-
23 votes
-
How Donald Trump won, and how Kamala Harris lost
19 votes -
Thoughts on a Democratic postmortem
So Trump won. Next few years are gonna be rough, I know. What happened, and where can the Dems go from here? James Carville said it best: It’s the economy, stupid (even if he predicted the wrong...
So Trump won. Next few years are gonna be rough, I know. What happened, and where can the Dems go from here?
James Carville said it best: It’s the economy, stupid (even if he predicted the wrong candidate). Inflation was a big concern among voters, mostly driven by gas, groceries, and housing. Rightly or wrongly, many voters tied this to Biden, and through him to Harris. They viewed Trump as being likelier to fix things, with a big bold plan (tariffs, deportations, tax cuts). I suspect some (many?) voters wanted to punish Dems for inflation. Others probably thought Harris would worsen it. While she had a long proposal, she didn’t seem to talk about it much, nor boil it down to soundbites. Many of the demos that swung were hit hard by the price increases.
We saw swings among Latinos, young voters, and rural voters toward Trump. Some of this was due to depressed D turnout (Harris got 15 million fewer votes than Biden), but in other cases it was due to genuine swings. Starr County, TX went Republican for the first time in decades. New Jersey only went for Harris by single digit percentages. Black voters had a small 2% decline of the share of the electorate.
I think non-immigration identity politics played a smaller role. I do think Harris/Walz could’ve talked more about men’s issues specifically (suicide, the academic gap, poor job prospects), although they are hard to soundbiteify and not sound forced. They likely could've approached it from a universalist angle. Trans issues might’ve driven some voters to Trump, but I believe it was more localized (e.g., reduced margins in Loudoun County). Latinos likely weren’t particularly turned off of Trump because they aren’t a cohesive bloc, and in many cases not even the same race (you’ve got whites, indigenous, blacks, mixed, even Asian Latinos). Between the countries the cultures can be very different, to the point of each country hating the other. They can be more socially conservative as well, especially those in their 40s and older.
Immigration was definitely a bigger issue, dovetailing with economic issues (housing costs, “why are migrants getting help but not me”, homelessness). The migrant bussing by Gov. Abbott will be viewed as one of the greatest political maneuvers of the 21st century. It brought the issue to voters outside of border states. The number of people coming to the border was frustrating/scary for some voters.
Abortion didn’t play as big of a role, I suspect because many women don’t think they’ll need one, or because they don’t view care that legally may qualify as one.
The state of democracy didn’t motivate enough people for the Dems, in fact, some people who thought it was important voted for Trump.
Foreign policy didn’t play much of a role, although Israel/Palestine probably was significant in Michigan. But that needle would’ve been hard to thread for any candidate, and probably would’ve been less of a problem if other points were addressed.
I think the fact that Harris is a biracial woman did reduce votes, but I don’t think it was necessarily decisive in her losing. The right woman can definitely win (Thatcher won the U.K. in 1979, so it should be possible in the U.S. in 2024). I would probably hold off in 2028, but I don’t see an issue with running women long-term.
So, what are the takeaways for Dems?
-
Suburban white-collar voters are not the end-all be-all. They are a good bloc to have (reliable voters in many swing states, including in off-years), but they are not enough to outweigh the others.
-
You cannot take minority demographics for granted. They will not stay with you forever. They are not monolithic.
-
Social policy can only go so far. Its salience can be quite limited compared to the economy. Negatives can be very negative, white positives may be “meh”.
-
Running against someone, rather than for yourself only works so many times.
-
You can only have so many issues stacked against you and be able to win. If it was just the economy, it might’ve been closer, but you had the economy, and immigration, and social policy, and Israel/Palestine.
-
The average voter does not account for lag in terms of policy. Trump got credit for a good economy even though Obama did a lot of the work.
-
Places that are or have been “safe” are not guaranteed to stay like that forever, especially when paired with point 2, without work.
-
NatCon populism is here to stay. The combination of left-ish economics and social conservativism, propelled by apathetics and the hard right is a winning one, and needs to be countered accordingly.
-
Many folks view Democrats as being the “mom” or “Karen from HR” party. That is not the kind of reputation that wins elections.
-
It’s the economy, stupid.
Based on that, what would my strategy be for Dems in 2026/2028?
-
Clean house. The folks in charge lost 2024 and only barely won 2020. Care needs to be taken to ensure replacements have sufficient political/management experience.
-
Don’t be the party of why/if. Be the party of do. The former implies insecurity, the latter confidence.
-
Bring back the 50-state strategy. Open offices in rural areas. States viewed as safely blue came awfully close to flipping for Trump this year. But the reverse can also be true, especially with a good candidate (cf. Indiana in 2008 ). And even if the presidential candidate loses, downballot candidates can still win, especially in off-years. I think the Dems had a good ground game, and while it cannot make up for everything else, it’s usually better to have it than not. Local elections matter a lot because they have stronger day-to-day impact, and they are the breeding ground for future politicians. North Carolina had several good Dem victories.
-
Focus on economics. Moderate suburbanites aren’t enough to win on, and many people like Trumponomics. Go for smart tariffs, universal policies (e.g., Child Tax Credit, universal Medicare, etc), targeted tax cuts and increases along with tax code simplification, and one other oddball policy (withdrawal from the WTO? Annual gas tax holiday?) likely to be popular with voters.
-
Social moderation/tolerance. The party is a big tent one, and there’s going to be friction over social issues. This doesn’t mean abandoning core constituencies, but being smarter about rhetoric and candidates (you won’t win the Georgia governorship with an Everytown candidate). Candidates should be allowed to have differing views on social policy (especially if it is personal and doesn’t extend to the political realm), and there should be a mechanism to allow dissent on an issue an individual is out of touch on. Related: get the loudest social progressives away from the party. They frequently clash with it but manage to tie the party to an unpopular viewpoint with something they said on Xitter/Tik Tok. I did like the initial message of freedom the Harris campaign was putting out, but it didn’t seem to be used much.
-
Turnout still matters. You need to be able to turn out more people for you than the other guy.
-
(My weird, hot take-ish view) Go on an offensive cyber campaign. You’ve got Russian operatives shilling for Trump and the GOP. Hack them. Make it so they can’t just continuously pump out disinfo. Even a few million should be enough to establish a unit dedicated to fucking up Russian troll farms.
-
(Courtesy of @EgoEimi) Go for the reality TV angle. Lots of rallies, some political stunts, and bring loads of energy.
One final thought: Trump is a sui generis candidate. He energizes people who aren’t into politics normally. Thus far, the GOP hasn’t been able to translate that into off-year elections or non-Trump POTUS candidates. Nobody wants diet Trump, they want the real deal. When he passes away, it remains to be seen whether someone (Vance?) can take over with the same level of success.
78 votes -
-
Donald Trump didn't win on the US economy. He won on the perception of it.
37 votes -
Why US Democrats won't build their own Joe Rogan
30 votes -
2024 United States election megathread
Post any/all news and discussion related to the US Election here. If there is something substantially newsworthy, feel free to post it as a separate topic. This will be a noisy topic. Please use...
Post any/all news and discussion related to the US Election here.
If there is something substantially newsworthy, feel free to post it as a separate topic.
This will be a noisy topic. Please use the
ignore
feature if you do not want to see it in your feed.If you need something to occupy your mind so you stop refreshing this and other news sites, check out our Distractions Thread.
Election Dashboards:
97 votes -
Jeff Bezos vetoed Washington Post plan to endorse Kamala Harris, paper reports
86 votes -
They ran for US President. What did they learn? (original from 2004)
7 votes -
Devin James Stone (Legal Eagle) presents his legal reasoning for public endorsing Kamala Harris
32 votes -
Donald Trump and the Joe Biden White House both say the United States should have a sovereign wealth fund – Norway, home to the world's largest, may offer a few lessons
21 votes -
These five tumultuous years in Montreal shaped Kamala Harris
20 votes -
California just passed the Freelancer Worker Protection Act (SB 988)
17 votes -
How Joe Biden's National Labor Relations Board has boosted bottom-up unionism in the US (and why this matters)
30 votes -
Teamsters won’t endorse a candidate for US President in 2024
23 votes -
Kamala Harris’ lead dips in national US polls and it’s very close in the key states
28 votes -
Thinking out loud: A US service to help you move to where your vote will count the most
Maybe this topic is silly, but I am up from insomnia, so here it goes. I watched a piece on the news about how the election may come down to teeny tiny little town in Nebraska. I remember a...
Maybe this topic is silly, but I am up from insomnia, so here it goes.
I watched a piece on the news about how the election may come down to teeny tiny little town in Nebraska. I remember a similar situation coming to pass in the 2020 election.
There are many teleworkers now. Many of them are IT people who would be happy anywhere there is a good Internet connection.
I was thinking that a movement to get people to move to where their votes would count the most would be interesting. At least to talk about.
There could be a web site/app that would identify the potential most crucial areas, like that little Nebraska town.
Nomadic and patriotic teleworkers could then move to such places a year in advance of an election, vote, and move on if they aren't happy in those places.
16 votes -
Donald Trump vs Kamala Harris: Who is leading in the US presidential election polls?
35 votes -
Trusted aide would likely play key role in Kamala Harris review of US-Israel policy
11 votes -
Kamala Harris plans to tax unrealized US stock gains — but only for people worth $100 million
51 votes -
Kamala Harris's speech killed any hope she would end the Gaza genocide
22 votes -
Kamala Harris names Tim Walz, the Minnesota governor, as running mate
131 votes -
Former US President Donald Trump backs out of ABC debate, says he will only debate Kamala Harris on Fox
65 votes -
Girl, so confusing: Will the “Brat” memes help or hurt Kamala Harris?
22 votes -
Governor Gavin Newsom orders homeless sweeps throughout California
38 votes -
The cynic and the two nations: Twenty years since Barack Obama assured us we're the *United* States of America, a new country has been building with fearful momentum. Can anything be done to stop it?
11 votes -
Kamala Harris lacks charisma and time
31 votes -
Jessica Valenti (Abortion, Every Day) summarizing Kamala Harris' position on abortion rights
18 votes -
How Kamala Harris rose as a California moderate
15 votes -
The roads to replacing Joe Biden
10 votes -
Joe Biden calls Volodymyr Zelensky 'Putin' right before huge press conference
41 votes -
Bernie Sanders: Joe Biden for US President
41 votes -
US history shows swapping candidates is a losing game for Democrats
32 votes -
Donald Trump is a de-facto incumbent US President ("Why I think Joe Biden decided to run again (and why he can’t really talk about it)")
29 votes -
Joe Biden's path to US re-election has all but vanished
23 votes -
After Joe Biden's debate performance, the US presidential race is unchanged
20 votes -
What are the most effective ways to help get Joe Biden re-elected in the US?
So I'm kind of terrified by recent political news. What can I do to help? Options include: Donating Phone banking Text banking Postcarding Door knocking Volunteering as an election worker Does...
So I'm kind of terrified by recent political news. What can I do to help?
Options include:
- Donating
- Phone banking
- Text banking
- Postcarding
- Door knocking
- Volunteering as an election worker
Does anyone have an informed opinion about which of these will actually move the needle and which ones just make you feel like you're doing something?
48 votes -
"Radical, in a different vein": The "Abundants" and supply-side progressives
17 votes -
After a shaky debate performance top US Democrats talk about replacing Joe Biden on the ticket
90 votes -
Illinois Democrats speedily change candidate law; Republicans call measure ‘election interference,' "undemocratic"
16 votes -
US drug control agency will move to reclassify marijuana in a historic shift, AP sources say
75 votes -
US House Democratic leaders say they would help save Speaker Mike Johnson's job
16 votes -
Historian Avi Shlaim: ‘I remain hopeful Israel will start to act rationally’
2 votes -
Do US voters care about policy even a little?
31 votes -
Democrats go on offense as IVF leaves Republicans vulnerable
25 votes -
American politics is undergoing a racial realignment – Democrats are rapidly losing non-white voters as the forces that ensured their support weaken
31 votes -
Why Joe Biden matters
26 votes -
Joe Biden’s chances of US re-election are better than they appear
34 votes -
US President Joe Biden pardons thousands on federal marijuana charges, commutes others
79 votes -
House Democrats call on US Justice Clarence Thomas to recuse from Donald Trump 2020 election case
27 votes -
Explainer: Joe Biden 2024: His record so far on the US economy, immigration, civil rights
12 votes