29 votes

Contender for the most non-viable startup: Reflect Orbital

47 comments

  1. [5]
    text_garden
    Link
    That's the basic premise of a Bond movie as far as I remember it!

    That's the basic premise of a Bond movie as far as I remember it!

    17 votes
    1. [4]
      Hollow
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      Worse. It's the premise of an episode of Totally Spies. (I am dead serious there was an episode where a villain named Edison held the world's sunlight to ransom).

      Worse. It's the premise of an episode of Totally Spies.

      (I am dead serious there was an episode where a villain named Edison held the world's sunlight to ransom).

      10 votes
      1. [3]
        Habituallytired
        Link Parent
        I remember this episode! Wow, that was a memory brought back from the depths.

        I remember this episode! Wow, that was a memory brought back from the depths.

        2 votes
        1. [2]
          Hollow
          (edited )
          Link Parent
          I was surprised by how much dialogue played in my mind by memory, before the characters said it.

          I was surprised by how much dialogue played in my mind by memory, before the characters said it.

          1 vote
          1. Habituallytired
            Link Parent
            This is off topic, but the creators of the show are the same creators of Miraculous if you're interested in another of their projects.

            This is off topic, but the creators of the show are the same creators of Miraculous if you're interested in another of their projects.

            1 vote
  2. [5]
    SloMoMonday
    Link
    I remember this look into the company from a year ago and the company doesn't really make the best arguments for the operation. It's little more than a convoluted and inefficient process to get 10...

    I remember this look into the company from a year ago and the company doesn't really make the best arguments for the operation. It's little more than a convoluted and inefficient process to get 10 nuclear power plants.

    To be most charitable, this could be one of those stepping stone technologies that might lead to something far more practical down the line. Sunlight is technically a signal and there plenty of value across the EM spectrum. Simplist solution would be to ship them off to supplement power generation on the moon or Mars. Or the orbital arrays can be reconfigured for interplanetary data transfers. Or its the building blocks for orbital billboards that will be promising cheap relief to weary space travelers.

    It does ultimately feel like wasted resources given the state of... everything and the project seems more concerned with the optics of being an "infinite growth space company". I'd say it's a few steps below OceanGate where it does genuinely have the potential to do some real environmental harm or even be weaponized against critical infrastructure or agriculture. Or as we've seen in Ukraine, it can just be used on the whims of a techbro or dictator without considering the implications on normal people.

    Speaking about non-viable startups, that was a dime a dozen in the 2010s. Smart street lights. Smart carpets. Smart tattoos. Crypto banks that are illigal almost everywhere on earth. My favorite was a smart chicken farm system with all the ways to optimize every hour of a chickens life for growth. And it was on the verge of working, just before the founders pivoted to agriculture blockchain technology.

    16 votes
    1. Fiachra
      Link Parent
      The absolute worst was that fucking bullshit solar roadways thing that somehow managed to become a meme in a non-derogatory way.

      The absolute worst was that fucking bullshit solar roadways thing that somehow managed to become a meme in a non-derogatory way.

      9 votes
    2. [3]
      Casocial
      Link Parent
      That smart chicken farm mention caught my interest. Do you know where I can read up on it?

      That smart chicken farm mention caught my interest. Do you know where I can read up on it?

      2 votes
      1. [2]
        SloMoMonday
        Link Parent
        So that was a process optimization technology so not exactly built on any cutting edge research. Rather a way to improve efficiency. This project was for Broiler farms that's used for meat...

        So that was a process optimization technology so not exactly built on any cutting edge research. Rather a way to improve efficiency.

        This project was for Broiler farms that's used for meat production and it is actually slightly less nightmare fuel than Battery egg farms. All farms get their chickens from hatcheries by the truckload (you don't even get them at a spesific qty, they just weigh the trucks on entry and exit and bill you on the difference). Hatcheries supply different kinds of chicken that are selectively bread for purpose. And hatcheries will provide you with a step by step instruction book on the optimal conditions to maximize yield for profitability. That optimal yield involves spesific ratios of meat/fat and muscle tenderness and moisture and a ton of other factors that are used to grade produce so it's not just about stuffing the animals with endless growth hormones. And all this information is in a handy 125page instruction manual. There's also decades of research, manuals, farm records and other datasets with useful information because we've put a lot of work into optimizing food production.

        If you look through the manual, you'll see that there are a ton of variables to control, as well as environmental indicators to monitor and adjustments to enact. The most important periods are the first and last 14 days but you can effectively get down to managing every aspect of a chickens life on an hour to hour basis. Many first-world and highly developed farms have been gradually implementing measures and controls to satisfy these conditions and incrementally increasing yields. On the flip side, you have many places where their farming practices haven't changed much since they started operations and there was opportunity to supply them with practical agri-tech that didn't demand a steep capital and time investment.

        The start-up wanted to make starter kits of off-the-shelf sensors that farmers could set up in their broiler houses which all connected to a mesh net of hub devices. The entire solution actually lived on these hubs in cases where the farm lost connectivity, but we "needed" everything to go through our subscription service to access the web interface and mobile app. The farmer would map out their broiler house which we virtualized and would dynamically create optimal mounting points for different sensors. Farmer would then allocate the serialized sensors they had available for the BH and we directed their placement for the best coverage. We would then simulate an optimal broiler house with those parameters and flag any significant deltas from the live feeds. The base kit had a ton of functionality and the farmer could supplement it with our more advanced sensors or integrate third party data feeds. And we supported a lot of data points. A lot more than any farmer could possibly need. On top of standard temp/humidity/lighting, we also supported air flow and water flow sensors that was important to minimizing bacteria growth. We could use top down security cams to identify clumping which could suffocate chicks. We even had simple door sensors because letting a draft in can create chaos as well. But I think the most powerful tool was simply providing checklists and reminders at appropriate times since that's the sort of things that are overlooked when managing large operations. The aim was not to increase any individuals workload or add any major new functions to the farm. Just set and forget hardware that would just fire off occasional alerts and it supplemented analytics to identify points that could be improved.

        We had working prototypes running across four vastly different broiler houses and there were notable gains over the 6 month trial. I even got a major farm interested and we were ready to test in one of their facilities. But it was all pointless because the start-ups founder was a complete fucking idiot. His grand ambition was to track and trace every individual chicken and have their life story on the blockchain. He pretty much wanted it for the entire agriculture sector. Right from the start his pitch was built around the idea of going to a restaurant, getting a QR code with your meal and being able to track every thing that ever happened to every ingredient on that plate. He also wanted to have a giant "command center" where we would have a view of farms all around the world. My favorite was that we needed to save every single byte of data generated because data was going to be the new currency. All crap that did absolutely nothing to actually help our paying clients.

        I can feel my blood pressure spiking just thinking about this guy and all the crap he pulled behind our backs. But it was a pretty interesting project and I actually enjoyed spending weeks on site just talking to farmers and figuring out what was important to the job. I did not enjoy all the techbro startup bullshit I needed to wade through to get to that work and then having all that work be for absolutely nothing.

        10 votes
        1. Englerdy
          Link Parent
          The beginning of that story really did not prepare me for the twist at the end. T.T the engineering challenge sounds really interesting only to find out the founder seemed completely detached from...

          The beginning of that story really did not prepare me for the twist at the end. T.T the engineering challenge sounds really interesting only to find out the founder seemed completely detached from the actual practical problem he could solve. What a shame.

          6 votes
  3. vetch
    Link
    Please contribute any startups you know of that are similarly baffling, or maybe help me understand why this has received money from someone.

    Please contribute any startups you know of that are similarly baffling, or maybe help me understand why this has received money from someone.

    10 votes
  4. [2]
    delphi
    Link
    I really hope these guys will make it, only because it'll be incredibly funny when their infrastructure inevitably gets hacked and we're getting disco ball earth for a night

    I really hope these guys will make it, only because it'll be incredibly funny when their infrastructure inevitably gets hacked and we're getting disco ball earth for a night

    6 votes
    1. myrrh
      Link Parent
      🎵disco inferno🎶

      🎵disco inferno🎶

      2 votes
  5. jcd
    Link
    You were supposed to cool the earth and fight global warming, not heat it up (much less burn it up). This will end in tears

    You were supposed to cool the earth and fight global warming, not heat it up (much less burn it up). This will end in tears

    6 votes
  6. [2]
    MimicSquid
    Link
    Something I don't know whether people have considered; This network of satellites is essentially a directed energy weapon against anything else in orbit. It's non-destructive, but also satellites...

    Something I don't know whether people have considered; This network of satellites is essentially a directed energy weapon against anything else in orbit. It's non-destructive, but also satellites aren't necessarily designed to handle a lot of extra energy being pumped into them. Even if it's a temporary disruption while the cooling systems resolve the situation, being able to turn off other people's satellites on command is the sort of power pretty much monopolized by the largest powers.

    6 votes
    1. vektor
      Link Parent
      Depends on the scale. They advertise that the illumnated spot is 5km min, meaning you're not getting a very tight focus here. If my understanding of optics and thermodynamics is right, in order to...

      Depends on the scale. They advertise that the illumnated spot is 5km min, meaning you're not getting a very tight focus here. If my understanding of optics and thermodynamics is right, in order to heat something as hot as sunlight does, you'd have to have your optics be the apparent size (as in, the size in your visual field, expressed in degrees^2) be the size of the sun. Wanna heat something with more intensity than the sun could? You need more apparent size. You'd need a pretty damn big mirror, or a whole lot of them, to get significantly more intensity than the sun. Want 10 times the power of the sun? At 600km distance, you need a 17km aperture, or 100 1.7km apertures, etc., assuming you can focus the energy onto a point, and they can't. As for the temperature you can reach on-target, your equilibrium temperature is the 4th root of the energy you put in. (You hardly ever see 4th powers/roots in nature, btw), so the power of 10 suns gives you not 10 times the temperature on any scale, but 1.7 times the (solar exposure) temperature in K.

      I doubt this makes for an effective ASAT weapon. And I think if you wanted to make it one, you'd have to send up mirrors that look a lot more like orbital ASAT DEWs than flat mirrors, and deploy them on different orbits.

      1 vote
  7. [4]
    Grayscail
    (edited )
    Link
    My question is how precise of a spot size do they expect to be able to resolve? Focusing light to a small range is made a bit difficult by wave diffraction effects. Its not necessarily infeasible,...

    My question is how precise of a spot size do they expect to be able to resolve?

    Focusing light to a small range is made a bit difficult by wave diffraction effects. Its not necessarily infeasible, but I wonder if they have done the math to figure out how many mirrors over how big a range would be necessary to illuminate, say, a single football field to daylight conditions.

    I also wonder how well such an array would be able to illuminate multiple scattered locations at once. I guess with holographic mirrors they could be configured to target multiple points, but youd still be splitting the power by doing that, so each new customer would require more mirrors to catch more light.

    4 votes
    1. [3]
      Weldawadyathink
      Link Parent
      On their website, they claim to be targeting a “precise” 5km range. That changes my opinion entirely. When I thought it could target like a 5m radius, I could see some helpful uses. But at 5km, I...

      On their website, they claim to be targeting a “precise” 5km range.

      That changes my opinion entirely. When I thought it could target like a 5m radius, I could see some helpful uses. But at 5km, I can’t see any use for these outside solar farms. And we still have so much space to install solar panels on earth, is making them slightly more efficient really a better option than just building a few more and some batteries?

      13 votes
      1. [2]
        nukeman
        Link Parent
        5 km is useful for sporting events like the Olympics or World Cup.

        5 km is useful for sporting events like the Olympics or World Cup.

        3 votes
        1. Grayscail
          Link Parent
          Maybe, but I feel like those are situations where you could easily just hold your event during the daytime. Or use lights. I would think this sort of scheme to be useful for people who NEED to...

          Maybe, but I feel like those are situations where you could easily just hold your event during the daytime. Or use lights.

          I would think this sort of scheme to be useful for people who NEED to operate at night, consistently.

          4 votes
  8. [6]
    AnxiousCucumber
    Link
    What happens during cloudy weather?

    What happens during cloudy weather?

    4 votes
    1. [5]
      ThrowdoBaggins
      Link Parent
      Really bright clouds /noise

      Really bright clouds

      /noise

      3 votes
      1. [4]
        macleod
        Link Parent
        ...perhaps strong enough to burn through the clouds, I can get on board with some purposeful climate engineering....

        ...perhaps strong enough to burn through the clouds, I can get on board with some purposeful climate engineering....

        1. [3]
          Grayscail
          Link Parent
          I dont think you can burn clouds

          I dont think you can burn clouds

          1. MimicSquid
            Link Parent
            Clouds are water vapor and/or ice crystals that have reached a height where it's cold enough for it to start to condense but not yet combine into droplets or crystals large enough to fall. A...

            Clouds are water vapor and/or ice crystals that have reached a height where it's cold enough for it to start to condense but not yet combine into droplets or crystals large enough to fall. A heat/light beam wouldn't burn the cloud, but it would disperse its mass through targeted heat, and that's close enough for most people.

            1 vote
          2. macleod
            Link Parent
            No, but we can try. If anything we can literally vaporize them.

            No, but we can try.

            If anything we can literally vaporize them.

  9. [13]
    macleod
    Link
    Surprisingly possible. They redirect solar beams to on the ground areas for power generation, construction lighting, can also aid farming in areas with too little sunlight. It's a fascinating...

    Surprisingly possible. They redirect solar beams to on the ground areas for power generation, construction lighting, can also aid farming in areas with too little sunlight. It's a fascinating idea, and an idea that I support scientifically, commercially I would have to see it in action and gauge if it causes meaningful nighttime light pollution.

    3 votes
    1. [5]
      kaffo
      Link Parent
      I mean I think the idea is cool. It's the 30,000 extra satellites in orbit which makes me uncomfortable. We've got enough crap in orbit and it's only going to get worse.

      I mean I think the idea is cool. It's the 30,000 extra satellites in orbit which makes me uncomfortable. We've got enough crap in orbit and it's only going to get worse.

      19 votes
      1. [2]
        kari
        Link Parent
        Yeah, FWIW, there are "only" ~16,000 satellites in orbit right now (with 10,000 of those being Starlink...)

        Yeah, FWIW, there are "only" ~16,000 satellites in orbit right now (with 10,000 of those being Starlink...)

        9 votes
        1. Habituallytired
          Link Parent
          I don't think that is a very good ratio. I had no idea they had such a huge majority of satellites in orbit.

          I don't think that is a very good ratio. I had no idea they had such a huge majority of satellites in orbit.

          2 votes
      2. Omnicrola
        Link Parent
        We've indeed got more than enough crap in orbit, and I have several astronomer friends who curse every time a Starlink flies over head. And those satellites weren't built to shine light on things.

        We've indeed got more than enough crap in orbit, and I have several astronomer friends who curse every time a Starlink flies over head. And those satellites weren't built to shine light on things.

        7 votes
      3. macleod
        Link Parent
        L1-L5 is massive amount of room, we barely have anything up there. The problem rests on low earth orbit satellites, mainly for communication. These iirc can fit comfortable in the L2-L3 range...

        L1-L5 is massive amount of room, we barely have anything up there. The problem rests on low earth orbit satellites, mainly for communication.

        These iirc can fit comfortable in the L2-L3 range which isn't even noticeable.

        4 votes
    2. ThrowdoBaggins
      Link Parent
      Given the website is already vying for military attention, my worry about it being misused is substantially outweighing any of my delight at the positive possibilities. I’m just imagining the...

      Given the website is already vying for military attention, my worry about it being misused is substantially outweighing any of my delight at the positive possibilities.

      I’m just imagining the catastrophic results of sudden daylight brightness on a 5km length of freeway at night, or an airport or dock, or just randomly in population centres every night for a week in the lead up to a military invasion so that everyone is sleep deprived, or a dozen other applications I can think of.

      7 votes
    3. [3]
      Grayscail
      Link Parent
      Has there been actual demonstrations of doing this? Im somewhat skeptical of the engineering requirements behind such a setup.

      Has there been actual demonstrations of doing this? Im somewhat skeptical of the engineering requirements behind such a setup.

      5 votes
      1. [2]
        Toric
        Link Parent
        Not of this exact thing, but a company like this is typically how you get a demonstration. They can piggyback a bit off of NASA's solar sail research, but thats about it.

        Not of this exact thing, but a company like this is typically how you get a demonstration. They can piggyback a bit off of NASA's solar sail research, but thats about it.

        1. macleod
          Link Parent
          According to Wikipedia, we have already done this as a species, USSR/Russia did: This link shows what the sat looked like in orbit.

          According to Wikipedia, we have already done this as a species, USSR/Russia did:

          The only such device flown before was Znamya, designed by the Soviet Union and launched by Russia. Znamya 2, deployed from a Progress cargo craft near the Mir space station in February 1993, unfurled a 20 m mylar reflector and briefly cast a moonlight-bright, roughly 5 km spot across Europe.^[7]^ The follow-on mission, Znamya 2.5, failed during deployment in 1999 due to human error.^[6]^^[8]^

          The mirror deployed successfully, and, when illuminated, produced a 5 km wide bright spot, which traversed Europe from southern France to western Russia at a speed of 8 km/s.^[2]^ The bright spot had a luminosity equivalent to approximately that of a full moon.^[3]^ Although clouds covered much of Europe that morning, a few ground observers reported seeing a flash of light as the beam swept by

          The Znamya 2.5 was a successor to the Znamya 2, which was deployed on 5 February 1999. It had a diameter of 25 m, and was expected to produce a bright spot 7 km in diameter, with luminosity between five and ten full moons. However, soon after deployment, the mirror caught on an antenna on the Progress, and ripped.

          This link shows what the sat looked like in orbit.

          3 votes
    4. papasquat
      Link Parent
      At what point does launching tens of thousands of mirrors into orbit become cheaper than just driving some industrial lighting systems out to a site though? I can't imagine this ever being the...

      At what point does launching tens of thousands of mirrors into orbit become cheaper than just driving some industrial lighting systems out to a site though? I can't imagine this ever being the economical choice.

      3 votes
    5. [2]
      vetch
      Link Parent
      I don't doubt that it's possible to do - at considerable effort and expense - the question I ask is why? Even without knowing the specifics, the idea that replacing any of these areas with this...

      I don't doubt that it's possible to do - at considerable effort and expense - the question I ask is why?
      Even without knowing the specifics, the idea that replacing any of these areas with this technology seems a little absurd no? Construction projects currently use, well, big lights? I don't know that much about farming but I would imagine it is far more impacted by rainfall and weather generally than lighting, and for energy generation it seems unlikely that a 1% boost is going to make up for the cost of putting 3 times more satellites than currently exist in orbit.

      2 votes
      1. IsildursBane
        Link Parent
        My in laws are farmers in a location with irrigation and decently long growing season. Weather and rain are bigger impacts than sunlight for them. Freezing is a big factor as well for farming, so...

        I don't know that much about farming but I would imagine it is far more impacted by rainfall and weather generally than lighting

        My in laws are farmers in a location with irrigation and decently long growing season. Weather and rain are bigger impacts than sunlight for them. Freezing is a big factor as well for farming, so in more northern areas, it isn't that they don't get enough sunlight that limits their season, but waiting for their fields to dry from snow melt before they can plant and then hoping there is enough time before frost starts to happen in the fall.

        3 votes
  10. [4]
    Noox
    Link
    I have no idea what they do, even though I read what was on the page. What do they do???

    I have no idea what they do, even though I read what was on the page. What do they do???

    1 vote
    1. [3]
      kaffo
      Link Parent
      They want to put 30,000+ satellites with mirrors in orbit in the next 10 years to allow... Anyone with an app? To direct a spot of sunlight with an adjustable diameter and intensity to anywhere on...

      They want to put 30,000+ satellites with mirrors in orbit in the next 10 years to allow... Anyone with an app? To direct a spot of sunlight with an adjustable diameter and intensity to anywhere on Earth at any time.

      So like, you out at 2am drunk and lost your keys outside the bar? No probs, just order a spot or sunlight to your location!

      14 votes
      1. CptBluebear
        Link Parent
        I'm going to go out on a limb and say that the bar-going person losing their keys isn't their target demographic. They're going for the bar owner, no scratch that, the billionaire owning the real...

        I'm going to go out on a limb and say that the bar-going person losing their keys isn't their target demographic. They're going for the bar owner, no scratch that, the billionaire owning the real estate in the neighbourhood the bar is operating in.

        15 votes
      2. vektor
        Link Parent
        min 5km, because it's only flat mirrors. Their use cases is flood light on-demand for industrial sites, solar power, agriculture. Not finding your keys, unless you've got a search party and need...

        adjustable diameter

        min 5km, because it's only flat mirrors. Their use cases is flood light on-demand for industrial sites, solar power, agriculture. Not finding your keys, unless you've got a search party and need to sweep a 5km diameter area.

  11. post_below
    Link
    This is a weird mix of hilarious and kinda sorta maybe viable. How many countries are going to approve people being able to arbitrarily light up the night and otherwise cause chaos on demand?...

    This is a weird mix of hilarious and kinda sorta maybe viable. How many countries are going to approve people being able to arbitrarily light up the night and otherwise cause chaos on demand? Seems like a risky bet to launch a bunch of satellites and then get regulated into oblivion after the fact (and rightly so).

    1 vote
  12. stu2b50
    Link
    To play devils advocate, if you think about what lighting looks like in a renewable world, you absorb the energy of the sun with solar panels (at a fairly low efficiency), then store it in a...

    To play devils advocate, if you think about what lighting looks like in a renewable world, you absorb the energy of the sun with solar panels (at a fairly low efficiency), then store it in a battery (at fairly low efficiency), then pipe it out at night to power LED lights. If you directly reflect from the sun, it skips many of the efficiency-loss energy transformation steps.

    Do I think it’s likely it’ll work out? Not really. But they only have FAA permission to launch a single satellite to test engineering feasibility. So it doesn’t really matter either. The only way we get a constellation of these things is if it does work out.

    It’ll probably fail and get acquihired by SpaceX or blue origin. That’s OK.

    1 vote
  13. vektor
    (edited )
    Link
    I want to see a realistic artist's rendition or render of what this would look like. I know there's volumetric renderers that can accurately render shadows cast through atmosphere, such as...

    I want to see a realistic artist's rendition or render of what this would look like. I know there's volumetric renderers that can accurately render shadows cast through atmosphere, such as godrays. I want to see what this one looks like. I suspect it's actually somewhat tame, if they're using many small satellites? In the upper atmosphere, any volume will have rather low intensity and thus be not very bright, it's only in the lower atmosphere directly above the site things get more intense. So if you're standing just outside that 5km spot, the sky might look very interesting.

    Can someone render that? I think their marketing renders try to undersell the light pollution aspects, but at least in simulation I think it'd be cool to see.

    1 vote
  14. lelio
    Link
    I don't know anything about this company but mirrors in space are likely going to be important to humanity if we ever get around to trying to maintain our planet. Mirrors could theoretically...

    I don't know anything about this company but mirrors in space are likely going to be important to humanity if we ever get around to trying to maintain our planet. Mirrors could theoretically deflect sunlight away as well if they are positioned at L1. Being able to control the amount and distribution of our main source of heat and energy seems worth a try.
    It requires such a scale that I wonder if its worth doing before we are able to make them in space from asteroids though. The energy and effort to launch so many satellites out of a gravity well seems excessive.

    1 vote