31
votes
Good domain registrars?
Looking to pick up a domain name for a personal site and was wondering if anyone could recommend a good registrar. The whole domain name industry always feels more than a bit shady, so I'm wary of most of the providers.
Back during the SOPA fiasco I remember GoDaddy was in favor of the law. Presumably because the main anti-piracy mechanism the law proposed would be domain name take-downs. Once your domain's taken down you'll need to buy a new one to keep operating, so GoDaddy was certainly on board.
Namecheap on the other hand opposed the bill. They also were the first major registrar to accept Bitcoin back in one of the old hype waves. I don't know if their record is spotless but they've earned my business.
Many many years ago, I experienced a case of domain name front running by GoDaddy. I used their site to search for the availability of a domain, which was available but I didn't register it. I hadn't spoken about the domain to anyone, and it was an improbable combination of words unlikely to arise randomly. It existed only in my head, and the GoDaddy WHOIS search. The very next day it was unavailable, and a landing page informed me that I could buy it from the new owners for an exorbitant fee.
Sure enough, I did nothing and after the five-day "trial period" elapsed the domain was available again. I never used GoDaddy again after that. Registrars flatly deny front running domains but it's undeniably what happened in my situation. It made my blood boil. In those days we didn't have a name for it, and it still lives in the realm of conjecture today; I have no idea if GoDaddy's still up to these shenanigans now but I don't care to find out. Whenever I'm curious about a domain name now it's strictly CLI for me.
Do you just ping or traceroute a domain to see if it's available, or is there some other CLI tool you use?
The
whois
command is what you need. Ping will tell you whether a server behind the domain is online and responding, but it won't tell you who/if anyone currently owns it.whois
on the other hand digs into the registration information.Generally just
whois
. Sometimes I'lldig
if I'm curious to know more.I use namecheap for domains. To be fair, I honestly don't keep track of the domain registrar industry besides 10 minutes every year to refresh them, but nothing bad, or good I guess, has really happened in the past 4 years. Which is what you want from a domain registrar, I guess.
I'm waiting for Drew DeVault to launch his registrar.
He has been teasing it as a part of source hut for about 3-4 months and even though I'm not entirely sure it's not somehow tied into it exclusively - ie, can't use the domains if not attached to custom source hut installations - I can hope it's not.
Looks like we're in the same boat! I bought my domain, cosmo.red, from Gandi before transferring it to Cloudflare. Once names.sr.ht launches, I think I'll finally be able to settle down for good.
I didn't know he was working on a registrar. I'll have to check it out too, when it launches.
I've used Gandi in the past though not currently. Not the cheapest but reliable, established and trustworthy in my experience.
I have personally not used Gandi, but I think their recent fiasco with losing customer data was handled very poorly by them [1].
Gandi is fantastic for one reason: They seamlessly allow you to register pretty much every single TLD, no matter the crazy requirements. I don't know of a single TLD they don't support.
You'd think it wouldn't matter that much, that most registrars will do most of the common TLDs, but… not so. I've used .com/.net/.org but also .ch, .us, .gr, .info and .gg. Most registrars lack support for one or the other (for example, Google Domains doesn't support .ch).
I wanted to make a Czech joke here, but
.ch
is a Swiss goddamn TLD. :(Gandi is great for some domains that require you to be a citizen of that country. This used to be the case with .es and others. Back when I was getting my first .es, they were one of only a handful of providers who could manage this.
I also use Gandi. They're solid.
I use NearlyFreeSpeech for hosting, they do registering too. I like them. It turns out they're a little more expensive but I already use them for hosting so. If you do that (and they're a great deal on hosting) I'd recommend.
+1 for NearlyFreeSpeech for hosting. I haven't had a single issue with them, I trust them immensely, and I appreciate that all of their documentation treats you like a knowledgeable user, not a baby—this probably puts a lot of people off, but I love it. (NFS's hosting also handled a recent gigantic traffic spike on one of my sites without so much of a stutter on their end.)
I don't have experience with them as a domain registrar, though—they're reselling through an external vendor while they're trying to set up their own registrar services.
I didn't know that about the registrar thing, thanks for the info. At this point with the domains I have I think the transfer cost would be more than it's worth, but it's good to keep in mind for future domains.
I used GoDaddy in the past, since it seemed cheaper, but found them a bit unpleasant, and the price is lower only for the first year, usually. Now I use Hover, haven't had a problem yet.
I use Njalla to register and manage my personal domains. It was founded by one of The Pirate Bay founders, Peter Sunde, and here's what he had to say:
Of course, since it promises anonymity there are some questionable users and the Njalla blog is full of the same childish humor that TPB used to have. Therefore, one may want to avoid Njalla for its profile-raising nature.
Oh my god that blog page is too funny. Especially the NYtimes one.
I use DynaDot. They seem to be pretty reasonable and not affiliated with shady practices (last I checked). There's also Google Domains. Google may be shady, but probably not in the domain registrar business.
I have about four domains (I tend to cycle through a variety of silly names depending on what's cheap at the time) through Namecheap and they've never messed me about. They also mask your WHOIS information by default which is nice
I moved recently to Cloudflare. They guarantee your renewal price will be at cost. You get the added benefit of all the free Cloudflare services for your domain. I'm also fairly confident that Cloudflare does domain security better than most registrars, given their existing business and talent pool.
I really like Porkbun.com. The pricing is almost always the best, free whois privacy, etc. I've got about four or five domains with them.
Also, https://tld-list.com is handy. NameSilo and some other common ones are so sketchy these days.
I used to use google domains, but they recently changed their UI and now I find it unusable. Namecheap and porkbun are both fine. Stay away from godaddy and gandi.
Used Namecheap for a long time. Now I use Cloudflare.
I've been using Pair Domains for decades and remain a very happy customer. Good feature set, reasonable prices, easy self-management tools, and on the rare occasions when I've needed customer service their response has been fast, friendly, and on-point.
I use domain.com . I don't know if they're good but they're probably better than godaddy...
I use hover.com—the stereotypical podcast domain registrar. They did help me port in most of my domains without issue, years ago, and I just continue to buy silly domains with them all the time. They're probably not the best value, but also probably aren't that far off. I do think they have some of the best coverage in the new TLD space, though.
I previously used joker but a few years ago changed over to namecheap. I also use baremetal for my
.ca
domains.I am wanting to register a
.rs
domain, so if anybody has any experience with such a registrar, I’d appreciate some advice!I've been satisfied using joker.com for over 20 years since seeing it recommended by DNS & infosec expert Daniel J. Bernstein (djb).
I’ve been very happy with iwantmyname.com - they have an awesome search interface that I use all the time (searches all tld’s at once) and a simple/elegant admin panel. I’ve only had to interact with their support once, but they were fast, friendly, and helpful.
👍👍 will buy from them again.
I use a combination of Amazon and Rebel. I've had no problems with either.