20
votes
Weekly US politics news and updates thread - week of November 9
This thread is posted weekly - please try to post all relevant US political content in here, such as news, updates, opinion articles, etc. Extremely significant events may warrant a separate topic, but almost all should be posted in here.
This is an inherently political thread; please try to avoid antagonistic arguments and bickering matches. Comment threads that devolve into unproductive arguments may be removed so that the overall topic is able to continue.
Chris Van Hollen announces he's running for Senate Majority Leader
Ol' Chuck is unfortunately my senator and I think he needs to step aside. He and Jefferies have been disappointing at best and actively hampering every effort forward at worst.
Chris Van Hollen is the senator that went to get his constituent back from ICE and is the right type of fighter we need atm.
https://apnews.com/article/van-hollen-schumer-senate-democratic-leader-6d74c189cb6c065c9a810a1cf1a53436
Bipartisan condemnation floods Israel and Palestine protests in Philadelphia
^That's actually disingenuous, they seem to have been targeting businesses that were pro-Zionism specifically but once again we're told they were targeting all "Jewish-owned businesses"
I find it odd that a bike ride is a boycott, and I find it odd that they keep trying to frame a boycott as antisemitic, disturbing, unwelcome, etc
I didn't see anywhere in the protest where they were glorifying that
Again, "targeted" with a boycott. I don't know how you do that with a bike ride but I also don't see how boycotts undermine American values. And again, they say targeting "Jewish business owners" leaving out the fact that these owners support the genocide
Again more framing. And again, they seem to be condemning free speech and twisting the words of the protesters. Yahoo News and Christen Smith also seem to be trying to bend the truth for them.
I brought this up in last week's thread, but this is a dangerous conflation that happens all the time. There was a post a few months ago in ~lgbt that examined the NYT's framing of trans issues, and I'd love to see something similar for how often mainstream outlets run with the 'Israel = Jews' framing. Just a few days ago, I had a long conversation/argument with someone who is otherwise educated, compassionate, and progressive, after they started going off about "The Jews." I mean WTF? This person watches a lot of CNN, btw.
On a slightly relevant note, and as a follow-up to my post in last week's thread, I came across a few things this weekend that feel worthy of a share:
J Street 2026 midterm poll of Jewish voters
Some highlights: 80% say Israel's actions in Gaza and the West Bank increase antisemitism, 76% support sanctions on West Bank settlers, 66% believe AIPAC 's spending against candidates who criticize Israel increases antisemitism, 72% supported Democrats in the primaries, and a paltry 14% cite Israel as the leading concern. (It would be nice to see that reality reflected in the media)
How "safety" rhetoric is weaponized to protect Israel and smear its critics
This is a hotter take that probably won't land with everyone who reads it, but there was an interesting bit in here that feels important after the outrageously bigoted senate campaign that took place in Michigan. (Note: this was posted in early October)
There is a lot of discourse here and not a single mention of one of the most inflammatory thing about the protests to the Jewish community. It's the day before the anniversary of Kristallnact, 88 years ago. The language also calls the people they're protesting "the disgusting human being they are".
If that was coincidental, they should have changed the date the moment they were made aware. They didn't.
I've talked before on this site about how Zionism is rarely actually defined in discourse. To American Jews, it most typically literally means the continued existence of the Jewish state. And in my own experience, the most obvious reason for that being a common belief is that they connect any scenario where the Jewish majority is gone with the slaughter of half the world's Jewish population. That doesn't mean those people support Netanyahu's government, or want the death of innocents. It just means they want their own people's survival.
So my question, is what did the establishments they are protesting do, beyond support for half of the world's Jewish population?
From Philly Bike On Your Left's statement:
[...]
Regarding the date, I'm not sure if you're talking about Tildes comments specifically, but the article quotes did mention that. As for the protest group, quoting again from their statement:
Kristallnacht is mentioned in the second set of quotes I had. Did you actually read the whole thing?
Also they're protesting businesses that support the Israeli military, which you wouldn't have seen from reading the article but which I found by looking at the group's actual posts.
Zionism to you is the continuation of the Jewish state (or existence, however you see fit). Of course that's not all American Jews, maybe a majority but not all. To most people who are not Jewish, it means the establishment of Israel and the continued genocide, apartheid, and persecution of non-Jewish people in Israel and Palestine (including Christians) since 1947. It seems like you're just trying to change the semantics in order to frame the protesters in a bad light and portray the Israeli military supporters in a good one.
Sorry for missing part of your comment. Do you see how it's problematic to redefine the meaning of a term away from how a people use it to define themselves? In what other context is that considered acceptable?
It's like trying to say that Black Lives Matter means that white lives don't. Obviously, that's not how people using the phrase mean it, and anyone trying to define it that way is just trying to demonize the people using it.
As a side note, I saw a claim that one of the businesses being protested was purely for social media posting mourning October 7th and the hostages. As for supporting the Israeli Army The IDF is an army of conscripts (Jews go to jail if they refuse to serve, barring some exceptions), and so I don't see refusing to demonize or exclude it's veterans (barring evidence of that individual's actions) as a good reason for action against a business.
So that leaves me with having to look through the social media postings myself, but I can't do that until I get home, because I keep all that stuff off my phone for my health.
If there was a single business on the boycott list not owned by Jews, maybe I would have less of a problem, but there isn't.
As someone who has been confronted with people who really say things like "You're not a real Jew you didn't serve in the Israeli millitary" and etc/etc lots of "not real Jew" nonsense
I'm sure if there existed a business supporting Israel that wasn't owned by Jewish people they would have boycotted it. My question to you is why on Earth would anyone who isn't Jewish want to support Israel, except just to be "that guy". Normal people who care about normal things don't care about a far away religious state in the middle east that literally has nothing to do with them.
The ENTIRE debate is within the Jewish community, and anyone not in that community is on the sidelines. Either you can be Jewish and not support the genocide that your country is committing, or all Jews must always support Israel. There's no reason for anyone who's not Jewish to give this group any reason to boycott them.
and to this effect the boycott is stupid anyway cause what are a bunch of non-Jews gonna accomplish, they can't convince these business owners that they can still be real Jews without supporting genocide, the only message a boycott by non-Jews sends is "we're boycotting you for being loyal to your people and your country" which, kinda has the opposite effect, no?
I look forward to the day when the media stops carrying water for Zionism. I'm not holding my breath, but I think we're at least seeing progress where less and less people are falling for the "criticizing Israel = antisemitism" lie.
Yeah, I thought it was odd that the writer was still trying to push that in the current climate. It could be that her superiors forced her to re-write the article with that framing, but I knew immediately to check the organization and see what they actually said in order to debunk what she was writing
If it's disingenuous, remember that you don't have to post it. And I don't just mean the article – although I would absolutely recommend finding an actual good source if you can – because you can replace portions as needed to remove harmful rhetoric if you feel it's necessary. As an example:
The brackets here make it clear that edits were made, and the twisted words are still removed. Anyone who wants to see the original article has the link available. If you're worried this is somehow disingenuous on your part, you can also clarify what you edited & why in
<sub>formatting below the quote.This is important because as it stands your comment is giving the article a lot more visibility than your own clarifications get. The article is preserved in huge quotes that take up a lot of screen real-estate, and those quotes come first. Anything the article says thus gets both more space dedicated to itself and a head-start in the minds of readers. When you're dealing with a duplicitous article, it's counterproductive to let either of those things happen.
Incidentally, you can also do this editing with titles, which I would also advise in a case like this. Do not let a liar dictate the frame of discussion.
I wanted to point out my annoyance with the article and the writer, but you're right that even in doing that I'm giving them more exposure. Maybe next time I'll just post the "gist" of the article and not post actual links, but I wouldn't mind other people on this site reading and making their own determination. We're a pretty small site.
This is a screenshot of the organization’s IG post for the event. They call it a boycott ride.
What did these businesses actually do? Did they do anything to start a dispute with the cyclists? If the cyclists were starting a conflict with people who previously had nothing to do with them, I’m not sure free speech rhetoric is enough to justify that, morally speaking.
Hegseth and advisers reprimanded by guard at Tomb of the Unknown Soldier | CNN Politics
If you're not familiar with the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, it's the burial site of a WWI soldier whose remains were unidentifiable. The atmosphere is one of respectful silence, at all times. (There is also a very elaborate ritualized changing of the guard ceremony that you may have seen). The soldiers who guard the tomb will respond to anyone violating that in the same manner as this video - their volume is based on how loud they need to be heard.
Children can manage respect and silence here. Hegseth and his group could not.
I was there with a class of middle schoolers years ago and they were completely silent.
Yeah, I've seen them correct people, and they absolutely will and have. But they should not have had to correct the literal Secretary of Defense.
In Mississippi, voters await cliffhanger Senate result with hope and frustration (BBC)
The AP has called the senate race in Mississippi for Scott Colom: https://apnews.com/live/trump-congress-midterm-elections-politics-news-updates-11-11-2026
A week ago I said on Tildes he was unlikely to win. Very happy to be wrong about that!
I agree with your assessment of lobbying being akin to bribery. Our political system is broken in so many ways, but this seems like low hanging fruit that would please a wide swath of voters across the political spectrum. I'm having a hard time thinking of a question that would get a more lopsided answer than "Should we get money out of politics?"
The reason this corruption is allowed to continue obviously has to do those in power benefiting from it.
Most Americans seem fine with people they perceive as helping them (whatever demographic they identify with) skimming some, or a lot, off the top. Corruption only broke through as a top issue in the recent midterms because voters started to feel like the corruption was taking all of it and not passing the toll to the voter.
It seems kind of bonkers to me, but I have listened to enough different focus group interviews and seen the polls where corruption doesn't rank and just in general lived through the last ten years, that I have come to believe that's how my fellow citizens feel.
Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky launches bid to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth (AP News)
Well, hopefully this'll mean that the GOP will get it's arse kicked beyond the midterms. Hegseth in particular deserves to be locked away for live.
Normally American politics can take a lot of air abroad which can be exhausting but I'll be following it a bit more in the near future. Rooting for you all to sort out this mess.
Massie is one of those republicans who goes scorched earth on his way out. Don't assume that he's normal and reasonable because of his recent actions. He's the kind of guy who posted a Christmas picture of his family with guns a few days after 4 teenagers were killed in a school shooting
Anyway he seems to enjoy trolling Hegseth about the impeachment.
Aaron Rupar post from CSPAN
Worst guy you know makes a great point. Thankfully somehow Hegseth is even worse
...aaaaand it failed. I guess it'll have to wait until January.
Honestly, all the better. It means that the new Democratic Senate will be the ones to approve his replacement, rather than the outgoing Republican-held one.
It would require 67 Senators to actually kick him out. Given the demonstrated lack of R support in the House, it seems extremely unlikely 11-12 Republican Senators would vote to convict. I'm not sure the floor time of a Senate trial is worth it just for show, when there is so much other business they could be working on.
They have two days to vote and there's still a Republican majority. I kind of wonder how this goes with all the Republicans losing their seats. Do some of them get pissed off enough that they throw this scapegoat under the bus? Do they stand by the current Trump GOP that has fucked them over in hopes that they can be seen as loyal lap dogs in the future? Is Massie doing him a favor by launching this before January? A lot of questions in my head about this.
He has literally said as much:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwr5y58jjp8ro
Massie is not doing this because he's a good guy he is trying to save face for the Republican party.
Okay thank you for that, I figured there was more to it. It was very odd to think of a politician doing the right thing for no real self benefit, let alone a Republican
The news keeps mentioning there's bipartisan support for the impeachment. Honestly even before the midterms, I got the impression a lot of them were VERY unhappy with Hegseth. Pretty sure the loss just removed any incentive to ignore their dissatisfaction with him in an attempt to stay on Trump's good side. Also, fairly sure Trump himself will easily abandon Hegseth with all the bad press about him. He's an easy scapegoat.
He's an easy scapegoat, but is he just waiting for the right moment then? I figure the goat would've been scaped a while ago but maybe they're just waiting for January. For some reason Trump seems to hold on to Hegseth, like Trump wants to get all his bad activities out of the way before pinning everything on Hegseth
Lauren Boebert loses election https://apnews.com/projects/elections-2026/colorado-us-house-results/
May this mark the end of her career and she fade into obscurity.
Delaware voters sue to expand U.S. House, calling 435-seat limit unconstitutional (WHYY)
Thought that you were editorializing “why?” But the name of the news organization is WHYY. I think we are due for expanding the house and it’s not a big a sell as trying to get nationwide popular vote for elections.
I don't disagree, but Delaware is one of the last states i would expect to lead on this topic.
:edit: ok I committed the sin of not reading the article first. This does make a lot more sense when thinking about the actual population (and not land area) and how it's changed over time.
Heather Cox Richardson November 8
…
…
…
Thank you, was thinking about posting this one myself.
Democrat Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins wins race for Alaska governor, replaces a Republican (NPR)