-
13 votes
-
Cameras/software for watching roofs
Lately there's been a rash of people ripping apart AC units on small business' so they can sell them for parts (mostly the copper). Tends to take days to months to discover, and by that time...
Lately there's been a rash of people ripping apart AC units on small business' so they can sell them for parts (mostly the copper). Tends to take days to months to discover, and by that time they're long gone and the police are rarely interested in it (in my experience even when you figure out who's actually buying stolen copper, or car parts....but i digress).
I was asked as a friend to help with this for a couple of small business locations that otherwise don't need normal security. To start it's just one large, 60x300', roof with a couple of units on it. They're willing to spend money, but also don't want to get scammed, so I've been looking into it for them.
They're getting a quote from one of the big security companies like ADT, but didn't feel they were getting it right since they just wanted a camera pointing at the access ladder, when it sure looks like the first time this happened it was someone who brought their own, so they really do need some good coverage and not just one camera pointed at a ladder while they pay for some 24/7 person to stare at the feed.
The rough requirements are:
-
Some decent weatherproofing, as this will be on a roof all day. We can put an enclosure around it but trying to keep this simple.
-
Easy remote access to footage, ideally with notifications that can be setup for things like human motion, or lost connection.
-
Ideally fewer cameras. Not exactly because of cost, but because of the difficulty of getting the power/network up there. Be a lot easier to do one drop in the middle of the roof than say a drop at every corner.
-
Probably not wifi cameras. I figure we need to run power up there anyways, so it might as well be POE if at all possible. Added bonus being that you don't need to worry as much about wifi signal and the rare enterprising criminal with a jammer/scrambler/whatever?
and the tricky one
5. No on site storage. Likely they'll want cloud.My first thoughts:
I have ubiquiti at home, and this seemed fine for it as a nice in-between since they probably need 2-4 POE cameras max (was going to see if i could get away with 2 in the middle of the roof, one looking each way). Was going to mess around and see what level of alerts they give and make them a couple of accounts (basically one alert to the person who'd call the cops and one to the person who'd look at it if the feed went down).The no on site storage thing however, complicates stuff....i think?
The short version is there's no way to do even a basic NVR there (i've been over this thoroughly, and it's more a drama thing than a business thing). I figured that wouldn't be an issue, they'd just have to pay extra for some cloud storage and host it there, and it would probably scale well for them if they liked the solution and rolled it out anywhere else. Rather than having a bunch of NVR's they could just have one cloud based one, neat.
buuuuut it seems ubiquiti doesn't really do that. The people i'm helping are somewhat technical but i'd like to keep this turnkey as possible. I don't think there's any clean/easy way to accomplish this with ubiquiti, or at least that I can find?
In theory I think there might be some clever network way to host the NVR at some other physical/central location (with less drama) and then route all the traffic there, but that's beyond my current ability, and i'm skeptical that even if I learn how, i can keep it simple enough that i'd feel comfortable suggesting it.
The followup research:
So there's huge professional companies like verkanda/axis. I did some basic pricing research and it looks like $2kish, minimum, a year for these things. That might be within their budget (i'm told the damage done was easily into the 5 figure territory), but it also feels like extreme overkill for something that should be easier to solve?Another one i've come across before is Reolink, but I have 0 experience with it and haven't found much in either direction that makes me think it'd be a good solution or a terrible one.
I'm pretty against ring/nest just due to a mixture of "fuck em" and also feeling like you don't get what you pay for.
Overall-
Anyone have any experience or guidance with this sort of thing? I really feel like my own home network/camera setup has me right on the edge of being able to say "ah yeah here's what you need...." and yet i've fallen at the finish line. Is there some easy way to make ubiquiti work (seems to meet all the needs except the cloud storage)? Or some system you're familiar with that does have that feature?
I feel like i bump into these kinds of problems more and more where the options are "make it a second hobby/job" or "pay through the nose" when it feels like there should be a reasonable inbetween.
12 votes -
-
Careless people. This is not your father’s book review.
26 votes -
Elon Musk says xAI has acquired X in deal that values social media site at $33 billion
23 votes -
Swedish fashion retailer H&M will use AI doppelgangers in some social media posts and marketing in the place of humans, if given permission by models
10 votes -
Amid calls for sovereign EU tech stack, Swedish startup Evroc raises $55M in Series A funding to build a hyperscale cloud in Europe
30 votes -
Google claims news is worthless to its ad business after test involving 1% of search results in eight EU markets
23 votes -
Discord in early talks about IPO
44 votes -
A Reykjavík building that houses a penis museum and an H&M is also the virtual home to an array of perpetrators of identity theft, ransomware and disinformation
14 votes -
Microsoft reported to be sharply reducing planned data center investment worldwide
30 votes -
Myanmar scam compounds that enslave workers apparently use Starlink for net access. US law enforcement says no company response to request for help.
26 votes -
MIT’s new AI-powered tool accelerates startup ambitions
6 votes -
Meta admits Instagram Reels featured violence, porn in graphic error
23 votes -
HP ditches mandatory fifteen-minute wait time policy due to 'feedback'
45 votes -
Meredith Whittaker said Signal intends to exit Sweden should its government amend existing legislation essentially mandating the end of end-to-end encryption
26 votes -
Automattic hit with class action over WP Engine dispute, accused of anti-competitive tactics
14 votes -
Planned foreign-owned data centres in Finland will bring minimal economic benefit, according to Jukka Manner, professor of networking technology at Aalto University
4 votes -
Apple to invest $500 billion in the US in the next four years, build AI server factory
12 votes -
The birth and glory of Swedish computers
7 votes -
Norway's 1X is building a humanoid robot – Neo Gamma is a prototype designed for testing in the home environment
4 votes -
Reddit will lock some content behind a paywall this year, CEO says
90 votes -
Dating app cover-up: How Tinder, Hinge, and their corporate owner keep rape under wraps
39 votes -
reCAPTCHA: 819 million hours of wasted human time and billions of dollars in Google profits
57 votes -
Nokia announces ex-Intel AI and data centre boss Justin Hotard as new CEO – company attempting to venture into artificial intelligence market as 5G sales fall
7 votes -
What is China’s DeepSeek and why is it freaking out the AI world?
47 votes -
Amazon to close Quebec facilities, insists it's not because of new union
57 votes -
TikTok is coming back online after US President-elect Donald Trump pledged to restore it
27 votes -
US Supreme Court unanimously backs law banning TikTok if it’s not sold by its Chinese parent company
48 votes -
Read.cv and Posts sold to Perplexity; will be closed soon
11 votes -
TSMC may have approval to create 2nm chips in the US
24 votes -
US introduces additional export restrictions on AI-chips
14 votes -
Candy Crush, Tinder, MyFitnessPal: See the thousands of apps hijacked to spy on your location
65 votes -
Mark Zuckerberg defends Meta's latest pivot in three-hour Joe Rogan interview
24 votes -
TikTok says it plans to shut down site for US unless Supreme Court strikes down law forcing it to sell
38 votes -
Tencent designated as a Chinese military company by US
29 votes -
Meta is ending its fact-checking program in favor of a 'community notes' system similar to X
40 votes -
Amazon’s latest seller squeeze - Amazon changes terms of compensation for lost third party inventory
22 votes -
Sweden's green industry hopes hit by Northvolt woes – growing calls for increased state support to help Sweden maintain its position in future technologies
12 votes -
Copyright abuse is getting Luigi Mangione merch removed from the internet – artists, merch sellers, and journalists making and posting Luigi media have become the targets of bogus DMCA claims
65 votes -
BuzzFeed sold 'Hot Ones' studio for $82.5 million to consortium including First We Feast's founder, host Sean Evans, Crooked Media, Mythical Entertainment, and Soros Fund Management.
15 votes -
Chatbots urged teen to self-harm, suggested murdering parents, Texas lawsuit says
24 votes -
Norwegian payment service Vipps becomes world's first company to launch competing tap-to-pay solution to Apple Pay on iPhone – follows agreement with European regulators
17 votes -
Intel CEO Pat Gelsinger forced out by board frustrated with slow progress
26 votes -
Mozilla begs courts to allow Google search deal for Firefox to continue
59 votes -
CrowdStrike avoids customer exodus after triggering global IT outage
24 votes -
Elon Musk asks court to block OpenAI from converting to a for-profit corporation
13 votes -
OpenAI, Google and Anthropic are struggling to build more advanced AI
34 votes -
Chegg is on its last legs after ChatGPT sent its stock down 99%
35 votes -
TSMC will stop making 7nm chips for Chinese customers
13 votes -
Reddit is profitable for the first time ever, with nearly 100 million daily users
51 votes