18 votes

Brave Origin, a paid, premium version of Brave is now available

33 comments

  1. [23]
    mat
    Link
    Friendly reminder that Brave CEO Brendan Eich is a homophobe, anti-vaxist and science denier. There are plenty of other browsers out there.
    • Exemplary

    Friendly reminder that Brave CEO Brendan Eich is a homophobe, anti-vaxist and science denier.

    There are plenty of other browsers out there.

    74 votes
    1. [21]
      MoralImperative
      Link Parent
      Not to be that guy but can you recommend another browser? I feel like I hear bad things for just about any browser. Chrome is owned by Google and they inject all kinds of nasty tracking and AI...

      Not to be that guy but can you recommend another browser?

      I feel like I hear bad things for just about any browser. Chrome is owned by Google and they inject all kinds of nasty tracking and AI stuff, and Firefox isn’t what it used to be. I use brave because it seems free from asshole influence but I guess not.

      10 votes
      1. [3]
        0xSim
        Link Parent
        You don't have much of a choice: if it's not Firefox, it's Chromium. I'd say that Firefox is the less bad option. I also use it on Android, or Vivaldi exclusively for the few PWAs that I want to...

        You don't have much of a choice: if it's not Firefox, it's Chromium. I'd say that Firefox is the less bad option. I also use it on Android, or Vivaldi exclusively for the few PWAs that I want to install.

        I'm also not too keen on using forks. Your web browser is the single most critical application on your system, and even though Mozilla and Google suck, they certainly don't mess around security. I don't have that kind of trust for amateurs, as well-intentioned as they are.

        39 votes
        1. redwall_hp
          Link Parent
          Note that Safari is also not Chromium. The Blink renderer in Chromium is descended from WebKit (Safari), but they've heavily diverged since Google forked it. They have completely different...

          Note that Safari is also not Chromium. The Blink renderer in Chromium is descended from WebKit (Safari), but they've heavily diverged since Google forked it. They have completely different JavaScript runtimes as well (JavaScriptCore in Safari vs Chromium's V8).

          Arguably, Apple's denial of non-WebKit browsers on iOS is the only thing standing in the way of Google having an Internet Explorer level monopoly, and companies only targeting chromium for everything. If that were opened up, there would likely be a major push to normalize installing Chrome, just like the situation where Mac users tend to install Chrome immediately.

          3 votes
        2. MoralImperative
          Link Parent
          This is a great summarization of my feelings as well.

          This is a great summarization of my feelings as well.

          1 vote
      2. [8]
        fxgn
        (edited )
        Link Parent
        Zen Browser (a fork of Firefox) works great for me. Helium is nice if you want a minimal Chrome experience without all the bullshit Vivaldi is also interesting, though I haven't used it much and...

        Zen Browser (a fork of Firefox) works great for me.

        Helium is nice if you want a minimal Chrome experience without all the bullshit

        Vivaldi is also interesting, though I haven't used it much and don't know how good it is privacy-wise.

        17 votes
        1. JCAPER
          Link Parent
          About Vivaldi: It's partially open source. The UI is closed source, while the rest is open source. (For me this isn't really an issue, but worth pointing out) I might be misremembering so put here...

          About Vivaldi:

          • It's partially open source. The UI is closed source, while the rest is open source. (For me this isn't really an issue, but worth pointing out)

          • I might be misremembering so put here a grain of salt, but privacy wise the browser calls home every day with a randomized ID and info about the CPU. They say that it's only meant for them to know how many people are using the browser.

          • I don't know how it is nowadays since they updated the UI, but last year I noticed that this browser was "hungrier" than other browsers. My work PC's hardware was abysmal so I could feel this, while other browsers like Brave, Chrome, firefox and even edge worked fine and felt less demanding.

          9 votes
        2. [2]
          trim
          Link Parent
          I use Vivaldi for whatever little that datum is worth.

          I use Vivaldi for whatever little that datum is worth.

          5 votes
          1. datavoid
            Link Parent
            I switched to vivaldi as my main browser in 2023, and absolutely love it. There are so many things you can customize.. the only thing I'm having issues with currently are tab groups, for some...

            I switched to vivaldi as my main browser in 2023, and absolutely love it. There are so many things you can customize.. the only thing I'm having issues with currently are tab groups, for some reason dragging tabs into / out of groups is massively bugged.

            2 votes
        3. [4]
          Lexinonymous
          Link Parent
          Count me as a very satisfied Zen user.

          Count me as a very satisfied Zen user.

          2 votes
          1. [3]
            Grzmot
            Link Parent
            I haven't found answer for this, but since it's a Firefox fork, does it support sync? If I used it on my PC but kept using FF on Android, would everything stay synced?

            I haven't found answer for this, but since it's a Firefox fork, does it support sync? If I used it on my PC but kept using FF on Android, would everything stay synced?

            1. [2]
              Lexinonymous
              Link Parent
              I use Firefox accounts with Zen just fine.

              I use Firefox accounts with Zen just fine.

              2 votes
              1. Grzmot
                Link Parent
                That's lovely to know, thanks!

                That's lovely to know, thanks!

      3. mat
        Link Parent
        I use Firefox day to day although I am also experimenting with Zen (Firefox fork), which seems a bit more like Olde Firefox. Opera also gets booted up from time to time. People like Vivaldi but I...

        I use Firefox day to day although I am also experimenting with Zen (Firefox fork), which seems a bit more like Olde Firefox. Opera also gets booted up from time to time. People like Vivaldi but I haven't tried.

        I mean yeah, everyone has issues to some extent. But Eich is very publicly a pretty large asshole and has been for a long time. Also Brave have always been on the wrong side of the asshole fence, frankly. I remember Tom Scott un-recommending them years ago when they forced their weird crypto thing onto him without his permission.

        14 votes
      4. [4]
        Trobador
        Link Parent
        I've used Firefox for years myself, but decided recently to give Waterfox, a fork of the browser, a go since Mozilla has allegedly been using user data to train AI without users' consent. It's...

        I've used Firefox for years myself, but decided recently to give Waterfox, a fork of the browser, a go since Mozilla has allegedly been using user data to train AI without users' consent. It's been a decent experience. I would recommend it.

        7 votes
        1. [2]
          Alfred
          Link Parent
          Can you source this? I know the new CEO talked about including AI features in the browser, but they very quickly came out and said that all "AI" things will be able to be turned off, and also all...

          Can you source this?

          since Mozilla has allegedly been using user data to train AI without users' consent.

          I know the new CEO talked about including AI features in the browser, but they very quickly came out and said that all "AI" things will be able to be turned off, and also all of said features are opt-in. Even just looking at my settings in FF152 I have all of that stuff turned off

          7 votes
          1. Trobador
            Link Parent
            I cannot, which is why I only used 'allegedly' ; an acquaintance told me about it and I remember her sourcing the info but I wouldn't be able to bring it up again. I added that to provide context...

            I cannot, which is why I only used 'allegedly' ; an acquaintance told me about it and I remember her sourcing the info but I wouldn't be able to bring it up again. I added that to provide context as to why I'd switched but maybe it was a bit zealous... apologies.

            1 vote
        2. 0x29A
          (edited )
          Link Parent
          I also switched to Waterfox as my main since they've stayed away from AI/etc so far. It's a nice fork. Sync still works, easy to move profile over, etc Tried Zen, wasn't a fan. LibreWolf was a...

          I also switched to Waterfox as my main since they've stayed away from AI/etc so far. It's a nice fork. Sync still works, easy to move profile over, etc

          Tried Zen, wasn't a fan. LibreWolf was a consideration but a bit too overkill for me privacy/security wise, etc

          If I have to use a Chromium browser in a pinch, I use Helium

          No longer interested in the vanilla corporate versions of browsers anymore, basically forks all the way down for me

          3 votes
      5. [3]
        rip_rike
        Link Parent
        You didn’t mention if you’re PC or Mac but if Mac… Orion - WebKit-based (same engine as Safari) but with Chrome/Firefox extensions. Been using this for a while now and it’s really matured. Zen -...

        You didn’t mention if you’re PC or Mac but if Mac…

        Orion - WebKit-based (same engine as Safari) but with Chrome/Firefox extensions. Been using this for a while now and it’s really matured.

        Zen - Firefox fork like others have mentioned

        Vivaldi - I use this at work and have no complaints

        7 votes
        1. [2]
          MoralImperative
          Link Parent
          Apologies, I am on Mac as well. I’ll take a look at these. Thanks!

          Apologies, I am on Mac as well.

          I’ll take a look at these. Thanks!

          1. trim
            Link Parent
            I'm using Vivaldi on Mac. I like it because it syncs between all my devices for bookmarks and browser state. I use that feature a lot. Macbook, Mac, Linux laptop, iPad, phone, can just pick up...

            I'm using Vivaldi on Mac. I like it because it syncs between all my devices for bookmarks and browser state. I use that feature a lot. Macbook, Mac, Linux laptop, iPad, phone, can just pick up browsing on whichever device I want.

            I "defected" from Firefox some time back and wanted to move to a Chromium fork. Vivaldi was the fork of choice.

      6. Eji1700
        Link Parent
        I mean...what are you worried about? It works and does anything I've ever needed.

        Firefox isn’t what it used to be

        I mean...what are you worried about? It works and does anything I've ever needed.

        7 votes
    2. knocklessmonster
      Link Parent
      Brave's crypto stuff also gives me the ick so I avoid using it. I use Vivaldi since it at least doesn't seem to try to mine my data, and is available as a flatpak. I'm less concerned with open...

      Brave's crypto stuff also gives me the ick so I avoid using it. I use Vivaldi since it at least doesn't seem to try to mine my data, and is available as a flatpak.

      I'm less concerned with open source than leadership ethics, especially since any features I like in Brave can be done via extensions.

      5 votes
  2. Indikon
    Link
    Brave was also caught injecting their own referral links into crypto urls. If they do that, what else are they going to try? Here - CPOMagazine

    Brave was also caught injecting their own referral links into crypto urls. If they do that, what else are they going to try?
    Here - CPOMagazine

    21 votes
  3. Nichaes
    Link
    Brave is a browser whose popularity I'm honestly baffled by. It's chromium, it constantly shoves AI and crypto in your face, bombards you with its own ads, on top of the shady stuff it's been...

    Brave is a browser whose popularity I'm honestly baffled by. It's chromium, it constantly shoves AI and crypto in your face, bombards you with its own ads, on top of the shady stuff it's been reported to do like selling your data and subbing affiliate links. Even if you don't wanna use Firefox, it makes no sense to use this particular browser.

    17 votes
  4. [3]
    Kerry56
    Link
    I use Firefox as my daily driver and see no reason to change, especially since I have all the extensions I need installed and working well. Eight extensions... is that a lot compared to you guys?...

    I use Firefox as my daily driver and see no reason to change, especially since I have all the extensions I need installed and working well. Eight extensions... is that a lot compared to you guys?

    I have Waterfox as a backup, and have it set up in as complete a privacy mode as I can, with nothing saved from each session.

    On the off chance I run into a site that requires Chrome or a Chromium based browser, I keep Ungoogled Chromium installed, but rarely use it.

    Not sure I see the need for a paid browser.

    12 votes
    1. [2]
      whs
      Link Parent
      I use Firefox Android out of idealogy (and sync), but I believe Brave Android to be the better choice and I bought Origin just for that (even though I rarely use it). GrapheneOS wrote that I...

      I use Firefox Android out of idealogy (and sync), but I believe Brave Android to be the better choice and I bought Origin just for that (even though I rarely use it).

      GrapheneOS wrote that

      Avoid Gecko-based browsers like Firefox as they're currently much more vulnerable to exploitation and inherently add a huge amount of attack surface. [..] Worst of all, Firefox does not have internal sandboxing on Android. [..] Even in the desktop version, Firefox's sandbox is still substantially weaker (especially on Linux) and lacks full support for isolating sites from each other rather than only containing content as a whole. The sandbox has been gradually improving on the desktop but it isn't happening for their Android browser yet.

      I believe that statement is a few years old already, so I'm not sure how much of it is out-of-date. I think it's clear though that Firefox Android's maintenance is not as good as Chrome.

      As for other browsers, I believe most community Chrome forks (eg. Ungoogled Chromium, Cromite) are not in Play Store? I tried looking at Bromite at some point, but the fact that you have to know that you need to move to Cromite because your browser is dead make me feel like Brave is the better choice, especially now that you don't have to put up with antifeatures. If you require sync like I do, then those forks either don't have one or it kept the Google's sync.

      1 vote
      1. Kerry56
        Link Parent
        I am one of those weird people who almost never get online with my phone. My close-up vision is poor, and I rarely have reading glasses with me, so using a phone for the things most people do is...

        I am one of those weird people who almost never get online with my phone. My close-up vision is poor, and I rarely have reading glasses with me, so using a phone for the things most people do is just not convenient or comfortable for me. I do use Firefox on Android, but so infrequently, it hardly counts.

        My opinions about browsers are based on useage on my desktop computers, and most of those are running Linux Mint.

        3 votes
  5. Dangerous_Dan_McGrew
    Link
    I find it baffling how they can constantly shove all the worst things into a browser and then get people who not only evangelize it but are now dumb enough to pay for it.

    I find it baffling how they can constantly shove all the worst things into a browser and then get people who not only evangelize it but are now dumb enough to pay for it.

    11 votes
  6. EnigmaNL
    Link
    Yeah... I'll stick to Firefox.

    Yeah... I'll stick to Firefox.

    7 votes
  7. [2]
    PraiseTheSoup
    Link
    Why would I pay money for a chromium-based browser? I mean honestly why would I pay money for any browser when they're all harvesting and selling my personal information but especially why would I...

    Why would I pay money for a chromium-based browser? I mean honestly why would I pay money for any browser when they're all harvesting and selling my personal information but especially why would I pay for a worse version of Google Chrome?

    5 votes
    1. Gazook89
      Link Parent
      I think the idea is that by paying, they have a more traditional revenue source than data harvesting. They offer a service, you pay for it with money. If you had a lawn care service, and you never...

      I think the idea is that by paying, they have a more traditional revenue source than data harvesting. They offer a service, you pay for it with money.

      If you had a lawn care service, and you never paid but they got to empty your mailbox every day in return, it might be nice to find a company that just does the mowing in return for cash.

      Of course, if they take the cash AND still take your mail, then it’s not such a good deal.

      And if they are only taking cash from you, but taking the mail of other customers, then it feels a little like extortion.

      10 votes