46 votes

Google’s ad policy changes to allow device fingerprinting

11 comments

  1. [2]
    X08
    Link
    A reminder to use adblockers not just to remove seemingly inescapable ads but also the whole data harvesting that comes from it. Even bigger step is to not use Google products and services at all....

    A reminder to use adblockers not just to remove seemingly inescapable ads but also the whole data harvesting that comes from it.

    Even bigger step is to not use Google products and services at all. But I'll be quickly reminded that other brands are also doing the exact same thing just maybe to a lesser extend.

    https://www.privacyguides.org/en/

    25 votes
    1. NoblePath
      Link Parent
      Adblockers aren’t enough tonstop fingerprinting though, right? You have to use a browser that reports only generic or null information to the requestor. Which means no javascript, and not even...

      Adblockers aren’t enough tonstop fingerprinting though, right? You have to use a browser that reports only generic or null information to the requestor.

      Which means no javascript, and not even slashdot looks ok without javascript these days.

      10 votes
  2. [3]
    elfpie
    Link
    I believe this is a relevant test for those who want to start understand the issue better. You'll see all the information you don't realize is being used and would never think of hiding....

    I believe this is a relevant test for those who want to start understand the issue better. You'll see all the information you don't realize is being used and would never think of hiding.

    https://coveryourtracks.eff.org/

    10 votes
    1. [2]
      Minori
      Link Parent
      I had no idea about the HTML5 Canvas fingerprinting! I think of myself as semi-privacy conscious with UBlock and Privacy Badger on Firefox, but there's apparently a huge amount of possible data...

      I had no idea about the HTML5 Canvas fingerprinting! I think of myself as semi-privacy conscious with UBlock and Privacy Badger on Firefox, but there's apparently a huge amount of possible data for fingerprinting...

      2 votes
      1. tauon
        Link Parent
        Yeah, my web-browser-adtech wordview got shattered quite a bit when I ran the Am I Unique test and found out I had a literally one of one unique profile (and 1 in like 1.8k for another browser...

        Yeah, my web-browser-adtech wordview got shattered quite a bit when I ran the Am I Unique test and found out I had a literally one of one unique profile (and 1 in like 1.8k for another browser instance)…

  3. skybrian
    Link
    I’m wondering how often advertisers violated this policy before. How would Google find out if advertisers were using fingerprinting? Did Google do anything to enforce it?

    I’m wondering how often advertisers violated this policy before. How would Google find out if advertisers were using fingerprinting? Did Google do anything to enforce it?

    8 votes
  4. [5]
    kingofsnake
    Link
    I'm blindly hoping that PrivacyBadger is doing all things behind the scenes since it regularly breaks my Firefox browser's access to some sites on mobile. I'm out of the loop on alternatives to...

    I'm blindly hoping that PrivacyBadger is doing all things behind the scenes since it regularly breaks my Firefox browser's access to some sites on mobile.

    I'm out of the loop on alternatives to Google's pre-installed OS on my phones. Is Lineage Android still a thing? Does anyone know whether it has privacy in mind at the OS level?

    8 votes
    1. [4]
      mild_takes
      Link Parent
      It sounds like Lineage is a little more focused on supporting more devices. GrapheneOS is the far more ...paranoid... option but only supports a limited set of devices, only the Google Pixel...

      It sounds like Lineage is a little more focused on supporting more devices. GrapheneOS is the far more ...paranoid... option but only supports a limited set of devices, only the Google Pixel phones and not once they get too old.

      IMO if you have a Pixel then do Graphene. Just be aware that it's totally stripped out: no calendar, no email client, no Google Play store, no Android auto... just the absolute basics plus a web browser. You can install the Google Play store and most other Google services/apps, you could just use your phone as only a phone + the web browser, or do something in between.

      9 votes
      1. kingofsnake
        Link Parent
        That is for the advice - that's great. I'm not at the point where I'd make the switch yet, but it's nice to know that there are options.

        That is for the advice - that's great. I'm not at the point where I'd make the switch yet, but it's nice to know that there are options.

        2 votes
      2. [2]
        kjw
        Link Parent
        Somewhere in between GrapheneOS and LinegageOS lies DivestOS, which afaik is a LOS fork focused on security, hence deblobbed, with many privacy and security features, degoogled with smooth monthly...

        Somewhere in between GrapheneOS and LinegageOS lies DivestOS, which afaik is a LOS fork focused on security, hence deblobbed, with many privacy and security features, degoogled with smooth monthly upgrades. Worth looking at in my opinion: https://divestos.org/
        It contains Mull web browser:

        Mull is a browser based on Mozilla technology that is hardened against fingerprinting techniques thanks to the Tor uplift project and arkenfox-user.js project.

        1 vote
        1. jamfox
          Link Parent
          Can confirm that DivestOS was a wonderful option (kept my OP 5T alive for quite a while), but unfortunately it was recently discontinued.

          Can confirm that DivestOS was a wonderful option (kept my OP 5T alive for quite a while), but unfortunately it was recently discontinued.

          5 votes