22 votes

Could we get a page dedicated to spirituality?

Hello, im new to Tildes, and iv been very active in spiritual subs (from the other website) and i was wondering if its possible to have a page here as well dedicated to spirituality and all relating topics? its a great and very popular theme that only grows with time, im sure it could be of great benefit to this platform, thank you!

23 comments

  1. [3]
    Banazir
    Link
    Out of curiosity, what made you want to join Tildes? I just find it odd that you join a community and immediately ask for a change rather than engaging with the community as it is now. There has...

    Out of curiosity, what made you want to join Tildes?

    I just find it odd that you join a community and immediately ask for a change rather than engaging with the community as it is now. There has to be something that drew you here. Like NotAFae said, it feels inauthentic, but moreso for the request itself rather than the way it is written.

    Just come on in! The water's great, we don't bite, insert analogy here - whatever it is that pulled you in, connect with that!

    36 votes
    1. [2]
      uaeaaie
      Link Parent
      I can only speak for myself but when I joined Tildes, I was drawn by the quality of discussion and general vibes, but there are also a few topics I frequently follow on other sites that's not...

      I can only speak for myself but when I joined Tildes, I was drawn by the quality of discussion and general vibes, but there are also a few topics I frequently follow on other sites that's not posted here much.

      So the thought is what if there's a home for those topics here? Then I'd get to keep enjoying those same topics but with higher discussion quality, without having to put up with the toxicity or wading through slops on those other sites.

      For this particular topic, a brief search showed that it has been suggested and engaged with in the past (one two three) so I think this fits in fine.

      Though to OP, I don't know if new group creation is possible. We might just have to make do with other means.

      9 votes
      1. updawg
        Link Parent
        It is possible, but the only site admin, @deimos, said Any significant changes to Tildes are extremely unlikely. Creating groups has relatively recent precedent, so I'm not sure if it would be...

        It is possible, but the only site admin, @deimos, said Any significant changes to Tildes are extremely unlikely. Creating groups has relatively recent precedent, so I'm not sure if it would be considered "significant," but I wouldn't consider it likely, per se.

        10 votes
  2. [4]
    DefinitelyNotAFae
    Link
    It's not likely we'll see new groups created, but feel free to share things in the most appropriate one, perhaps ~life ? I will let you know this post reads a bit inauthentic, like maybe you used...

    It's not likely we'll see new groups created, but feel free to share things in the most appropriate one, perhaps ~life ?

    I will let you know this post reads a bit inauthentic, like maybe you used something to help you write it. Maybe you're just eager and thus trying to impress. But I encourage you to be genuine here regardless. Welcome!

    19 votes
    1. [3]
      Noox
      Link Parent
      You do? My first thought was non-native speaker trying to get their request across as clearly as possible :p

      You do? My first thought was non-native speaker trying to get their request across as clearly as possible :p

      20 votes
      1. DefinitelyNotAFae
        Link Parent
        I said inauthentic, not necessarily AI written and possibly just eager. Not just the non-native speaker but almost an affected earnestness. In other contexts it could read more like a spammer*,...

        I said inauthentic, not necessarily AI written and possibly just eager. Not just the non-native speaker but almost an affected earnestness.

        In other contexts it could read more like a spammer*, but as that didn't seem to make sense here, I felt like mentioning it in case they were feeling the need to over prepare their communications. And just to encourage genuineness.

        *"Great and very popular theme" "of great benefit to the platform"

        12 votes
      2. kargaroc
        Link Parent
        Agreed this does not seem like AI at all. Has typos etc.

        Agreed this does not seem like AI at all. Has typos etc.

        9 votes
  3. [7]
    WhistlePig
    Link
    Their only contribution to the site is to make a request to change it to their liking, and then they don't even participate in that thread. I'm not sure this is the type of user Tildes should be...

    Their only contribution to the site is to make a request to change it to their liking, and then they don't even participate in that thread. I'm not sure this is the type of user Tildes should be catering to.

    14 votes
    1. [4]
      updawg
      Link Parent
      To be fair, they were immediately called inauthentic by two users. That could easily immediately push someone away.

      To be fair, they were immediately called inauthentic by two users. That could easily immediately push someone away.

      23 votes
      1. Grayscail
        Link Parent
        Yeah, at first glance, I think its understandable that someone coming in would request that, considering places like reddit and discord have the ability for new channels or subreddits to be...

        Yeah, at first glance, I think its understandable that someone coming in would request that, considering places like reddit and discord have the ability for new channels or subreddits to be created.

        But personally I have had plenty of experiences where I tried to start a conversation and it immediately didnt go well, so I just bailed and forgot the whole thing.

        13 votes
      2. [2]
        WhistlePig
        Link Parent
        I think those comments were pretty diplomatic and fair. Imagine going to a new social group in person and, instead of making any attempt to mingle or participate, you ask for the group to change...

        I think those comments were pretty diplomatic and fair. Imagine going to a new social group in person and, instead of making any attempt to mingle or participate, you ask for the group to change to accommodate your preferences. It's obviously not the end of the world but it's leaning towards antisocial behavior.

        8 votes
        1. updawg
          Link Parent
          It's maybe a little awkward but it's not antisocial and it doesn't merit an immediate "you seem fake."

          It's maybe a little awkward but it's not antisocial and it doesn't merit an immediate "you seem fake."

          13 votes
    2. [2]
      caliper
      Link Parent
      No need to dogpile, this has already been said. Also, give the user some time to respond.

      No need to dogpile, this has already been said. Also, give the user some time to respond.

      11 votes
      1. WhistlePig
        Link Parent
        "Dogpile" is a little dramatic. I don't think a few different comments questioning the poster's motivation and pointing out their lack of participation warrants comment policing. And surely a day...

        "Dogpile" is a little dramatic. I don't think a few different comments questioning the poster's motivation and pointing out their lack of participation warrants comment policing.

        And surely a day is long enough participate in a conversation that you started. If not, why not just wait to post it?

        4 votes
  4. [3]
    text_garden
    Link
    There is a ~humanities group which is suitable for that as well as other topics of a philosophical nature. It seems to me that the problem should precede the solution, and it's not like the...

    There is a ~humanities group which is suitable for that as well as other topics of a philosophical nature. It seems to me that the problem should precede the solution, and it's not like the existing groups are overflowing with discussions on this topic.

    On the other hand, perhaps more people would be interested in the topic if there was a designated space for it.

    13 votes
    1. [2]
      lostwax
      Link Parent
      Does anyone use the topics in that way? For me they are simply useful unsubscription areas that let me turn off topics I don't want to deal with (I'm probably one of the few with both comp and...

      On the other hand, perhaps more people would be interested in the topic if there was a designated space for it.

      Does anyone use the topics in that way? For me they are simply useful unsubscription areas that let me turn off topics I don't want to deal with (I'm probably one of the few with both comp and games turned off), but they aren't pages I visit by themselves. Given the level of site and individual topic activity it's likely most people work this way? Most of the time I have no idea what topic a post has been given, I'd have to check.

      5 votes
      1. text_garden
        Link Parent
        I don't really use them except to see at a glance where something was posted. Like if I see the title "The story of Mel" (now on my front page) I might have no clue what kind of story to expect if...

        I don't really use them except to see at a glance where something was posted. Like if I see the title "The story of Mel" (now on my front page) I might have no clue what kind of story to expect if I couldn't see that it was posted in ~comp (though bad specific example for me, since I know the story of Mel).

        Tag filters have been useful though for the same purpose you use the groups. In my use just to get rid of capeshit and AI news without throwing the baby out with the bathwater.

        2 votes
  5. [6]
    Grayscail
    Link
    For what its worth, I do think it would be nice to have a space focused on religion and spirituality, I think its an interesting topic to think about. However, there is no capability for users to...

    For what its worth, I do think it would be nice to have a space focused on religion and spirituality, I think its an interesting topic to think about.

    However, there is no capability for users to create new groups. What is available now is what you get.

    If you have a specific topic or link in mind, you can still feel free to post that in an existing group where it fits.

    6 votes
    1. [5]
      uaeaaie
      Link Parent
      I've actually been curious about tarot reading. I once read an article (that I couldn't find now annoyingly) about how astrology and its elaborate mythology can serve as a shared language to help...

      I've actually been curious about tarot reading. I once read an article (that I couldn't find now annoyingly) about how astrology and its elaborate mythology can serve as a shared language to help communicate information or feelings that you get on an instinctual level but don't have more explicit description for yet, which changed my mind as a "science-pilled" person. Whether we do or do not think of something as "real", the value it provides can still be.

      4 votes
      1. DefinitelyNotAFae
        Link Parent
        I think of Tarot as a useful tool and functioning something like counseling (there are similar tools used as actual counseling tools and a therapist could easily use a tarot deck in the same way)....

        I think of Tarot as a useful tool and functioning something like counseling (there are similar tools used as actual counseling tools and a therapist could easily use a tarot deck in the same way). I want to believe there's more to it, but I don't really? I still find and acquire decks with beautiful art sometimes.

        I don't find it super instinctual naturally (especially outside of the Major Arcana, but even some of those) but think the art lets folks find and assign meaning in a less intentional, more subliminal way.

        6 votes
      2. [2]
        Grayscail
        Link Parent
        Ive always wanted to learn tarot, not for fortune telling, but as a card deck. Like, theres all the normal cards you have from a 52 card deck, but then theres all these other unique cards. And...

        Ive always wanted to learn tarot, not for fortune telling, but as a card deck. Like, theres all the normal cards you have from a 52 card deck, but then theres all these other unique cards. And apparently, there are in fact some card games meant to be played with a full tarot deck, which I think itd be fun to learn.

        Btw, I think what you are describing sounds a bit like Jungian archetypes.

        2 votes
        1. uaeaaie
          Link Parent
          Ooh I didn't know there're games with them, more reason to get a deck then :) Also thanks for mentioning Jungian archetypes, guess I have some reading to do.

          Ooh I didn't know there're games with them, more reason to get a deck then :)

          Also thanks for mentioning Jungian archetypes, guess I have some reading to do.

          1 vote
      3. cesarandreu
        Link Parent
        I think of divination and similar tools as a technique for externalizing intuition. When you do a tarot reading, whatever resonates tends to be stuff that is already in your mind and the reading...

        I think of divination and similar tools as a technique for externalizing intuition. When you do a tarot reading, whatever resonates tends to be stuff that is already in your mind and the reading is just making it easier for you to understand it. The magic isn't in the tools, it's in your interpretation and reaction.

        I would recommend Tarot and the Psychology of the Soul: Exploring the Archetypal Mirrors of the Psyche by Mariana Louis if you are interested in the subject.

        4 votes