Clearly the behavior is not changing, only their realization of both the internal and external optics of this process so far. Thankfully I've only ever used free tier things and they've never been...
Clearly the behavior is not changing, only their realization of both the internal and external optics of this process so far. Thankfully I've only ever used free tier things and they've never been a primary provider of any service for me, and I certainly will never become a paying customer and probably migrate what little I have there elsewhere. This isn't Yen's first misstep and certainly won't be his last.
Yep, and for a number of reasons after reviewing that situation it left a bad taste in my mouth, though I did give the benefit of the doubt because it did seem at the time, despite the mishandling...
Yep, and for a number of reasons after reviewing that situation it left a bad taste in my mouth, though I did give the benefit of the doubt because it did seem at the time, despite the mishandling and doubling-down and posting on official accounts- that mostly he was simply being critical (albeit naively so) of policy towards Proton that he viewed the parties as having- and his social media seemed to echo this as he was both positive and critical of various political figures, not sycophantic.
On top of that I already didn't like that they provided some genAI products. So that was another thing that made me uncomfortable. But I get that they were trying to go after a market and position it as a secure/private way of doing so (again something I think is incredibly naive). Another bad sign but one I let slide again.
The original Trump thing was so mishandled and out of touch and just mind-boggling that I didn't feel great about it. Now to go down the road of "mediocrity at speed" and worker hostility and especially as a security/privacy-positioned business and a million other reasons I oppose their embrace of genAI, just clearly shows where they stand. The choice to use genAI internally, and the behavior that has followed from that, are both as much a political statement as anything he said previously, and it's a choice of political position I find unacceptable
I wonder if senior leadership could be replaced by AI at this rate. Proton is one of those companies that could do nothing and win -- since "getting security right" is not rocket science, and...
I wonder if senior leadership could be replaced by AI at this rate. Proton is one of those companies that could do nothing and win -- since "getting security right" is not rocket science, and their competitors are few and far in between -- so incentivizing risky customer acquisition behaviours by promising large incentive packages to C-suite execs who promise to find growth (via launching new features) is the exact opposite of what their existing, profitable, conservative, security-focused customer base would want.
Admittedly I don't use their services, so I could be misreading the target demographic.
Really by their own words not replacing senior leadership with AI is loser thinking. If they want to focus more on being faster, then they need to stop lovingly crafting all their leadership...
Really by their own words not replacing senior leadership with AI is loser thinking. If they want to focus more on being faster, then they need to stop lovingly crafting all their leadership decisions and join the future already. Yen can "reflect on and improve" his communication skills in a role more appropriate for his capabilities then.
I agree with everything but: I think "getting security right" is now harder than ever, with all the AI agents hammering all public services, using (and discovering!) vulnerabilities every day. We...
I agree with everything but: I think "getting security right" is now harder than ever, with all the AI agents hammering all public services, using (and discovering!) vulnerabilities every day. We had more globally relevant vulnerabilities discoveries and hacks in the past month than would appear in 5 years previously.
I think that's part of the reason the proton employees are nervous about quickly pushing out features. And CEO ridiculing the call for pen testing... Well that just goes directly against their primary mission, as perceived by the customers.
Ironically, one HAS to use AI for the defense against attacking bots these days.
From the article: [...] [...] [...] [...] [...] It's good that they're acknowledging the situation rather than denying it but it doesn't look like they're rethinking the actual development...
From the article:
On Friday, Andy Yen, the CEO of Proton, cancelled a series of nearly company-wide ‘re-interviews’ that would have forced employees to explain how they are using AI, with the clear intention that they may be fired if not using it enough in the eyes of Proton leadership, according to six current Proton employees and audio of an around two hour all-hands meeting obtained by 404 Media.
[...]
In one exchange, an employee in the company’s security Slack channel urged Proton to at least take a few days to pentest newly written code before pushing it live. “That’s bullshit and loser thinking. Of course it’s possible to be fast and secure,” Yen wrote in the channel at the end of August. “Stop thinking always of how to be slower, and focus more on how to be faster.” Yen added, “stop lovingly handcrafting all our code and use AI more.”
The re-interview cancellations likely don’t address the concerns of many Proton users, who are more focused on Proton’s deprioritization of security
[...]
“I don’t think he will change anything, and I think the only reason we had this meeting is because he has a rebellion on his hands,” one employee told 404 Media after the all-hands meeting on Friday.
Near the start of the meeting, Yen said, “I want to acknowledge myself, personally, that there was a communication failure on my part and there are many things that probably could and should have been communicated differently, and this is something that I’ll have to reflect on and improve over time. So I will do that.”
“So what does that mean going forward? Going forward, I'm still going to push,” he added.
[...]
After those discussions with leadership and the board, “We’ve decided to actually cancel the re-interviews,” Yen said. “Why? Well, I think actually in a, let’s say, unintentional way, they have actually already served their purpose.” As in, employees are now talking and learning about AI.
[...]
“We fucked up, we know we fucked up,” Butler later said in response to an employee’s comments in the meeting.
[...]
“They have said clearly the direction had not changed. As a Proton user that doesn’t reassure me,” the employee said. “As an employee, the re-interviews weren’t cancelled until this became public despite concerns raised by many of us. I think it goes beyond communication issues and growing pains.”
“Right now, everything seems consistent with it being damage control,” they said.
It's good that they're acknowledging the situation rather than denying it but it doesn't look like they're rethinking the actual development strategies they're pushing for. At least not so far.
Maybe slowing signups and attrition will change their mind. I'm surprised the board isn't pushing harder against this, but then Yen is apparently on the board.
I have such a disconnect with this way of thinking. Why is doing everything as fast as possible a reasonable goal? As a user / consumer, I find constant updates and UI changes obnoxious. Not...
Stop thinking always of how to be slower, and focus more on how to be faster
I have such a disconnect with this way of thinking. Why is doing everything as fast as possible a reasonable goal? As a user / consumer, I find constant updates and UI changes obnoxious. Not saying I want no change ever, but I already find the pace frustrating and it often feels like changes for the sake of changes rather than changes to improve the product or experience.
Feel like companies and CEO's have lost the plot so hard these days that simply treating your customers, workers fairly and shutting up will be a strong signal of trustworthiness going into the...
Feel like companies and CEO's have lost the plot so hard these days that simply treating your customers, workers fairly and shutting up will be a strong signal of trustworthiness going into the future.
Indeed - it feels like another case-in-point about what has become my least favorite symptom/tell of AI psychosis: people imagine that they're going to "use AI" on others to extract value without...
Indeed - it feels like another case-in-point about what has become my least favorite symptom/tell of AI psychosis: people imagine that they're going to "use AI" on others to extract value without being impacted by it themselves. Like the CEO thinks "this guy or that guy is a loser because they're not doing their job 10x faster" but they won't ask themselves "why am I not a 10x better CEO with AI?"
Too late for me, I'm already mid migration onto a different service. This isn't the only reason (they've been weird about crypto and AI for a while now), but this was the last straw for me.
Too late for me, I'm already mid migration onto a different service. This isn't the only reason (they've been weird about crypto and AI for a while now), but this was the last straw for me.
It’s been mentioned in previous threads but I can’t stress enough how important it is you use your own domain for your email addresses. I left proton years ago for fastmail, before I got my own...
It’s been mentioned in previous threads but I can’t stress enough how important it is you use your own domain for your email addresses. I left proton years ago for fastmail, before I got my own domain, and I had to keep proton’s app installed that whole time because I couldn’t keep track of all the places I needed to update my email. I started using my own domain after proton and have been able to move between other email providers without any hassle.
+1 to this for sure. i have done the same. i use fastmail as the base with my own domain(s) on top after leaving gmail, and it's so much better having an email address not tied to a particular...
+1 to this for sure. i have done the same. i use fastmail as the base with my own domain(s) on top after leaving gmail, and it's so much better having an email address not tied to a particular service/company, so no matter what happens with my email providers, i can quickly migrate at anytime and just redirect my domain's mail records to whatever provider i need, without having to go log into my hundreds of online accounts and change my email (which is sometimes impossible or difficult, given not all sites provide a way of modifying this data).
I've already been through that pain once and still have a few accounts stuck on my mostly-unused gmail account. I need to go through another wave of cleanup and try to get the rest off.
i do recommend going with a common/stable TLD (com/net/org/etc) for email domains in particular. while it's not required- there are rare cases of some obscure TLDs being restricted/changed or pulled out from under domain holders in ways that force them to migrate. should be a rarity- just make sure whoever owns the TLD you're getting is a well-established/stable entity
I sent fastmail some feedback/suggestions about their UI layout and just sent me a very friendly response thanking me and stating they registered everything as feature requests. So far so good....
I sent fastmail some feedback/suggestions about their UI layout and just sent me a very friendly response thanking me and stating they registered everything as feature requests. So far so good.
For people considering a migration to a different service as of right now, my process was: Get every account in my keepass database into addresses using domain names I control (except accounts I didn't want to keep), then migrating all alternative addresses away from the old service, and finally keeping an eye on the old service and updating everything/everyone still contacting you through the old service.
I think I've mentioned this before (it was months ago) but surprisingly, it's easier to update your e-mail address on american services (which tend to have well-defined and secure processes for doing so) than in some european services, which are outright violating the GDPR and prone to refusing to let you update at all.
It has been an interesting experience dealing with the byzantine way certain companies use your e-mail address. Here's an e-mail I received yesterday from Microsoft:
The following security info was recently added to the Microsoft account example@fastmail.com
example@fastmail.com
If this was you, then you can safely ignore this email.
That's right, Microsoft requires you to add the same e-mail address to the same account in two distinct ways if you want to use it for logging in...
Clearly the behavior is not changing, only their realization of both the internal and external optics of this process so far. Thankfully I've only ever used free tier things and they've never been a primary provider of any service for me, and I certainly will never become a paying customer and probably migrate what little I have there elsewhere. This isn't Yen's first misstep and certainly won't be his last.
You know, I was recently considering migrating everything to them. Not anymore! I only have an alternate email there, barely used. Easy to move.
Certainly not a first misstep. He publicly praised trump in the past.
Yep, and for a number of reasons after reviewing that situation it left a bad taste in my mouth, though I did give the benefit of the doubt because it did seem at the time, despite the mishandling and doubling-down and posting on official accounts- that mostly he was simply being critical (albeit naively so) of policy towards Proton that he viewed the parties as having- and his social media seemed to echo this as he was both positive and critical of various political figures, not sycophantic.
On top of that I already didn't like that they provided some genAI products. So that was another thing that made me uncomfortable. But I get that they were trying to go after a market and position it as a secure/private way of doing so (again something I think is incredibly naive). Another bad sign but one I let slide again.
The original Trump thing was so mishandled and out of touch and just mind-boggling that I didn't feel great about it. Now to go down the road of "mediocrity at speed" and worker hostility and especially as a security/privacy-positioned business and a million other reasons I oppose their embrace of genAI, just clearly shows where they stand. The choice to use genAI internally, and the behavior that has followed from that, are both as much a political statement as anything he said previously, and it's a choice of political position I find unacceptable
I wonder if senior leadership could be replaced by AI at this rate. Proton is one of those companies that could do nothing and win -- since "getting security right" is not rocket science, and their competitors are few and far in between -- so incentivizing risky customer acquisition behaviours by promising large incentive packages to C-suite execs who promise to find growth (via launching new features) is the exact opposite of what their existing, profitable, conservative, security-focused customer base would want.
Admittedly I don't use their services, so I could be misreading the target demographic.
Really by their own words not replacing senior leadership with AI is loser thinking. If they want to focus more on being faster, then they need to stop lovingly crafting all their leadership decisions and join the future already. Yen can "reflect on and improve" his communication skills in a role more appropriate for his capabilities then.
I agree with everything but: I think "getting security right" is now harder than ever, with all the AI agents hammering all public services, using (and discovering!) vulnerabilities every day. We had more globally relevant vulnerabilities discoveries and hacks in the past month than would appear in 5 years previously.
I think that's part of the reason the proton employees are nervous about quickly pushing out features. And CEO ridiculing the call for pen testing... Well that just goes directly against their primary mission, as perceived by the customers.
Ironically, one HAS to use AI for the defense against attacking bots these days.
From the article:
[...]
[...]
[...]
[...]
[...]
It's good that they're acknowledging the situation rather than denying it but it doesn't look like they're rethinking the actual development strategies they're pushing for. At least not so far.
Maybe slowing signups and attrition will change their mind. I'm surprised the board isn't pushing harder against this, but then Yen is apparently on the board.
I have such a disconnect with this way of thinking. Why is doing everything as fast as possible a reasonable goal? As a user / consumer, I find constant updates and UI changes obnoxious. Not saying I want no change ever, but I already find the pace frustrating and it often feels like changes for the sake of changes rather than changes to improve the product or experience.
From what I have read; Yen is on the board and a majority shareholder.
Feel like companies and CEO's have lost the plot so hard these days that simply treating your customers, workers fairly and shutting up will be a strong signal of trustworthiness going into the future.
Indeed - it feels like another case-in-point about what has become my least favorite symptom/tell of AI psychosis: people imagine that they're going to "use AI" on others to extract value without being impacted by it themselves. Like the CEO thinks "this guy or that guy is a loser because they're not doing their job 10x faster" but they won't ask themselves "why am I not a 10x better CEO with AI?"
Too late for me, I'm already mid migration onto a different service. This isn't the only reason (they've been weird about crypto and AI for a while now), but this was the last straw for me.
It’s been mentioned in previous threads but I can’t stress enough how important it is you use your own domain for your email addresses. I left proton years ago for fastmail, before I got my own domain, and I had to keep proton’s app installed that whole time because I couldn’t keep track of all the places I needed to update my email. I started using my own domain after proton and have been able to move between other email providers without any hassle.
+1 to this for sure. i have done the same. i use fastmail as the base with my own domain(s) on top after leaving gmail, and it's so much better having an email address not tied to a particular service/company, so no matter what happens with my email providers, i can quickly migrate at anytime and just redirect my domain's mail records to whatever provider i need, without having to go log into my hundreds of online accounts and change my email (which is sometimes impossible or difficult, given not all sites provide a way of modifying this data).
I've already been through that pain once and still have a few accounts stuck on my mostly-unused gmail account. I need to go through another wave of cleanup and try to get the rest off.
i do recommend going with a common/stable TLD (com/net/org/etc) for email domains in particular. while it's not required- there are rare cases of some obscure TLDs being restricted/changed or pulled out from under domain holders in ways that force them to migrate. should be a rarity- just make sure whoever owns the TLD you're getting is a well-established/stable entity
I sent fastmail some feedback/suggestions about their UI layout and just sent me a very friendly response thanking me and stating they registered everything as feature requests. So far so good.
For people considering a migration to a different service as of right now, my process was: Get every account in my keepass database into addresses using domain names I control (except accounts I didn't want to keep), then migrating all alternative addresses away from the old service, and finally keeping an eye on the old service and updating everything/everyone still contacting you through the old service.
I think I've mentioned this before (it was months ago) but surprisingly, it's easier to update your e-mail address on american services (which tend to have well-defined and secure processes for doing so) than in some european services, which are outright violating the GDPR and prone to refusing to let you update at all.
It has been an interesting experience dealing with the byzantine way certain companies use your e-mail address. Here's an e-mail I received yesterday from Microsoft:
That's right, Microsoft requires you to add the same e-mail address to the same account in two distinct ways if you want to use it for logging in...