-
35 votes
-
Controversial opinion: I don't like "cosmetic armor" being an option in games
In some games like Terraria or Horizon Forbidden West, you can have a "fake" set of armor on top of your "real" set of armor. The "fake" set defines how your character looks, while the "real" set...
In some games like Terraria or Horizon Forbidden West, you can have a "fake" set of armor on top of your "real" set of armor. The "fake" set defines how your character looks, while the "real" set determines your stats. This isn't a common thing in a lot of games, but in basically any game with different outfits with stats, I hear this being a requested feature. Whenever someone mentions this feature in a comment, people will chime in that it's cool and they wish [insert game here] would add it. The Horizon devs being one example of a studio who heard about this from the community of their first game, Zero Dawn, and added it to the sequel.
I really don't like this, even having it available as an option for single player games. Let me explain...
I think it really ruins the whole point of stat changing equipment in games. A big part of video games with customizable equipment and builds is designing a build and a character appearance that you like. Do you want to be slow with powerful attacks? Do you want to be fast with weak attacks? Do you want balance?
I'd argue that making a set that looks good while balancing the stats is another one of these things that adds to meaningful character creation decisions. Do you take the insane armor, or the really decent armor with worse stats that looks cool? Find a cool hat the character you're roleplaying as totally would wear? Oh, it has worse stats than the helmet you were using... But it weighs less! Maybe you can use a heavier chest plate to compensate for the stats you lost?
This also makes armor that both looks cool and has great stats into very valuable items that players want to get.
Of course for PvP games, having the type of armor that a player has on instantly give away their power level is important. On a Minecraft server, if you see two hostile players, one has leather armor, and the other has full netherite, you know the netherite guy is going to have better gear.
You might think this only matters for PvP games, but not allowing this mechanic in mostly single player games also adds a lot to the game, since you'll likely either see friends play the game or watch videos of other people playing the game. Each armor being intrinsically linked to certain stats creates a link between what you know that armor does and what kind of player would use that armor. In Elden Ring (which also has PvP, but bear with me), if you see someone wearing Bull Goat (the heaviest armor with the best stats), or wearing nothing but a jar on their head (to get worse defense but faster dodge rolls and some buffs to consumable throwing items), that tells you a lot about their play style just looking at their character's appearance. If both of these people could wear whatever armor they wanted and make the functional armor invisible, I would have no idea what build they had.
Using armor that looks good but has bad stats can be a fun flex to show you're good at the game, and choosing to have terrible fashion in exchange for stats is hilarious, as per this ProZD skit. That concept is a fun part of gaming culture I wouldn't want to see destroyed.
44 votes -
Helldivers 2's crucial 01.001.100 update completely reworks weapons, adds new Galactic War feature, and changes much more in bid to make the game easier
17 votes -
Introducing Steam Families - now out of beta!
36 votes -
Valve bans Razer and Wooting’s new keyboard features in Counter-Strike 2
43 votes -
Steam updates user reviews with a new helpfulness system
45 votes -
Doom Eternal official mod support released, includes the same dev tools used to make the game
17 votes -
Wreckfest 2 announced with new car customization feature
12 votes -
Steam - Game Recording Beta - A new built-in system for creating and sharing your gameplay footage
55 votes -
Steam Business Update - Update on the Steam Platform, features, and global trends
32 votes -
Baldur's Gate 3 - Official modding support
35 votes -
Introducing Steam Families
71 votes -
Controller support shown in Steam library and store expands to now include PlayStation controllers
32 votes -
Valve doesn't sell ad space on Steam so it can make room for surprise hits: 'We don't think Steam should be pay-to-win'
76 votes -
Minecraft Live 2023: New mob, Trial Chambers, and auto crafting!
23 votes -
Sony announces smaller PlayStation 5 design with option to add a disc drive to the Digital Edition console
20 votes -
From prototypes to future tech: How PS VR2 was built. New insight into the multi-year development process behind the PlayStation VR2 hardware.
5 votes -
Minecraft Wiki strongly considering moving away from Fandom
99 votes -
New custom D&D miniatures from Hero Forge will soon include adjustable facial features
7 votes -
A few more things added to Steam Deck
9 votes -
Eve Online fans literally cheer Microsoft Excel features at annual Fanfest
18 votes -
Epic Online Services launches Anti-Cheat support for Linux, Mac, and Steam Deck
18 votes -
Humble Bundle is removing the "choose where your money goes" sliders, intending to switch to a choice between giving 5% or 15% to charity
13 votes -
Super Mario Party update allows online play, adds new games mode
11 votes -
Dota 2 introduces many new features and systems to help new players, and makes smurfing a bannable offense
16 votes -
Microsoft xCloud for Web - First look
3 votes -
Xbox’s “instant on” feature could consume four billion kWh of energy by 2025
15 votes -
New Steam Labs experiment adds new ways to browse games through genres, themes, and player modes
9 votes -
Operation Broken Fang; Major CSGO update adds map vetoes, retakes servers, detailed stat tracking
7 votes -
Credits are not 'extra' - why game credits matter
5 votes -
Steam Remote Play Together is now in beta - A new feature that lets you play your couch co-op games with friends over the internet
19 votes -
Google Stadia will be missing many features for Monday’s launch
9 votes -
Microtransactions - What does good game monetization look like?
5 votes -
Overwatch 2 to feature PvE, new map, at least one new hero
8 votes -
Bethesda announces "Fallout 1st", a $13/month premium membership for Fallout 76 that allows you have to have a private world along with other benefits
20 votes -
Red Dead Redemption 2 for PC - First screenshots, details about new features and updates, and system requirements
7 votes -
Overwatch - Introducing the Role Queue system
10 votes -
Introducing Steam Labs - a place for testing and giving feedback on experimental Steam features
11 votes -
Google announces "Stadia", a new game-streaming platform with deep YouTube integration
38 votes -
The past, present, and future of Pokémon Go, according to Niantic
8 votes -
PSN online ID change feature entering PlayStation preview program soon
8 votes -
PlayStation Now adds downloading of PS4, PS2 games
14 votes -
Steam has updated its built in chat feature
4 votes -
Multiplayer is in development for Beat Saber
12 votes -
Black Ops 4 ditches single-player campaign, adds battle royale mode
6 votes