Also report about Ireland and Estonia supermarkets: link Seems like hybrid warfare of some kind?
Supermarket chains in Sweden, Belgium and Luxembourg have said the temperatures of their refrigerators and freezers in dozens of stores rose overnight, prompting fears of a cyber-attack similar to one that caused millions of euros of food losses in France.
Also report about Ireland and Estonia supermarkets: link
This is what I thought initially, but it seems simply the case of default username/password (Supervisor/12345) and internet connected devices. I'm not kidding with that password. It looks like...
This is what I thought initially, but it seems simply the case of default username/password (Supervisor/12345) and internet connected devices. I'm not kidding with that password. It looks like scanning for these devices, I bet Shodan can easily list them, then trying default creds. I was reading Danfoss is the maker. So in essence nothing new, much like internet connected printers being abused by script kiddies.
Don’t be fooled. Script kiddies aren’t behind this. Seriously; I’m extremely involved in countering Russian attacks and regardless of how shit security is, it’s still Russia behind it. We can...
Don’t be fooled. Script kiddies aren’t behind this.
Seriously; I’m extremely involved in countering Russian attacks and regardless of how shit security is, it’s still Russia behind it.
We can blame poor security all we want, it still takes a criminal to break in, even if the key was simple.
I’m not convinced. This type of thing has happened so many times before and if I was still in high school and heard about this, I might have logged in somewhere to take a look. This is not...
I’m not convinced. This type of thing has happened so many times before and if I was still in high school and heard about this, I might have logged in somewhere to take a look. This is not hacking, it’s just looking for devices with no protection. Just like shared printers, security cameras, raspberry pi’s, etc. that had similar issues.
Since it’s so easy to break into, care to log in and send me a screenshot? I don’t think you understand europe is at war and we’re the constant target of hybrid attacks by a foreign enemy. I’m...
Since it’s so easy to break into, care to log in and send me a screenshot?
I don’t think you understand europe is at war and we’re the constant target of hybrid attacks by a foreign enemy. I’m quite sick of people not understanding this and pretending the situation is ok. It’s not ok and you can be convinced as much as you want, I am telling you now: I am actively involved in this, it’s Russians, there’s no pretending it’s not. That’s the facts. I understand in your world theoretically it could be someone else, but it’s not, and from my perspective, any denying of this gets into “jet fuel can’t melt steel beams” territory.
Asking me to log in myself to prove something is a strange request, because it's illegal and I'm a grown man with grownup responsibilities. But you don't need to take my word for it, Previdian...
Asking me to log in myself to prove something is a strange request, because it's illegal and I'm a grown man with grownup responsibilities. But you don't need to take my word for it, Previdian reported login attempts with default username password at the same time these 'hacks' happened. This doesn't scream hacking mastermind; this is known weakness that's suddenly exploited a number of times in a few weeks. These companies could have, I don't know, listened to all the reports and just pulled these devices off the internet like any sane person would do. Instead, they've chosen to not do anything. Shocked pikachu face, someone exploited it and messed their shit up. Expensive mistake to make.
Being at war with whoever and not providing any proof of their involvement in this hack is a weak argument. Just like saying you are actively involved in something without providing any information to what your involvement is exactly. Then resorting to namecalling ("jet fuel bla bla") is also a weak argument.
If you want to add something substantial to the discussion, I'm all ears. But until then, I'm not sure we're getting anywhere with this.
Here, it’s becoming a bit more public now. https://swedenherald.com/article/pro-russian-hacker-groups-claim-responsibility-for-attacks-on-refrigeration-systems-across-europe And I really hope you...
Sigh I’m sorry man but you’re parroting Russian talking points. At what point is the burden of proof on me rather than on the country attacking Europe and Ukraine constantly for years? Again I...
Sigh
I’m sorry man but you’re parroting Russian talking points. At what point is the burden of proof on me rather than on the country attacking Europe and Ukraine constantly for years?
Again I didn’t say the security of these systems was good. I said the attackers were Russians. These are facts backed by two things: 1. Plain logic on incentives, 2. Forensic data you will not have access to. Sorry, best I can do is promise you this shit is real (and yes I have quite a bit of authority on the subject at this point).
You want bad security? The lock on my front door is basically useless, very easy to pick. And yet, if my house gets broken into, I don’t blame “script kiddies”, I file a police report on the burglars that have been going through the entire neighbourhood.
The security of my house is irrelevant to it being robbed. It’s only relevant to it being robbed successfully.
Of course not. I don't exactly understand what you are trying to achieve here, but it looks like you are paving the road for "plausible" deniability of the responsibility of our enemy. back off.
Of course not. I don't exactly understand what you are trying to achieve here, but it looks like you are paving the road for "plausible" deniability of the responsibility of our enemy. back off.
I'm trying to have a meaningful discussion, is what I'm trying to achieve here. I'm not paving a road, I'm trying to objectively look at the story and understand how this could happen. Immediately...
I'm trying to have a meaningful discussion, is what I'm trying to achieve here. I'm not paving a road, I'm trying to objectively look at the story and understand how this could happen. Immediately screaming "it's still fucking Russians" doesn't really fall in the "understand how this could happen" section. At the moment, I see more proof it is non-existent security and just a massive fuck up by these stores, than proof that's it the Russians.
Just like I wrote in response to Adys: if you want to add something substantial to the discussion, I'm all ears.
Look, you ARE trying to posit this case is not clear and that the enemy is not attacking us. You are hiding it behind pretend rigor and asking for proof. You are out of the loop, yet you take...
Look, you ARE trying to posit this case is not clear and that the enemy is not attacking us. You are hiding it behind pretend rigor and asking for proof. You are out of the loop, yet you take position benefitting the enemy. That's really all there is to it - think about who you are benefitting with your actions.
Whatever your aims and stated motivations are, you are actively helping russians with this - helping them in public opinion at least. Normally, they need to pay the troll farms to do this - you do it for free.
This is the same as when they shot down a civilian plane at the start of the war, more than 11 years ago, killing hundreds of Europeans - and useful idiots were "just asking" - "were those really russians?" "The bullet marks on the plane debris don't look russian to me" etc.
This case isn't clear-cut. (In case it needs to be said, Russia is a failing state whose leadership is engaged in an unprovoked war of aggression in which they have committed and continue to...
This case isn't clear-cut.
(In case it needs to be said, Russia is a failing state whose leadership is engaged in an unprovoked war of aggression in which they have committed and continue to commit numerous war crimes.)
The freezers in question are horrifically insecure. This is a fact about which there's absolutely no question; they exposed a management interface with trivial default credentials (IIRC based on the date), and were open to the Internet so literally anyone could credential-stuff until they broke in and then "manage" them.
We don't have any evidence (at least, not that I've seen) about who broke into these freezers. Russian state hackers are definitely on the differential! But again, the level of sophistication required here was negligible. "Bored British teenager" is also on the differential, and we have no shortage of proven cases of bored British teenagers engaging in exactly this sort of activity. Aside from questioning why in the absolute fuck every operator didn't yank their freezers off the open Internet the instant news of the last hack broke, we should reserve judgement until we have actual evidence to base it on. The appropriate reaction to Russian hackers attacking the food supply chain of other countries is very different from the appropriate reaction to unaffiliated hackers poking at a particularly juicy target.
If you are aware of any such evidence, please link it! I am, very seriously, completely open to either of those scenarios (or some other plausible one I didn't mention). But I'm not going to jump to conclusions without any, even circumstantial, evidence.
MH17 was a very different situation. Bored teenagers halfway across the globe cannot shoot down an airliner. The facts of the situation—a plane flying well above short-range SAM range—left exactly two even slightly plausibly responsible parties, and to the best of my knowledge nobody who wasn't obviously Russia-aligned ever disputed that the shootdown was done with Russian materiel.
I had never considered that supermarkets would be using app-controlled freezers and thermostats. Doesn't seem worth the extra cost to a famously slim-margin business, but clearly it made sense at...
I had never considered that supermarkets would be using app-controlled freezers and thermostats. Doesn't seem worth the extra cost to a famously slim-margin business, but clearly it made sense at the time.
In a way, I get it. It’s a lot of fridges, so having a centralized place to control them makes sense. On the other hand, I wonder if they were exposed to the internet? Maybe the solution could be...
In a way, I get it. It’s a lot of fridges, so having a centralized place to control them makes sense.
On the other hand, I wonder if they were exposed to the internet? Maybe the solution could be making sure that they stay within the LAN.
Or maybe it’s just better to make them dumb devices again. Some devices are simply too important and shouldn’t have extra points of failure
For industrial fridges and freezers it makes sense to have these features. You need temperature logging to verify the cold chain and (I'm guessing) it's useful to have the ability to remotely...
For industrial fridges and freezers it makes sense to have these features. You need temperature logging to verify the cold chain and (I'm guessing) it's useful to have the ability to remotely control the temperature so that say, before a delivery you can set it to a lower temperature to compensate for any cooling lost while moving the delivered merchandise in.
The mistake here is just typical lax security. These devices shouldn't be exposed to the public internet and if they already aren't, then it just means they had weak network security that the hackers were able to get through to reach the devices.
That, and I have been told you need to sanitize the freezer on set intervals by heating them to ~50 c, so that is handy to be able to turn that on when you know they should be empty.
That, and I have been told you need to sanitize the freezer on set intervals by heating them to ~50 c, so that is handy to be able to turn that on when you know they should be empty.
Ah, so that's why they go all the way up to 50. I was kinda confused how and why a freezer would be able to heat up above ambient temperature just because a digital setting said so.
Ah, so that's why they go all the way up to 50. I was kinda confused how and why a freezer would be able to heat up above ambient temperature just because a digital setting said so.
I remember watching gameplay footage of Watch Dogs, people wirelessly hacking traffic lights and electronic doors, and thinking how stupid it was that everything electronic in this world would be...
I remember watching gameplay footage of Watch Dogs, people wirelessly hacking traffic lights and electronic doors, and thinking how stupid it was that everything electronic in this world would be network accessible. Now people's smart beds are being bricked and half of Europe's freezers were taken out by a Russian cyber op. The only thing I don't think is network accessible yet are those fecking traffic lights.
Traffic lights are definitely networked in most cities. Whether said network is accessible easily from the internet is another story. Traffic control is a fairly complicated field, and you'll have...
Traffic lights are definitely networked in most cities. Whether said network is accessible easily from the internet is another story.
Traffic control is a fairly complicated field, and you'll have a range from dumb fixed-cycle lights in rural or low traffic areas (previously electromechanical, now probably an embedded computer) to centrally coordinated systems that use sensors to collect traffic flow information and optimize cycles. Lights are coordinated to create "green waves" to minimize congestion, and cycle times are dynamically adjusted based on the presence of vehicles or time of day or alternate routes being closed.
Also report about Ireland and Estonia supermarkets: link
Seems like hybrid warfare of some kind?
Given that the first known target was US Army commissaries? Absolutely.
This is what I thought initially, but it seems simply the case of default username/password (Supervisor/12345) and internet connected devices. I'm not kidding with that password. It looks like scanning for these devices, I bet Shodan can easily list them, then trying default creds. I was reading Danfoss is the maker. So in essence nothing new, much like internet connected printers being abused by script kiddies.
Don’t be fooled. Script kiddies aren’t behind this.
Seriously; I’m extremely involved in countering Russian attacks and regardless of how shit security is, it’s still Russia behind it.
We can blame poor security all we want, it still takes a criminal to break in, even if the key was simple.
I’m not convinced. This type of thing has happened so many times before and if I was still in high school and heard about this, I might have logged in somewhere to take a look. This is not hacking, it’s just looking for devices with no protection. Just like shared printers, security cameras, raspberry pi’s, etc. that had similar issues.
Since it’s so easy to break into, care to log in and send me a screenshot?
I don’t think you understand europe is at war and we’re the constant target of hybrid attacks by a foreign enemy. I’m quite sick of people not understanding this and pretending the situation is ok. It’s not ok and you can be convinced as much as you want, I am telling you now: I am actively involved in this, it’s Russians, there’s no pretending it’s not. That’s the facts. I understand in your world theoretically it could be someone else, but it’s not, and from my perspective, any denying of this gets into “jet fuel can’t melt steel beams” territory.
Asking me to log in myself to prove something is a strange request, because it's illegal and I'm a grown man with grownup responsibilities. But you don't need to take my word for it, Previdian reported login attempts with default username password at the same time these 'hacks' happened. This doesn't scream hacking mastermind; this is known weakness that's suddenly exploited a number of times in a few weeks. These companies could have, I don't know, listened to all the reports and just pulled these devices off the internet like any sane person would do. Instead, they've chosen to not do anything. Shocked pikachu face, someone exploited it and messed their shit up. Expensive mistake to make.
Being at war with whoever and not providing any proof of their involvement in this hack is a weak argument. Just like saying you are actively involved in something without providing any information to what your involvement is exactly. Then resorting to namecalling ("jet fuel bla bla") is also a weak argument.
If you want to add something substantial to the discussion, I'm all ears. But until then, I'm not sure we're getting anywhere with this.
Here, it’s becoming a bit more public now.
https://swedenherald.com/article/pro-russian-hacker-groups-claim-responsibility-for-attacks-on-refrigeration-systems-across-europe
And I really hope you reflect on how your attitude actually only helps such attackers.
Sigh
I’m sorry man but you’re parroting Russian talking points. At what point is the burden of proof on me rather than on the country attacking Europe and Ukraine constantly for years?
Again I didn’t say the security of these systems was good. I said the attackers were Russians. These are facts backed by two things: 1. Plain logic on incentives, 2. Forensic data you will not have access to. Sorry, best I can do is promise you this shit is real (and yes I have quite a bit of authority on the subject at this point).
You want bad security? The lock on my front door is basically useless, very easy to pick. And yet, if my house gets broken into, I don’t blame “script kiddies”, I file a police report on the burglars that have been going through the entire neighbourhood.
The security of my house is irrelevant to it being robbed. It’s only relevant to it being robbed successfully.
Don't murk the waters with technicalities. Its still fucking Russians
Sorry I need to ask this, but that’s /s, right? In this topic I find it difficult to distinguish.
Of course not. I don't exactly understand what you are trying to achieve here, but it looks like you are paving the road for "plausible" deniability of the responsibility of our enemy. back off.
I'm trying to have a meaningful discussion, is what I'm trying to achieve here. I'm not paving a road, I'm trying to objectively look at the story and understand how this could happen. Immediately screaming "it's still fucking Russians" doesn't really fall in the "understand how this could happen" section. At the moment, I see more proof it is non-existent security and just a massive fuck up by these stores, than proof that's it the Russians.
Just like I wrote in response to Adys: if you want to add something substantial to the discussion, I'm all ears.
Look, you ARE trying to posit this case is not clear and that the enemy is not attacking us. You are hiding it behind pretend rigor and asking for proof. You are out of the loop, yet you take position benefitting the enemy. That's really all there is to it - think about who you are benefitting with your actions.
Whatever your aims and stated motivations are, you are actively helping russians with this - helping them in public opinion at least. Normally, they need to pay the troll farms to do this - you do it for free.
This is the same as when they shot down a civilian plane at the start of the war, more than 11 years ago, killing hundreds of Europeans - and useful idiots were "just asking" - "were those really russians?" "The bullet marks on the plane debris don't look russian to me" etc.
This case isn't clear-cut.
(In case it needs to be said, Russia is a failing state whose leadership is engaged in an unprovoked war of aggression in which they have committed and continue to commit numerous war crimes.)
The freezers in question are horrifically insecure. This is a fact about which there's absolutely no question; they exposed a management interface with trivial default credentials (IIRC based on the date), and were open to the Internet so literally anyone could credential-stuff until they broke in and then "manage" them.
We don't have any evidence (at least, not that I've seen) about who broke into these freezers. Russian state hackers are definitely on the differential! But again, the level of sophistication required here was negligible. "Bored British teenager" is also on the differential, and we have no shortage of proven cases of bored British teenagers engaging in exactly this sort of activity. Aside from questioning why in the absolute fuck every operator didn't yank their freezers off the open Internet the instant news of the last hack broke, we should reserve judgement until we have actual evidence to base it on. The appropriate reaction to Russian hackers attacking the food supply chain of other countries is very different from the appropriate reaction to unaffiliated hackers poking at a particularly juicy target.
If you are aware of any such evidence, please link it! I am, very seriously, completely open to either of those scenarios (or some other plausible one I didn't mention). But I'm not going to jump to conclusions without any, even circumstantial, evidence.
MH17 was a very different situation. Bored teenagers halfway across the globe cannot shoot down an airliner. The facts of the situation—a plane flying well above short-range SAM range—left exactly two even slightly plausibly responsible parties, and to the best of my knowledge nobody who wasn't obviously Russia-aligned ever disputed that the shootdown was done with Russian materiel.
I had never considered that supermarkets would be using app-controlled freezers and thermostats. Doesn't seem worth the extra cost to a famously slim-margin business, but clearly it made sense at the time.
In a way, I get it. It’s a lot of fridges, so having a centralized place to control them makes sense.
On the other hand, I wonder if they were exposed to the internet? Maybe the solution could be making sure that they stay within the LAN.
Or maybe it’s just better to make them dumb devices again. Some devices are simply too important and shouldn’t have extra points of failure
For industrial fridges and freezers it makes sense to have these features. You need temperature logging to verify the cold chain and (I'm guessing) it's useful to have the ability to remotely control the temperature so that say, before a delivery you can set it to a lower temperature to compensate for any cooling lost while moving the delivered merchandise in.
The mistake here is just typical lax security. These devices shouldn't be exposed to the public internet and if they already aren't, then it just means they had weak network security that the hackers were able to get through to reach the devices.
That, and I have been told you need to sanitize the freezer on set intervals by heating them to ~50 c, so that is handy to be able to turn that on when you know they should be empty.
Ah, so that's why they go all the way up to 50. I was kinda confused how and why a freezer would be able to heat up above ambient temperature just because a digital setting said so.
It’s probably to save on labor.
I’m sure before it was centralized some human had to go through and make sure each freezer was working
I remember watching gameplay footage of Watch Dogs, people wirelessly hacking traffic lights and electronic doors, and thinking how stupid it was that everything electronic in this world would be network accessible. Now people's smart beds are being bricked and half of Europe's freezers were taken out by a Russian cyber op. The only thing I don't think is network accessible yet are those fecking traffic lights.
Traffic lights are definitely networked in most cities. Whether said network is accessible easily from the internet is another story.
Traffic control is a fairly complicated field, and you'll have a range from dumb fixed-cycle lights in rural or low traffic areas (previously electromechanical, now probably an embedded computer) to centrally coordinated systems that use sensors to collect traffic flow information and optimize cycles. Lights are coordinated to create "green waves" to minimize congestion, and cycle times are dynamically adjusted based on the presence of vehicles or time of day or alternate routes being closed.
Yes, if this is like the last attack(s), they were exposed with weak passwords.
Previous attack on refrigerators
https://tildes.net/~tech/1wfr/fridges_in_french_supermarkets_hit_by_cyber_attack
We are in for some crazy times ahead.
Well we are at war and there's an insane emperor on the other side of the ocean... So yes, we are.
It’s not just that