-
20 votes
-
I can't describe it, but I know it when I see it
My oldest zygote is 5 years old. Up until now, I've been able to keep a good lid on what he's allowed to watch. We have Roku with a handful of streaming services, and he's comfortable navigating...
My oldest zygote is 5 years old. Up until now, I've been able to keep a good lid on what he's allowed to watch. We have Roku with a handful of streaming services, and he's comfortable navigating it himself to watch shows. I'm big on teaching agency and responsibility, and he's responded well to that: he watches shows we've okayed, asks about other shows he's interested in, and respects us if we tell him no. He's a smart kid and I'd like to keep him that way.
It's starting to get harder. Originally I could say on on grounds of age appropriateness, or I could point to things about a show that I outright didn't approve of for him. This is important to me because I want to teach him to think about these things and make good choices for himself in the future. So instead of telling him "No, you can't watch that", I want to tell him "No, you can't watch this because _________."
Now that he's getting older, he's asking more and more to watch things. And in some cases, I find myself saying "No. It's hard to explain why, but this isn't good." I hate saying that because I know that's not satisfying at his age, and it doesn't teach him anything about how to make good choices about what to watch.
YouTube is rife with examples. If my son is watching a branded show about Spiderman, I know what to expect. There are brand standards that I don't always agree with, but I know what the damage is, and the problems I have with those shows are problems I can talk through with him.
But when YouTube recommends videos that are low production quality videos of people in their living rooms playing with Spiderman figures, I don't want him watching it. Some of it feels Elsagate-adjacent (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elsagate) in that it seems harmless but you are just waiting for it to veer into weird or inappropriate territory. There's no trust between me and the content creator. Sometimes they're just harmlessly dumb. But in any case it's hard to explain why I don't want him to watch something that appears harmless to him.
Does anyone have similar experiences? Advice? Commiseration? Perspectives?
40 votes -
Fairy tales contain useful lessons for navigating our interactions with the internet
28 votes -
The goon squad. Loneliness, porn’s next frontier, and the dream of endless masturbation.
108 votes -
The state of American men is — not so good
42 votes -
How algorithms, alpha males and tradwives are winning the war for kids’ minds
46 votes -
The “loneliness epidemic” myth
29 votes -
The strange world of dimension jumping
15 votes -
How much do I really need to know?
23 votes -
Stoop coffee: How a simple idea transformed my neighborhood
48 votes -
Swedish far-right extremists pull in boys online and use bodybuilding and fight clubs to further their white supremacist agenda
20 votes -
Secret Ink - South Korea's underground tattoo scene: The women defying the law | BBC 100 Women
14 votes -
Feminists facing resistance in China find the funny side of things
13 votes -
Do our dogs have something to tell the world?
8 votes -
Let's talk 'underconsumption core'
31 votes -
A wife’s revenge from beyond the grave
48 votes -
'I want her to worry about who’s waiting on the corner’: How one man uses Facebook to frighten his children’s mother and why police do nothing
35 votes -
The great deterioration of local community was a major driver of the loss of the play-based childhood
26 votes -
Why Gen Z is quietly giving up
27 votes -
Scammers are targeting teenage boys on social media—and driving some to suicide
27 votes -
The life-ruining power of routines: Habits don’t lead to personal optimisation. They lead to suffering.
32 votes -
Notes on conciseness
30 votes -
Booktok and the hotgirlification of reading
19 votes -
Everyone’s a sellout now
33 votes -
Third places, Stanley cup mania, and the epidemic of loneliness
11 votes -
Technology is making people busier during their so called free time
34 votes -
What does it mean to friend someone online?
Recently my daughter (third grade) has started learning to type at school. It's a Montessori program, so it's a pretty low tech environment overall, which I mention because I don't necessarily...
Recently my daughter (third grade) has started learning to type at school. It's a Montessori program, so it's a pretty low tech environment overall, which I mention because I don't necessarily expect them to have a nuanced view of technology issues.
One of the typing programs they use is nitrotype.com, which adds a competitive gameplay element. However, it also has mechanism to friend another player. Friends can only communicate with stock phrases, so there's not too much "Internet leakage" beyond being able to choose a username.
I set it up for my daughter on her Linux Chromebook (I whitelist things I want her to have and everything else is blocked at DNS). Seeing her interact with it the first time, I realized that she spends as much time "adding friends" as doing the typing.
On its face, this activity is pretty harmless. But I am worried about the patterns it might be creating for her. I'm worried about her uncritically engaging with the dopamine hit of getting a new friend. Or how it shapes her idea of how many friends she has or where idea of her self worth comes from. Or what she thinks friends are.
So after that long preamble, here are some questions:
- How would you explain "friends" in this context?
- Would you distinguish them from other kinds of friends, either real or virtual?
- Would you attach a moral component to the activity? E.g. that it is good/bad or helpful/harmful
- How would you frame it to the teacher? Not so much in terms of whether or not they should do it in the classroom, but what kinds of conversations should they be having about the friends experience?
- If I'm asking the wrong questions, what questions should I be asking instead?
I'm really interested in seeing the perspectives people have on this. My own ideas are a bit murky, but I will put them down as a comment.
37 votes -
Inside an OnlyFans empire: Sex, influence and the new American Dream
32 votes -
A handful of influencers are trying to turn the tide on toxic masculinity. But can they get anyone to listen?
36 votes -
Millions of people see staying home and cleaning as their idea of a good time
31 votes -
You're not traumatized, you're just hurt
20 votes -
In Alabama, white tide rushes on
10 votes -
It's not just male influencers who preach problematic manipulation
21 votes -
Japan's ridiculous weatherwoman fiasco
57 votes -
Not all porn is created equal - is there such a thing as a healthy pornography?
83 votes -
How are you actually supposed to network / LinkedIn?
I've been having a particularly rough time finding a new job in the field I graduated in. I'm doing pretty much everything most job sites have told me but networking is kinda hard. I don't...
I've been having a particularly rough time finding a new job in the field I graduated in. I'm doing pretty much everything most job sites have told me but networking is kinda hard.
I don't currently work in my field so I don't know anyone that would be particularly useful. Everyone I know is already aware of my situation and some of them have even found leads for me but no luck yet.
I have gone to events related to organizations I'm interested in and spoken to people there but it feels super weird to just approach people and tell them I'm looking for a job.
Similarly Linkedin is super foreign to me. This post is literally the most I've ever interacted with a social media site. What do I do once I open that app? Am I supposed to just stalk people on there that might hire me someday? I tried joining a "group" but it's been pending for a week now.
59 votes -
Bloodied Macbooks and stacks of cash: Inside the increasingly violent Discord servers where kids flaunt their crimes
8 votes -
The reaction economy
3 votes -
Crushed
7 votes -
How Finland is teaching a generation to spot misinformation
8 votes -
Stop talking to each other and start buying things: three decades of survival in the desert of social media
17 votes -
Are you sure you’re not guilty of the ‘Millennial pause’?
11 votes -
The personal brand is dead
6 votes -
The cost of engaging with the miserable: Were we always this lonely and embittered?
6 votes -
We should all know less about each other
12 votes -
Let’s please not make “the slap” more than what it is
17 votes -
Map drawn from memory helps man reunite with family decades after abduction
4 votes -
Walking away from Omelas - Lindsay Ellis says goodbye
33 votes -
Inside the online movement to end work
12 votes -
People are blasting Chanel's $825 Advent calendar on TikTok
6 votes