33 votes

Hyundai Ioniq 5N or: welcome back Forester XT

There are plenty of video reviews of this car out there from people who do it for a living, but I'm not a car influencer or anything like that, I'm just an enthusiast who bought this car with my own money and wanted to give some real impressions for other enthusiasts out there.

Long ago Subaru made a Forester XT that was more or less a de-tuned STI engine in a compact SUV and it was AWESOME. I had an 04 XT that was turbo-swapped, with race exhaust, it was a very quick car and other than getting terrible gas mileage, burning oil, and eventually imploding the transfer shaft in the transmission, it was pretty great. In the ensuing years Subaru pulled out of WRC, killed the STI, and stopped putting turbos on everything (shame). While the hot hatch market has kept up to an extent, the crossover/smaller SUV performance market more or less died entirely.

Fast forward to 2023, I purchase a new Ioniq 5 to replace our BMW 3 series before our kiddo is born, since it's easier to get the car seat in and out etc with a higher vehicle(if it'd have even fit in the 3 series at all). And it's.....great, they are awesome cars, and changing to an EV was not a big deal at all, we mostly charge at home, but the overall build quality of the Ioniq 5 is really quite good, and it's a well put together car, there's a reason it's won many awards since release, outside of the ICCU roulette(which nobody seems to know whether you will or won't be affected, we haven't, knock on wood).

As things go, at some point I start wanting another enthusiast vehicle, my friends and family have stayed car people the whole time, and there's only so much envy you can have when you see Corvettes, 911s, etc, fast is fun. Well Hyundai releases the Ioniq 5N, the legally distinct M5 Estate, the Great Value Urus. And I happen to find one for a good price, and with another kid on the way, I really still can't have a 2 door sports car, it needs to fit a car seat(or two) and well, if having one of a car is good, having two of a car must be....gooder?

I don't need to tell you about all the weird quirks etc about the 5N, every single youtube video goes over this, it's pointless to rehash. What you need to know: holy fuck this car is fast, if you have been in fast cars, or hot hatches, or supercharged trucks, or tuned builds, I assure you it is likely faster. Over 600hp with minimal losses and a single gear transmission, AWD, and large summer tires will do that. The only car faster I've regularly driven is a 992.1 Turbo S, which is a stupid fast car that it's wild they sell to the general public, but those cost $250k, this costs $68k (or the aforementioned ICCU issues, there is quite a few lemons for far less, and those have pushed the clean titled, low mileage used down as well) so you can very easily pick up a 600hp, practical hatchback, for around 50k or less if you want a buyback. That is an absolutely, tremendously insane value. And yes, we all know EVs are fast, but the suspension setup, the grippy tires, and the additional chassis work they did makes it suspiciously capable to cornering, it corners better than many sports cars stock, which should not happen in a 4800lb SUV, wtf.

So then: is the 5N worth it over the normal 5? If you do not want an enthusiast vehicle, no it's not. Especially in the US market, the 5N loses amenities that it gets in other markets, or that are on the Limited trim of the base version: no HUD (Boo), no heated rear seats or sunshades (Boo) and no sunroof option(idc). The Limited trim seats are also much more comfortable for long drives, and you have the relax/recline function for charging stations. The 5N bucket seats are perfectly comfortable, they are actually great for the car, but I had to drive the car back 250miles and it was fine, but it would have been better in the default seats. Other downsides: the range is TRASH, expect 200miles at full charge max, 10% of battery buys you 20miles, the car is on fatter, larger wheels, with lots of additional cooling for performance, and you WILL want to drive it like a lunatic because the car BEGS you to. I wouldn't recommend this car as a first performance vehicle for someone, it's just too fast. Nobody should go from a normal car to a car that runs an 11.1 quarter mile bone stock.

On all the N options: I basically never use the e-shift, I don't care, I like not having gears, it's what you'd want in any car if you could get away with it. Shifting is vestigial, and while I can understand coming from manuals, people like the sensation, it's kind of fun, but I like going fast, and I want the cars full power as much as possible, but it's there if you want it. I really like the N-Pedal, I absolutely adore one pedal driving, and while I usually use the max default regen, the N-Pedal cranks that even more, and a quirk is that, because it's intended for track use, N-Pedal won't bring you to a complete stop the way that max regen in default will, I wish they'd change that honestly. Dynamics wise, this car has a rear power bias, and if you make a turn and punch the gas you WILL kick the ass out, especially in N mode(which is basically how I have the car every time I drive it, with everything in Sport+ except ESC in sport not off, and suspension in normal (sport+ suspension is harsh)) so it is far livelier than any other EV with big HP and accel numbers out there. And while again, it is not light at 4800lbs, considering the new M5 weighs nearly 6000, there's no shortage of large and heavy performance vehicles these days.

So yeah, I've had the car for several months now, and really enjoy it, and wanted to share my own opinions with you all, for the price to performance ratio of this car is truly, truly stupid, and you're not sacrificing practicality for it. One of the first things I did was throw a car seat in the back, and it's got enough boot space to put my kid's huge wagon+anything else. You really can't buy anything at all comparable for less than double or triple the price. Downside is that there simply isn't that many 5Ns that were allocated to dealers, and at the beginning they were charging over MSRP for them because they could. AND there's no telling that the ICCU may or may not fail, and it'll brick your car if it's not fixed, so that's a downside, that said, going back to the title of this whole post, my Suburu XT also exploded it's transmission and couldn't drive anywhere afterwards either, at least the ICCU is under warranty for a while, and I went through I think 3-4 high pressure fuel pumps on my first gen 335i, too.

We don't have a ~cars area, so hopefully hobbies is the right place, cheers.

25 comments

  1. PraiseTheSoup
    Link
    Thanks for the review. I hope someday I'm in a situation where I can buy a fun car like this. It sounds like an absolute blast and I want an EV so bad, but I can't even test drive a basic one...

    Thanks for the review. I hope someday I'm in a situation where I can buy a fun car like this. It sounds like an absolute blast and I want an EV so bad, but I can't even test drive a basic one within a couple hundred miles.

    4 votes
  2. [8]
    lelio
    (edited )
    Link
    I have an EV6 with dual motors. Its plenty fast for my family car. my family groans in pain from the G-force if I floor it. I cant imagine shaving 2 seconds off the 0-60. I briefly considered...

    I have an EV6 with dual motors. Its plenty fast for my family car. my family groans in pain from the G-force if I floor it. I cant imagine shaving 2 seconds off the 0-60. I briefly considered trying to get the GT, but I'm fine with what I got.

    The ev6 will also oversteer and fishtail if you turn off traction control. It really drives great. I'm either in one pedal/sport mode or radar cruise.
    We had the ICCU replaced a year or two ago under warranty, it just stopped accepting AC charges one day. it took a week but we got a loaner, not too bad.

    My pre family car history includes an AWD Talon and SRT-4 so i come from a similar place :). We had a Mazda 3 for awhile. I love a good wagon.

    4 votes
    1. [3]
      Mullin
      Link Parent
      It's crazy how Kia/Hyundai have really turned things around isn't it? And yeah, I wish there were more wagons out there, they are just very practical. Growing up I mostly drove sedans, but...

      It's crazy how Kia/Hyundai have really turned things around isn't it? And yeah, I wish there were more wagons out there, they are just very practical. Growing up I mostly drove sedans, but hatchbacks are just much more practical and you get more interior room for your passengers, many a sedan, even as they've grown now, doesn't have as much headroom in the rear, especially if it's fastback style. The back seats in the Taycan are notoriously bad iirc, and the cross turismo(the body style I'd like) only makes it marginally better. And that's before you get to the price tag :x

      2 votes
      1. [2]
        moonwalker
        Link Parent
        Unfortunately their customer service is trash. As reported here but I've also personally experienced their review process taking months

        Unfortunately their customer service is trash. As reported here but I've also personally experienced their review process taking months

        2 votes
        1. Mullin
          Link Parent
          Yeah the ICCU issue is a pita, they also for whatever reason tend to eat the 12v batteries, but the time it happened in my wife's 5 they fixed it same day.

          Yeah the ICCU issue is a pita, they also for whatever reason tend to eat the 12v batteries, but the time it happened in my wife's 5 they fixed it same day.

          1 vote
    2. [4]
      updawg
      Link Parent
      I'm confused. I know there are fast EV6s but the 5 N only does 0-60 in 3.25 sec. That's only marginally faster than the fastest EV6. Are you looking at where the Kia site claims 5.0 sec for the...

      I have an EV6 with dual motors. Its plenty fast for my family car. my family groans in pain from the G-force if I floor it. I cant imagine shaving 2 seconds off the 0-60

      I'm confused. I know there are fast EV6s but the 5 N only does 0-60 in 3.25 sec. That's only marginally faster than the fastest EV6. Are you looking at where the Kia site claims 5.0 sec for the EV6? Because they have been clocked at less than 3 sec in the real world.

      1 vote
      1. Mullin
        Link Parent
        They were saying they have the AWD non-GT spec. Yeah the EV6 GT is reasonably close to the 5N in straight line acceleration, afaik the 5N handles considerably better though, and personally I...

        They were saying they have the AWD non-GT spec. Yeah the EV6 GT is reasonably close to the 5N in straight line acceleration, afaik the 5N handles considerably better though, and personally I didn't like either of the EV6 exterior or interior styling. Still the same platform though so I'm sure they are solid vehicles

        2 votes
      2. [2]
        lelio
        Link Parent
        I have a regular dual motor 2023 EV6 . its around 300hp. 200 on the rear motor and 100 on the front. I've assumed it does 0-60 in 5.0 since thats what Ive read, never tested. There is a much...

        I have a regular dual motor 2023 EV6 . its around 300hp. 200 on the rear motor and 100 on the front. I've assumed it does 0-60 in 5.0 since thats what Ive read, never tested. There is a much faster "GT" EV6 that i think is close to the 5N spec.

        1 vote
        1. updawg
          Link Parent
          They're both listed by Kia as 5.0 but they're realistically more like 3.4 and 4.4. Maybe even faster for each (I know the GT AWD has been clocked under 3 sec and the Wind AWD has been clocked at...

          They're both listed by Kia as 5.0 but they're realistically more like 3.4 and 4.4. Maybe even faster for each (I know the GT AWD has been clocked under 3 sec and the Wind AWD has been clocked at 4.2 sec).

  3. [2]
    artvandelay
    Link
    Funnily enough, I was just thinking earlier today it'd be nice to have a place to discuss cars. Someone moved it to under ~transport which makes more sense to me, especially with the automobiles...

    Funnily enough, I was just thinking earlier today it'd be nice to have a place to discuss cars. Someone moved it to under ~transport which makes more sense to me, especially with the automobiles tag.

    Cool review on the 5N. As someone who drives a manual, I completely understand where you're coming from. Manuals are fun, I like being in control, but sometimes I want to have fun without having to worry about changing gears. I really like what Hyundai are doing with their N lineup, they're really rowdy and really do let you be really stupid when you want but can also button down and be sorta normal. I'm glad that energy has not been lost when translating the N formula to electric. Going through the downsides, I didn't realize the 5N had range that bad, but I guess it makes sense given the sportier wheels/tires. no HUD and no rear sunshades is a bit of a bummer too. It's a little wild to me just how much performance EVs have, especially in a straight line and it seems like they're improving dynamically at a rapid pace too.

    3 votes
    1. Mullin
      Link Parent
      Yeah, it's definitely one of those things where, they seriously put an investment in making the car track capable, up to and including thermal management, that, plus the wheels, really harms the...

      Yeah, it's definitely one of those things where, they seriously put an investment in making the car track capable, up to and including thermal management, that, plus the wheels, really harms the range. Our other Ioniq 5 is RWD only, and regularly shows over 300miles of range at full charger. I really don't drive that far, my longest drives are usually 50 miles across town and back, so it's not a huge issue, and I do NOT wish the car to be even heavier, which it would be with a larger battery. I won't touch a Tesla, so their performance models were not a consideration, but the Porsche EVs and the Audis and frankly, even Volvo are making some really capable vehicles that aren't just a straight line dragster

      3 votes
  4. [8]
    TheDarkerZone
    Link
    Thank you for the timely review - currently have a 2012 2.0 TSI Octavia VRS facelift, and if you know anything about cars, you'll know these engines are just as capable as they are problematic....

    Thank you for the timely review - currently have a 2012 2.0 TSI Octavia VRS facelift, and if you know anything about cars, you'll know these engines are just as capable as they are problematic. Touch wood, I've had nothing but relatively smooth sailing over the 60k miles i've put on the clock (~112k total), but I'm itching to upgrade and relegate this to a project car.
    Anyway, the i5N is on my shortlist as i have solar panels and a battery on the house already, and nothing gets me giddier as a tech-nerd petrol head than being able to scoot around silently and pay virtually nothing to do so (aside from general maintenance and outgoings for the solar pv and car). What colour did you go for in the end? And whats your opinion on the abundance of settings and tinkering that can be done through the i5N infotainment?

    3 votes
    1. [7]
      Mullin
      Link Parent
      I ended up with white, and it's grown on me, but I'd really have preferred the orange, just couldn't find one for the right price. I also think the matte grey looks really good, too. I love all...

      I ended up with white, and it's grown on me, but I'd really have preferred the orange, just couldn't find one for the right price. I also think the matte grey looks really good, too. I love all the settings, I'm someone who likes fiddly things in general, so being able to adjust the engine, battery, stability control, traction control, N pedal, launch control, track and drag modes, sprint modes..... there's a lot, but none of them feel gimmicky, or well, the ones that feel gimmicky like e-shift are implemented incredibly well so it doesn't feel like no care or thoughts went into them. It's a car you can just drive a different way if you feel like it. Not to mention that you can just punch it normally, or press the NGB for full power, or any other number of things. I haven't tried the drift mode or torque distribution much but it's got that too, plus a LSD in the rear. It is a serious driver's and track focused car, in an insanely affordable package and with insane power.

      I get that at MSRP, people were hesitant to pay 68k for a Ioniq 5, it still has a lot of interior trim from a vehicle 30k cheaper, but the numbers don't lie and it's still a value if you want this type of car. An RS3 would run you similar price and you'd be in a slower vehicle that's gas only. And personally I get concerned having owned a high strung turbo about the longevity of high strung turbo engines. I have zero qualms driving the 5N hard since I know the car can do it all day, I'm not worried about the clutches or transmission or gunning it with a cold engine and causing unnecessary wear etc etc etc.

      I will say, I don't think people really recognize this car, or appreciate it the way they would any flavor of 911, if you go to a cars and coffee, don't expect to get waved into the fancy section, they will put the 50th base Carrera in front of you, but for me as someone who built a sleeper, I don't mind too much. And it's kind of cool to own the fastest car that Hyundai has ever produced (we'll see if the 6N is appreciably quicker but they are the same platform, same power etc, so doesn't bother me any, and I like the 5 aesthetic WAY more). And it's funny that there are likely more of the mass market Ferraris like the 296 then there are 5Ns, it's truly that rare, I haven't seen another one on the road period, whereas I see lambos and even McLarens just driving around here.

      There are low mileage, certified pre-owned 5Ns scattered about with full+extra manufacturer warranty in the high 40s, fully 20k off MSRP, if you find one, I wouldn't hesitate to snap it up.

      3 votes
      1. [4]
        mysterylevel
        (edited )
        Link Parent
        https://www.trademe.co.nz/a/motors/cars/hyundai/ioniq-5/listing/5758889273 It's definitely a cool car and I love the look compared to other EVs, but it's hard to stomach used pricing in NZ.

        https://www.trademe.co.nz/a/motors/cars/hyundai/ioniq-5/listing/5758889273

        It's definitely a cool car and I love the look compared to other EVs, but it's hard to stomach used pricing in NZ.

        1 vote
        1. CptBluebear
          Link Parent
          Ha, I was looking them up as well just to see if that "high 40s" was remotely possible in my market and they're easily €70k+ second-hand. Some auto markets are just broken I suppose.

          Ha, I was looking them up as well just to see if that "high 40s" was remotely possible in my market and they're easily €70k+ second-hand. Some auto markets are just broken I suppose.

          2 votes
        2. [2]
          Mullin
          Link Parent
          Oof yeah sorry, I'm coming from a US perspective, that still seems like under MSRP if I convert it to USD though, not sure what the starting MSRP was in NZ, but hey, at least you get the HUD and...

          Oof yeah sorry, I'm coming from a US perspective, that still seems like under MSRP if I convert it to USD though, not sure what the starting MSRP was in NZ, but hey, at least you get the HUD and sunshades in your market if that's a consolation!

          1 vote
          1. mysterylevel
            Link Parent
            Unfortunately the charging network is also pretty bad for me where I live. No government assistance for EV or solar in my home either, just "better" rates from the bank for specific, approved...

            Unfortunately the charging network is also pretty bad for me where I live. No government assistance for EV or solar in my home either, just "better" rates from the bank for specific, approved installations.

      2. [2]
        TheDarkerZone
        Link Parent
        Totally agree with you on the grey, and am a big fan of the white too. I hadn't noticed a price difference between orange and the other colours but that's something I'll keep in mind. It sounds...

        Totally agree with you on the grey, and am a big fan of the white too. I hadn't noticed a price difference between orange and the other colours but that's something I'll keep in mind.
        It sounds like a tinkerers dream honestly and I'm glad to hear you're happy with the abundance of features that many reviewers suggest is overwhelming.

        I appreciate the sleeper aspect of it too, and would be perfectly fine at a cars and coffee pitched out the way of all 20 flavours of Porsche, Supra and 3 Series.

        Thanks for getting back to me and maybe I'll be able to nab a decent pre-owned when the 6N gets released here in the UK!

        1 vote
        1. Mullin
          Link Parent
          Sorry, I more meant that with the low inventory, there wasn't an Orange near me that wasn't marked up or more than I was willing to spend, it's not that the color itself cost more, these cars are...

          Sorry, I more meant that with the low inventory, there wasn't an Orange near me that wasn't marked up or more than I was willing to spend, it's not that the color itself cost more, these cars are very much, dealers have one or zero, or at most two available, it's not like normal cars where you can pick your color at any given dealership. When we got my wife's car, we had to go out of town to find a dealer that wasn't overcharging, and for this car as well, I had to drive over 200miles for it, I rented a car, drove, bought the car, dropped off the rental, and drove it back lol.

          1 vote
  5. [6]
    Narry
    Link
    Thank you for that very thorough review. It brought to mind old memories from when I was a kid, and my uncle would take us out in his muscle car to tool around on the winding backroads around...

    Thank you for that very thorough review. It brought to mind old memories from when I was a kid, and my uncle would take us out in his muscle car to tool around on the winding backroads around Central Missouri where he lived. I don’t remember the exact make and model of his car, but I wanna say it was some sort of Chevy knowing him. This was in the 80’s and 90’s, but his car was from the 60’s or 70’s before seatbelts were required, and car seats were for babies only.

    He would kick its ass out around corners on gravel roads and fishtail it to give us a little bit of a thrill. I think if he could’ve gotten away with it he would have demonstrated the PIT maneuver (yes, forcing cars off the road: he was a cop in the 70s). Because the area that he lived in was so hilly, the way that he took the crests of the hills literally felt like being on a roller coaster ride, with the heavy feeling of being pressed back in the seat as he accelerated and the almost weightless feeling on the drop. I hit the same roads some years later in a V6 Mercury Cougar but it just didn’t feel the same. I suspect it was the traction control and stabilization features that blunted the sensation.

    Kind of makes me wonder if the 5N could bring back that old feeling.

    2 votes
    1. [5]
      vord
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      Safety features are awesome and all, but they suck all the joy out of many things. I want a 'I know what the fuck I'm doing' button buried somewhere which will let me perform some of my 'get out...

      I suspect it was the traction control and stabilization features that blunted the sensation.

      Safety features are awesome and all, but they suck all the joy out of many things.

      I want a 'I know what the fuck I'm doing' button buried somewhere which will let me perform some of my 'get out of the snow' maneuvers without having a seizure and getting me more stuck.

      3 votes
      1. Mullin
        Link Parent
        The 5N at least will let you fully turn off traction control as well as stability control if you want to, so it's perfectly content to let you spin out, it's nice that the car has a lot of "tech"...

        The 5N at least will let you fully turn off traction control as well as stability control if you want to, so it's perfectly content to let you spin out, it's nice that the car has a lot of "tech" features like the E-shift combined with enthusiast "turn all the nanny's off". Best of both worlds

        2 votes
      2. [3]
        Narry
        Link Parent
        That would be nice. Let me swap back and forth between 2-wheel and 4-wheel driving, and let me rebalance the vehicle and pick if it's FWD or RWD or 4WD. I also want every vehicle to have that one...

        That would be nice. Let me swap back and forth between 2-wheel and 4-wheel driving, and let me rebalance the vehicle and pick if it's FWD or RWD or 4WD. I also want every vehicle to have that one "crab walk" feature from... I think it was GMC? Did Hummer do it first or am I misremembering a video I half paid attention to while sleep deprived some years ago? Hmm.

        2 votes
        1. [2]
          vord
          Link Parent
          Being able to swap between fwd and rwd would not only be cool, but also could help with tire wear.

          Being able to swap between fwd and rwd would not only be cool, but also could help with tire wear.

          2 votes
          1. Mullin
            Link Parent
            the 5N has torque distribution, which because the two motors aren't connected, really just lowers the power on one or the other, so it'll let you go 100% front or rear, but you'll have less power...

            the 5N has torque distribution, which because the two motors aren't connected, really just lowers the power on one or the other, so it'll let you go 100% front or rear, but you'll have less power as a result. I'm almost positive that "Eco" mode also disconnects the front motor.

            1 vote