41 votes

I wanted to make friends in a new city — so I hosted five strangers for dinner

20 comments

  1. KodaLeFaye
    Link
    This reminds me of a program that my pastor instituted at my old church. Instead of stuffy old Bible studies, prayer meetings, and all the usual jazz that churches get into, he encouraged people...

    This reminds me of a program that my pastor instituted at my old church.

    Instead of stuffy old Bible studies, prayer meetings, and all the usual jazz that churches get into, he encouraged people to do something like this - host a dinner. That's it. No evangelizing, no religious talk, and don't even pray before the meal. Just invite people you don't know into your home and host a meal. We did it at first with just church members who we didn't know but some people eventually expanded it to their neighborhood.

    His theory was that one of the biggest shortcomings of modern Christianity is that when Christians get together, there's always an agenda. He wanted instead to focus on building relationship both within and outside the church. It wasn't even about getting non-Christians to come to church; it was simply about being a good neighbor and a good person overall. He felt that we could do a lot more good in the world if we moved away from all the trappings of modern Christianity - missions, street evangelism, church programs, etc. - and spent more time building genuine relationships with other people without any kind of an agenda.

    85 votes
  2. [5]
    Eabryt
    Link
    I was prepared to make some joke about how "this sounds like my nightmare!" before reading, but after I found myself thinking about how fantastic this is. I'm male, so wouldn't qualify anyway, but...

    I was prepared to make some joke about how "this sounds like my nightmare!" before reading, but after I found myself thinking about how fantastic this is.

    I'm male, so wouldn't qualify anyway, but my wife and I are planning on moving to a different state in the near future. It will be close to family, but neither of us will have friends in the area and I could see something like this being a good way to meet people.

    18 votes
    1. [4]
      boxer_dogs_dance
      Link Parent
      I recently read a decently informative book, We Should Get Together by Kat Vellos. I think the author was right that making friends as an adult is especially challenging today as compared to the...

      I recently read a decently informative book, We Should Get Together by Kat Vellos. I think the author was right that making friends as an adult is especially challenging today as compared to the past. Her attempts and proposed strategies made me think and I stole some tips, including some decent 'get to know you' questions that I wouldn't have thought of.

      Best of luck with the move.

      12 votes
      1. [2]
        catahoula_leopard
        Link Parent
        I'm also a fan of reading books about friendship, I feel like it's one of the more useful "self-help" style topics. In our society we have a fairly rigid, defined way that we collectively...

        I'm also a fan of reading books about friendship, I feel like it's one of the more useful "self-help" style topics. In our society we have a fairly rigid, defined way that we collectively understand romantic relationships and agree on how they're supposed to work, but when it comes to friendships it sometimes feels like the wild west.

        I like Shasta Nelson's books about friendship. They're written for and marketed towards women, but I sort of wish they weren't, because I feel like the concepts can be applied by anyone. I like that she has one book about making friends, and another about deepening those friendships, since I feel like the second part is where many people tend to struggle.

        2 votes
      2. amerikiwi
        Link Parent
        Love the recommendation! My partner and I have been finding it really challenging as we've been in our current city for several years, but the cost of living has pushed a lot of our friends out of...

        Love the recommendation! My partner and I have been finding it really challenging as we've been in our current city for several years, but the cost of living has pushed a lot of our friends out of the city and even overseas.

  3. NaraVara
    Link
    There actually used to be a service (that sold to Foursquare and went defunct) called GrubWithUs that was basically this. A host registers to do a dinner at a restaurant. Everyone buys a ticket...

    There actually used to be a service (that sold to Foursquare and went defunct) called GrubWithUs that was basically this. A host registers to do a dinner at a restaurant. Everyone buys a ticket and lists restrictions the restaurant does a fixed price menu for the ticket price. Each person was responsible for their own drinks.

    I attended several such dinners and cohosted one with a friend I made through the service. It was a great way to meet people in a new city as well as try new restaurants. I still keep in vague touch with some of them via Facebook. It was also one of the few ways I ever found to make new friends that didn’t have the odd pressure that structured socializing things often do where there is maybe kinda some pressure hovering over things that maybe you’ll meet a romantic partner so everyone has a bit of a guard up. It felt more low key.

    15 votes
  4. [4]
    Spongey
    Link
    I absolutely love the idea of this. As I was reading I was so excited to see there was a platform to help set these dinner parties up and was considering hosting. Then in the next sentence I was...

    I absolutely love the idea of this. As I was reading I was so excited to see there was a platform to help set these dinner parties up and was considering hosting. Then in the next sentence I was sad to see it was limited to women. Is anyone aware of something like this for men or coed groups? The other services linked in the article don't really seem to be the same thing.

    11 votes
    1. Eabryt
      Link Parent
      Sounds like a gap in the market that someone more enterprising than me would be able to exploit!

      Sounds like a gap in the market that someone more enterprising than me would be able to exploit!

      7 votes
    2. [2]
      Very_Bad_Janet
      Link Parent
      I think the article has links to other similar groups (they don't mention gender).

      I think the article has links to other similar groups (they don't mention gender).

      1. Spongey
        Link Parent
        Unfortunately the links look like they're mostly at actual restaurants in New york or around Boston instead of at somebodies home. Still a neat idea but halfway across the country for me.

        Unfortunately the links look like they're mostly at actual restaurants in New york or around Boston instead of at somebodies home. Still a neat idea but halfway across the country for me.

        1 vote
  5. lou
    (edited )
    Link
    A friend of mine did that on New Year's Eve about 20 years ago. Nervous, weird, interesting energy. One guest left the bathroom with some cocaine still at the tip of his nose -- not my scene, but...

    A friend of mine did that on New Year's Eve about 20 years ago. Nervous, weird, interesting energy. One guest left the bathroom with some cocaine still at the tip of his nose -- not my scene, but so random. We were young, so we laughed and forgot about it.

    I watched Monty Python and the Holy Grail for the first time during the sunrise surrounded by people I barely knew. It was awesome. Two people that met there eventually got married. They are now divorced, but it was like a real, long relationship.

    Good times.

    8 votes
  6. Maelstrom
    Link
    I have anxiety just thinking about this!

    I have anxiety just thinking about this!

    5 votes
  7. Qgel
    Link
    In the city I lived previously, there was this regular event you could register for, and they would match 3 pairs of people together. You would then meet up at the first pairs place, eat a starter...

    In the city I lived previously, there was this regular event you could register for, and they would match 3 pairs of people together. You would then meet up at the first pairs place, eat a starter they prepared, move to the second pair for the main and the third for a dessert. That worked pretty well to meet new people. The matches were based on dietary restrictions/preferences and walk-able distance between households.

    I once helped out for a special one of these just before a local election where one 'pair' would be a politician. I think that was a great concept for people to get a chance at a more 1-to-1 conversation in a somewhat casual setting than you might otherwise get during an election campaign.

    5 votes
  8. [2]
    PossiblyBipedal
    Link
    Before I read the article, I was skeptical. But then I realised I've sort of done something similar. I used to organise small drawing hangouts where strangers, mainly artists, would come together...

    Before I read the article, I was skeptical.

    But then I realised I've sort of done something similar. I used to organise small drawing hangouts where strangers, mainly artists, would come together to doodle and chat in a cafe. It was an easy way to make friends.

    It helped that everyone had a common hobby to talk about.

    But I think a dinner at your home probably feels more intimate and makes it easier to open up.

    5 votes
    1. Very_Bad_Janet
      Link Parent
      This sounds so nice! You could host one again, maybe this time as an artists' hang at brunch at your home, rather than at a cafe.

      This sounds so nice! You could host one again, maybe this time as an artists' hang at brunch at your home, rather than at a cafe.

      2 votes
  9. Finnalin
    Link
    There was a YouTube channel that did something similar. I can't remember the name. But they'd go door to door and ask if they could cook for them. If they said yes then they'd buy all the...

    There was a YouTube channel that did something similar. I can't remember the name. But they'd go door to door and ask if they could cook for them. If they said yes then they'd buy all the groceries, do all the cooking and cleaning and ask the hosts to invite some friends over. It was super wholesome

    Edit: discover connection is the channel I believe

    3 votes
  10. [3]
    Good_Apollo
    (edited )
    Link
    This seems like one of those things that only works for a certain demographic. Looking through some of the tables available, I feel I'm right. I was about to suggest something like this to my wife...

    This seems like one of those things that only works for a certain demographic.

    Looking through some of the tables available, I feel I'm right. I was about to suggest something like this to my wife who is currently feeling the pains of growing older and losing friends, plus we just moved. None of these people seem like they would cater to her personality though.

    Influencers hosting lavish gluten-free menus seeking high-end conversations around founder-style careers and indie creativity...a small window indeed and quite intimidating. I imagine my wife showing up asking "You guys like video games and Sailor Moon?" and getting blank stares.

    1 vote
    1. honzabe
      Link Parent
      I don't know... but I think people sometimes underestimate how little is needed to make friends when people are open to it - and if you go to this kind of a dinner, you are open to it. I will give...

      You guys like video games and Sailor Moon

      I don't know... but I think people sometimes underestimate how little is needed to make friends when people are open to it - and if you go to this kind of a dinner, you are open to it. I will give you myself as an example. I do not play video games and I have no idea what Sailor Moon is but I would happily tell your wife about that one time I tried a video game and spent two weeks totally hooked on Duke Nukem 3D and I would ask what Sailor Moon is and I would listen with genuine curiosity what it is that she finds interesting about it.

      3 votes
    2. Very_Bad_Janet
      Link Parent
      She should host. I'd bet she'd be inundated with requests from gamers and anime fans, or just down to earth people who aren't looking for fodder for their IG feeds.

      She should host. I'd bet she'd be inundated with requests from gamers and anime fans, or just down to earth people who aren't looking for fodder for their IG feeds.

      2 votes