRE1989 making (and enjoying!) a freeze dried homemade Thanksgiving MRE.

    https://youtu.be/9183p7iJ5E0

    8 votes

  3. Comment on A summer Covid-19 wave in ~health

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    I'd like to rebut this - politics is not divorced from life. Politics is not some separate issue that can be considered in isolation. By pretending that it is, you are participating in the...

    I know that it's hard to empathize with a political enemy

    "political" enemy

    I'd like to rebut this - politics is not divorced from life. Politics is not some separate issue that can be considered in isolation. By pretending that it is, you are participating in the gaslight that politics is a team sport that can be ignored between the biennial votes.

    The Republicans have chosen the path of existential threat.

    • They wave Nazi flags. They knowingly collaborate with Nazis. Jewish people have the right to feel existential threat, and the right to respond accordingly.
    • They wave Confederate flags. They openly advocate for race war. All non-white people have the right to feel existential threat, and the right to respond accordingly.
    • They are dismantling the Civil Rights Act. For a second time, all non-white people have the right to feel existential threat, and the right to respond accordingly.
    • They dissolved the right to abortion. This will directly lead to the death of thousands of women. In any other time- in any other place- this is called massacre. Women have the right to feel existential threat, and the right to respond accordingly.
    • At the RNC, they are blatantly calling for the death of liberals. Non-Republicans have the right to feel existential threat, and the right to respond accordingly.

    If you think they will not act on these threats, then you are a fool:

    • in Bush v. Gore, they interfered with the vote and set the precedent that the courts can decide elections.
    • They have, in Citizen's United, disenfranchised the individual and empowered special interests.
    • On January 6, they made their first attempt to ignore the vote, and are now using those court cases to make the next attempt easier.
    • They have, just a few weeks ago, allowed government officials to take not-bribes from special interests.
    • They have, just a few weeks ago, set the stage for dictatorship by making the President unaccountable.

    They are publicly acting on their threats. They are publicly advancing their agendas.

    They are not trying to hide that they want to hurt people. They are not trying to hide that they want to abolish democracy. They are not trying to hide that they are fascist.

    11 votes

  4. Comment on Six distinct types of depression identified in Stanford Medicine-led study in ~health.mental

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    SciHub, which is just out-of-date enough to be immune to AI slop. Questionably legal, but unquestionably the best tool.

    SciHub, which is just out-of-date enough to be immune to AI slop. Questionably legal, but unquestionably the best tool.

    21 votes

  5. Comment on We need to rethink exercise – The workout paradox in ~health

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    Checked a couple out, they are empty channels with links to adult sites in their bio. Some of their profile pics are blatantly pornographic, I'm surprised youtube hasn't cracked down on them.

    Also, what's with all the naked female butts in the comments?

    Checked a couple out, they are empty channels with links to adult sites in their bio. Some of their profile pics are blatantly pornographic, I'm surprised youtube hasn't cracked down on them.

    7 votes

  6. Comment on What's your recommended survival crafting game to play solo? in ~games

    trobertson
    (edited )
    Link Parent
    The most janky thing is building. My personal most-hated thing is the snapping, as the game does a terrible job letting you move between two near-by snap points. But building overall is very...

    The most janky thing is building. My personal most-hated thing is the snapping, as the game does a terrible job letting you move between two near-by snap points. But building overall is very limited. Subnautica's building is about twice as versatile and much easier to do thanks being able to swim around the structure (Subnautica is a clear and obvious influence on Planet Crafter's buildings; I initially mistook Planet Crafter for that team's next game as a result of the almost identical visual style of everything).

    The most clumsy thing is the inventory management as you enter mid/late game. Initially, it's not too bad, but it lacks decades-old improvements such as

    • Deposit in / Stack to nearby containers
    • Craft from nearby containers
    • Auto-craft constituent parts

    This reached a tipping point for me (and is why I uninstalled) during the Insects phase, where you need to turn Larva into actual insects (which you use in further crafting). It takes >10 inventory clicks (at minimum, in multiple containers) to make 1 Bee Larva, and you need to make a lot of those (and they take >1 minute to make, for each larva). When I realized that to make a couple dozen Bee larva I would need to perform hundreds and hundreds of inventory clicks over the course of ~1 hour, I just stopped caring.

    If the game had "Craft From Nearby Containers" than this wouldn't have been an issue at all, but the lack of that makes progression so cumbersome and tedious that it stopped being worth it for me.

    The most boring/undeveloped thing is the terraforming progression. Progression is resource limited and time gated, and there isn't much of the resources you need after the 1st tier structures (specifically, Ozmium(*) is way too rare for how much you initially need it). You'll end up making 1 of each of the structures you need and then stand around waiting for the terraforming index to tick up. You can (if you have infinite patience) collect enough resources to create a lot of the low tier structures, but that just feels like pure grinding.

    And the actual progression is just waiting. Building structures accelerates the progress, but it doesn't change that it's a waiting game. It's clear that the devs know this because they added Satellites that speed up progression - by 1000% per satellite. These are expensive but absolutely required, and making and launching them is pretty tedious. These are also resource limited.

    Additionally, your terraforming structures have nothing to do with how the world terraforms. The world will proceed along a fixed terraformation, and where you place different things (like grass spreaders, flower spreaders, insect spreaders, etc.) has no impact on how the world terraforms. You can try to spread a particular tree type in an area, but the world will just grow the pre-determined tree type in that area.

    I think the game is worth playing, if only to see a game that actually takes on the idea of terraforming. But I don't think it's a game worth finishing.

    (*) Ozmium is mine-able, but only after hours of waiting for the Tier 2 Ore Extractor to unlock - and that needs Ozmium as well, so you're probably taking apart your earlier machinery in order to make your first Ozmium extractor.

    edit: it's less janky and more focused than modded minecraft, but modded minecraft also has tons of convenience features (like AE2) that eliminate the basic frustrations as you make progress. This game has none of that.

    1 vote

  7. Comment on What's your recommended survival crafting game to play solo? in ~games

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    I just uninstalled it earlier today (was about halfway through Insects stage). I agree about it being rough. It's a great idea, but the idea can only carry the jank for so long. It still feels...

    I just uninstalled it earlier today (was about halfway through Insects stage). I agree about it being rough. It's a great idea, but the idea can only carry the jank for so long. It still feels like an early access game.

  8. Comment on Factorio: Space Age releases on October 21st 2024 in ~games

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    "Go in one direction forever" has been achieved, but it's not easy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HzpUQZIr15g (Dosh's video) In the expansion, the spaceship seems to sort of do what you want -...

    "Go in one direction forever" has been achieved, but it's not easy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HzpUQZIr15g (Dosh's video)

    In the expansion, the spaceship seems to sort of do what you want - you use asteroids to produce fuel + ammo, so it's technically infinite-able, probably.

    6 votes

  9. Comment on Texas secessionists win GOP backing for independence vote: 'Major step' in ~society

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    So was Brexit, until it wasn't.

    This is all utter performative nonsense.

    So was Brexit, until it wasn't.

  10. Comment on Science fiction or fantasy recommendations for children in ~books

    trobertson
    Link
    Earthsea, by Ursula K. Le Guin.

    Earthsea, by Ursula K. Le Guin.

    17 votes

  11. Comment on What would you recommend for a single, minimal, "overview-of-the-world" news source? in ~talk

  12. Comment on Norwegian bridge collapsed ten years after it was built – all because designers focused too much on making it look good in ~engineering

    trobertson
    Link
    There's a video from a year ago I watched about this bridge, it has a lot of engineering info about what happened. How did the Engineers Miss This? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FSPI0xkTifI

    There's a video from a year ago I watched about this bridge, it has a lot of engineering info about what happened.

    How did the Engineers Miss This? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FSPI0xkTifI

    4 votes

  13. Comment on X4: Foundations 7.00 trailer in ~games

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    Kinda weird that you started with the negative comparisons, seeing as they are completely different games (as you said!). The biggest things that X4 does that other space games don't do: X4 is a...

    Kinda weird that you started with the negative comparisons, seeing as they are completely different games (as you said!). The biggest things that X4 does that other space games don't do:

    • X4 is a fully simulated economy (wartime economy, specifically)
    • The player can fully engage with that economy
    • All ship construction depends on the economy - 100% of the resources that go into a ship must be produced somewhere, and shipped by someone
    • Exactly the same deal with building stations - whether they be economic stations, military stations, shipbuilding stations, or some other purpose
      • You the player will be designing, building, owning, and profiting from the stations that all other space games take for granted
    • Sector ownership is dynamic and regions can (and do) change hands
      • You can conquer the galaxy, for real, if you want. Your player faction can genuinely take over sectors
    • Quests
      • minor quests are either economic jobs or military jobs
      • Questlines shape the factions of the galaxy and determine faction merges, wars, ceasefires, etc. They also open up new portions of the map - the Kingdom's End questline, for example, reveals another ~8 sectors (iirc) that you can't get to until you do the quest
    • You can stand on the bridge of your flagship and watch while your fleet engages your enemies
    • Or you can pilot your flagship, or your destroyers, or your frigates, or your fighters, and let the AI take primary control of your fleet
    • Similarly, you will also have economic fleets that can automate a lot of the logistical challenges your stations will face. Or you can pilot one of your traders yourself (really smart in the early game)
    • Lot of awesome mods! But probably avoid these on a first playthrough because otherwise you won't know what you want or need

    Elite definitely has the best pilot feel of all the modern space games, but that's about all it does. X4 is trying, and mostly succeeding, at being an engaging space world rather than an engaging space ship.

    7 votes

  14. Comment on What are you reading these days? in ~books

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    If you haven't already, you should read "A Journey of Black and Red". Same author, and imo a slightly better story. Ariane is even more fun than Viv.

    The Calamitous Bob

    If you haven't already, you should read "A Journey of Black and Red". Same author, and imo a slightly better story. Ariane is even more fun than Viv.

    1 vote

  15. Comment on Piracy is surging again because streaming execs ignored the lessons of the past in ~tech

  16. Comment on The New York Times sues OpenAI, Microsoft over the use of its stories to train chatbots in ~tech

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    My understanding of the case is that the NYT have produced as evidence cases where ChatGPT has, very literally, copied their articles word-for-word, as a result of a prompt to get around the NYT...

    They own the license to ... those specific articles. Not any others.

    My understanding of the case is that the NYT have produced as evidence cases where ChatGPT has, very literally, copied their articles word-for-word, as a result of a prompt to get around the NYT paywall. If that evidence is legit and not doctored, then ChatGPT has blatantly plagiarized NYT articles. That is illegal, according to contemporary copyright law.

    As for this stuff:

    The modern attitude seems to be that the first caveperson who scratched a picture on the cave floor owns the concept of cave drawings.

    The Times doesn't own the concept of news, or product reviews.

    Oh, wait, I just violated William Gibson's copyright probably. He owns cyberpunk doesn't he? Or is it Mike Pondsmith? Philip K Dick? Bruce Sterling? Guess I'll find out when one of them sues me.

    Nobody is accusing them of plagiarizing a genre of writing. That's a nonsensical refutation of the case.

    20 votes

  17. Comment on Steam Winter Sale 2023: Hidden gems in ~games

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    I don't, but seeing how it's been 2 days without a response, maybe this entertaining "review" by Sseth can sway you in one direction or another. My takeaways are that the game designer has a...

    I don't, but seeing how it's been 2 days without a response, maybe this entertaining "review" by Sseth can sway you in one direction or another. My takeaways are that the game designer has a vision and sticks to it, even when that vision causes some inconveniences.

    1 vote

  18. Comment on What games have you been playing, and what's your opinion on them? in ~games

    trobertson
    Link Parent
    I used to think this too before giving San Andreas a solid chance. It's hard to go back to Vice City now (even though VC has way better music).

    Vice City was best GTA, and I don't think there is anything that could convince me otherwise. It had a lot more soul to it than many of the others.

    I used to think this too before giving San Andreas a solid chance. It's hard to go back to Vice City now (even though VC has way better music).

  19. Comment on Patrick Rothfuss on the wait for book two of The Kingkiller Chronicle (February 26, 2009) in ~books

    trobertson
    Link
    The "2009" in the title is very important. There have been two major events since then that have shaken most fans' belief that book 3 will ever come out. Essentially, his most dedicated fanbase...

    The "2009" in the title is very important. There have been two major events since then that have shaken most fans' belief that book 3 will ever come out. Essentially, his most dedicated fanbase thinks he's been lying to them for over a decade about there even being a book 3.

    In 2020, his editor made a facebook post where she claims that she hasn't seen even a single word of book 3. From his Wikipedia:

    In July 2020, Rothfuss's editor and publisher Betsy Wollheim responded publicly on her Facebook account to an article speculating on reasons why The Doors of Stone, the concluding volume of the trilogy, had not been published,[17] saying she had "never seen a word of book three" and that she didn't think Rothfuss had written anything since 2014.[17] The post has since been deleted.[18]

    In 2021, he told his stream he would release the first chapter if his audience hit a donation goal (which they hit within minutes). Two years later, he has still not released that chapter. From his Wikipedia:

    In December 2021, Rothfuss tweeted that he would "[s]hare a full chapter of Doors of Stone" if his charity reached a $333,333 fundraising goal.[20] Later that month he added more stretch goals, with the largest being for $666,666 to "assemble the Geek Glitterati equivalent of the Avengers and record [the full chapter] for you". He noted that such a goal would take some time but said "I’m pretty sure we’ll be able to get it done early next year. February at the latest."[21] The chapter has not been released, with Rothfuss saying in April 2022 that the process was “moving more slowly than [he] would like.”[22]

    Personally, I'm done with this guy. He has made and broken far more promises than those two passages suggest, and he's got nobody to blame but himself. And when his fans ask him for the things he promised, he gets incredibly angry and rages at them. It's textbook narcissism.

    And to drive the point home, it's not like his poor behaved is a recent thing. His lies started before the first book even released - he said of books 2 and 3: "Well.... I've already written them. So you won't have to wait forever for them to come out. They'll be released on a regular schedule. One per year." This was in an interview in 2007. He's been lying to everyone for a very long time.

    21 votes

  20. Comment on Any good art based podcast recommendations? in ~arts