Oct 26 (Reuters) - While global tech stocks teeter, in China they have already crashed as lofty valuations collapse under worries about AI demand and curbs on Chinese exports.
The meltdown, tanking the mainland STAR50 index (.STAR50), of AI and semiconductor leaders by 40% in less than four months and vaporising some $480 billion in market value, is an ill omen for wobbly world markets and a dampener on China's efforts at encouraging its savers into stocks to fund the AI boom.
[...]
Shares in robot-maker Unitree (688836.SS), 8,000 times oversubscribed by retail buyers at listing, have halved since they started trading in August, and chipmaker CXMT (688825.SS), opens new tab has lost more than a quarter of its value in the past month.
Chipmakers MetaX Integrated Circuits (688802.SS), and Moore Threads Technology (688795.SS), which leapt 700% and 400% respectively on their market debuts last year, have also halved in value since July.
[...]
Shares in optical parts makers Zhongji Innolight (300308.SZ), and Eoptolink Technology (300502.SZ), are down roughly 60% from highs in June and July, in part as Washington moves towards banning the one-time darlings from supplying US data centres.
Dumb question by someone mostly uneducated about how Chinese society works, wouldn't the government just step in and dump enough money to correct it? Edit wouldn’t the government just step in if...
Dumb question by someone mostly uneducated about how Chinese society works, wouldn't the government just step in and dump enough money to correct it?
Edit wouldn’t the government just step in if there were actually a problem worth stepping in for implying, theres no issue here, since they haven’t stepped in. But, idk how it works, this is a broad assumption.
Why would it need to correct it? Not every bubble is 2008. There’s lots of financial bubbles at any point in time. Them bursting is just price discovery in action. It’s the market correcting...
Why would it need to correct it? Not every bubble is 2008. There’s lots of financial bubbles at any point in time. Them bursting is just price discovery in action. It’s the market correcting itself.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with a bubble bursting.
Ever since Deng Xiaoping, the CCP correctly realized that planned economies are a fools errand. It impossible. Market allocation of resources, at least in a micro level, is necessary. Of course, they still maintain control over the economy, but they let markets figure out of the minutia. The CCP doesn’t need to step in when there’s an overabundance of boba stores.
Isn't this slightly contradictory? I'd think an economy that's planned but which is still flexible at low levels would still qualify as a "planned economy," making it decidedly not impossible, no?
planned economies are a fools errand [...] the CCP [...] let markets figure out the minutia
Isn't this slightly contradictory? I'd think an economy that's planned but which is still flexible at low levels would still qualify as a "planned economy," making it decidedly not impossible, no?
Government intervention in markets doesn't by itself make a country a planned economy. True laissez-faire markets have been out-of-fashion for a century.
Government intervention in markets doesn't by itself make a country a planned economy. True laissez-faire markets have been out-of-fashion for a century.
Offhand armchair analysis thought: Long term, letting the AI financing bubble pop is likely better, as it essentially wipes clean the slate for a more sustainable thing. Much like the dotcom...
Offhand armchair analysis thought: Long term, letting the AI financing bubble pop is likely better, as it essentially wipes clean the slate for a more sustainable thing. Much like the dotcom bubble popping drastically altered the funding landscape for the (at least a little) better.
Looking at it from an even more basic stance - the bigger the bubble gets before popping, the bigger the fallout. For the everyday person, the best time for the bubble to pop is right now. The...
Looking at it from an even more basic stance - the bigger the bubble gets before popping, the bigger the fallout. For the everyday person, the best time for the bubble to pop is right now. The next best time is tomorrow, etc
And in this case, since companies are adjusting their workflows to it, arguably vital. Even if you can automate a certain task with the newest, most impressive models, it's a question on whether...
And in this case, since companies are adjusting their workflows to it, arguably vital. Even if you can automate a certain task with the newest, most impressive models, it's a question on whether they'll remain available at a reasonable price.
Producing something at 0% market price just to spite your geopolitical competition isn't profitable, it turns out. Shocking. If anything, this should give the western AI companies more room to...
Producing something at 0% market price just to spite your geopolitical competition isn't profitable, it turns out. Shocking.
If anything, this should give the western AI companies more room to operate, not less.
Given how Anthropic is about to IPO, I'll just say that this is not an investment advice in any way or form.
Do you have reason to believe that's what was happening with these companies? From the article: [...] I don't think these are exactly China-specific concerns that Anthropic et al can ignore.
Producing something at 0% market price just to spite your geopolitical competition isn't profitable, it turns out. Shocking.
Do you have reason to believe that's what was happening with these companies?
If anything, this should give the western AI companies more room to operate, not less.
From the article:
While global tech stocks teeter, in China they have already crashed as lofty valuations collapse under worries about AI demand and curbs on Chinese exports.
[...]
There has been no obvious selling trigger in China, although traders said high prices, tax bills and the threat of the US or other nations banning Chinese equipment in data centres all contributed.
I don't think these are exactly China-specific concerns that Anthropic et al can ignore.
STAR50 seems hard to compare to the US market for a couple reasons. We think of Anthropic and OpenAI here as the obviously risky options, for one. However they're not in any indexes because they...
STAR50 seems hard to compare to the US market for a couple reasons. We think of Anthropic and OpenAI here as the obviously risky options, for one. However they're not in any indexes because they aren't public, so the parties currently likely to lose money are the rich few rather than the individual investors losing their shirts in China. That's less bad.
On the other hand, if Anthropic goes down, it would have some cascading effects on the publicly traded tech companies which do have a lot of individual investors. However, there's a key difference:
With the STAR50 index still at around 100 times trailing earnings, albeit down from a high of nearly 250, investors compare the Nasdaq 100's multiple of 30 and worry the selloff could get worse before it gets better.
With that, it means that valuations would drop and a bubble would pop, but the bubble appears to be much less inflated over here. Still, STAR50 being not very analogous to the Nasdaq means we should be careful to draw too many conclusions.
From the article:
[...]
[...]
Dumb question by someone mostly uneducated about how Chinese society works, wouldn't the government just step in and dump enough money to correct it?
Edit wouldn’t the government just step in if there were actually a problem worth stepping in for implying, theres no issue here, since they haven’t stepped in. But, idk how it works, this is a broad assumption.
Why would it need to correct it? Not every bubble is 2008. There’s lots of financial bubbles at any point in time. Them bursting is just price discovery in action. It’s the market correcting itself.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with a bubble bursting.
Ever since Deng Xiaoping, the CCP correctly realized that planned economies are a fools errand. It impossible. Market allocation of resources, at least in a micro level, is necessary. Of course, they still maintain control over the economy, but they let markets figure out of the minutia. The CCP doesn’t need to step in when there’s an overabundance of boba stores.
This is minutia.
Isn't this slightly contradictory? I'd think an economy that's planned but which is still flexible at low levels would still qualify as a "planned economy," making it decidedly not impossible, no?
Like everything, it’s a sliding scale, but in general no, that would not qualify as a planned economy.
Government intervention in markets doesn't by itself make a country a planned economy. True laissez-faire markets have been out-of-fashion for a century.
Offhand armchair analysis thought: Long term, letting the AI financing bubble pop is likely better, as it essentially wipes clean the slate for a more sustainable thing. Much like the dotcom bubble popping drastically altered the funding landscape for the (at least a little) better.
Looking at it from an even more basic stance - the bigger the bubble gets before popping, the bigger the fallout. For the everyday person, the best time for the bubble to pop is right now. The next best time is tomorrow, etc
And in this case, since companies are adjusting their workflows to it, arguably vital. Even if you can automate a certain task with the newest, most impressive models, it's a question on whether they'll remain available at a reasonable price.
Producing something at 0% market price just to spite your geopolitical competition isn't profitable, it turns out. Shocking.
If anything, this should give the western AI companies more room to operate, not less.
Given how Anthropic is about to IPO, I'll just say that this is not an investment advice in any way or form.
Do you have reason to believe that's what was happening with these companies?
From the article:
[...]
I don't think these are exactly China-specific concerns that Anthropic et al can ignore.
STAR50 seems hard to compare to the US market for a couple reasons. We think of Anthropic and OpenAI here as the obviously risky options, for one. However they're not in any indexes because they aren't public, so the parties currently likely to lose money are the rich few rather than the individual investors losing their shirts in China. That's less bad.
On the other hand, if Anthropic goes down, it would have some cascading effects on the publicly traded tech companies which do have a lot of individual investors. However, there's a key difference:
With that, it means that valuations would drop and a bubble would pop, but the bubble appears to be much less inflated over here. Still, STAR50 being not very analogous to the Nasdaq means we should be careful to draw too many conclusions.