10 votes

Google Assistant shutting down on Android and Wear OS in September

8 comments

  1. Eji1700
    Link
    I know at least one person who was using this, but they only use it for things like "dim the lights". They're going to be looking into switching to home assistant over the weekend. Of all the tech...

    I know at least one person who was using this, but they only use it for things like "dim the lights". They're going to be looking into switching to home assistant over the weekend.

    Of all the tech out there, i do find these...well...recording devices just sitting in your living room the most insidious. Even if they aren't doing anything with them yet, the concept is just so so dangerous, and YES i'm not thrilled about my phone/tv/monitor doing it either.

    8 votes
  2. Carrow
    Link
    Dang, I use it frequently, usually like quickly setting timers while I'm doing chores/cooking, setting a route in maps while getting to my car, etc. It only pops up if I long hold home so it...

    Dang, I use it frequently, usually like quickly setting timers while I'm doing chores/cooking, setting a route in maps while getting to my car, etc. It only pops up if I long hold home so it doesn't feel invasive or start randomly.

    When Gemini launched and replaced it, it just told me how to do these things (incorrectly I might add) when prompted to do them, so I swapped back to the functional app.

    I didn't get the email though, my phone no longer receives updates, I wonder if that means I'm grandfathered in like android auto cars are?

    4 votes
  3. [4]
    dhcrazy333
    Link
    I got this email today. I've been avoiding Gemini as much as possible but it's looking like it's finally going to be time to swap to iOS or install Graphene OS onto my Pixel.

    I got this email today. I've been avoiding Gemini as much as possible but it's looking like it's finally going to be time to swap to iOS or install Graphene OS onto my Pixel.

    3 votes
    1. [3]
      Englerdy
      Link Parent
      You can always just disable the digital assistant. I've never used Bixby, Google Assistant, or Gemini on my phones. I just go through and disable and lock them out (hasn't been too hard to find...

      You can always just disable the digital assistant. I've never used Bixby, Google Assistant, or Gemini on my phones. I just go through and disable and lock them out (hasn't been too hard to find the right settings) because I find the assistants to intrude at weird times. I'm sure it's not fully shut down, but shut down enough. I've never found their integration into the phone to be useful for how I'd want to use them.

      4 votes
      1. [2]
        dhcrazy333
        Link Parent
        To be fair I rarely use the assistant as is with the exception of setting timers or asking about what the weather will be tomorrow, but I've found the assistant is quite useful when paired with...

        To be fair I rarely use the assistant as is with the exception of setting timers or asking about what the weather will be tomorrow, but I've found the assistant is quite useful when paired with Android Auto while I'm driving, especially if I'm trying to ask for directions or search up a song on Spotify hands free.

        Maybe I'm misunderstanding how it works but I thought those functions would require the Assistant to perform that function. I had all sorts of Android Auto issues when it was using Gemini originally before I figured out how to disable Gemini and have it switch back to the old Google Assistant.

        4 votes
        1. Englerdy
          Link Parent
          That's a good point, I forgot about that. I have my digital assistant set to Firefox right now (which doesn't do anything, so it's a nice placeholder in that respect), but realized a couple months...

          That's a good point, I forgot about that. I have my digital assistant set to Firefox right now (which doesn't do anything, so it's a nice placeholder in that respect), but realized a couple months ago that I could no longer use voice commands while driving. I haven't had time to tinker and figure out how to expose the limited amount of functionality to use voice with Android Auto without having the full assistant enabled. I thought I had it working on my S10 (changed to a Xcover Pro 7 at the new year), and haven't had as much time to mess with it.

          Maybe it's no longer as easy to mostly lock out the assistant except for when using Android Auto. I haven't really looked into Graphene (other than knowing it exists), but does it have its own agent? Can't imagine Gemini is super compatible with what the project is trying to accomplish.

          2 votes
  4. [2]
    moonwalker
    Link
    What happens to all the little speaker things? Isn't that what those operate on? Didn't seem to be mentioned in the article

    What happens to all the little speaker things? Isn't that what those operate on? Didn't seem to be mentioned in the article

    1. dhcrazy333
      Link Parent
      In the email I got it said the following: So based on that it sounds like smart speakers still will be on assistant for the moment but they have separate plans to switch them over.

      In the email I got it said the following:

      These changes are only for the assistant experience on your mobile device and accessories that pair to your phone, like watches, headphones, and car infotainment systems.You can also read more about our separate plans to bring Gemini to Google TV devices
      and Google Home speakers and smart displays.

      So based on that it sounds like smart speakers still will be on assistant for the moment but they have separate plans to switch them over.