Ethoscore beta round two - and thank you!
For anyone that missed round one, the Ethoscore Project is a conscious consumerism platform that's in invite only beta. Invites are only available to Tildes users. Reply to the top level comment below for an invite.
There have been a lot of updates since my first post, many of which are thanks to feedback from Tildoes. I'm so grateful for all of the feedback, it was incredibly helpful.
Here are some highlights:
- New scoring UI. Quite a few people commented about scoring, one of my takeaways was that the old display gave people the impression that scoring was meant to be, essentially, perfect. Another takeaway was that scoring kinda took center stage and obscured the rest of the functionality when, from my perspective, scoring isn't the most interesting part. I'm not sure how much the changes will help, we'll see! Thanks to: @MimicSquid @Autoxidation @Kilcundas @fnulare @atomicshoreline for scoring related comments and feedback. See below for more notes about scoring.
- Company types i18n. @Lia pointed out that the company types were US-centric (public, private, etc.). I decided the best way to solve that was to run the various company type designations through a selection of pre-AI global english text corpuses, including GloWbe. It turned out that the types were already pretty close. 'Public' company won globally at 52% usage, so no need for a change there. The runner up was 'listed' at 33%. Similar for 'private' which won at 92%. 'Cooperative' and 'nonprofit' also won. The one designation that needed an update was 'government', which I've changed to 'state-owned' which came in first at 62%.
- Company locations. Locations now include the country in all cases rather than just some. Thanks to @xothist for the feedback.
- Companies page table sort. I've expanded this in various ways including: Added 'employees' to the custom sort column so that it's possible to sort by an approximation of company size. Thanks to @fnulare
- Companies page table. Filters now include tags and company type. Also added a tags column (when screen size allows). Thanks to @Lia and @Kilcundas
- Company profile pages. Headquarters location now shows up earlier (thanks @xothist). There's now a 'lists' stub that shows all lists a company show up on (thanks @CannibalisticApple).
- Homepage trending companies. The display now includes lists and tags. Thanks to @Lia and @Kilcundas and everyone who commented on scoring.
- New scoring impacts. This is ongoing, researching scoring impacts takes time and a lot of companies continue to lack full scoring impacts. In some cases the baseline scoring gets it right without impacts, in a lot of cases it doesn't. That's ok! Scores will keep improving, especially when users start to contribute scoring impacts. And scores aren't everything, lists can do all of the work for many usecases without scoring mattering very much at all. Maybe a couple dozen more companies (along with 100's of brands) now have full scoring impacts since round 1, including all companies on the Champions and Villians lists. Thanks to @atomicshoreline @fnulare and @Autoxidation for comments about scores that looked wrong.
- New companies added. This is also ongoing, thanks to @Lia for the new company suggestion.
- B Corp certification now positively impacts all metrics instead of just ethics. This one wasn't based on specific feedback, just the dawning realization that b corps are consistently better than the alternatives in every case I've researched so far.
- Local Vaultwarden calls no longer trip bot protection. Thanks to @F13
- Mobile safari bugfix. Thanks to @umbrae
- Metric badge clicks on company pages now link to impacts details when available. Thanks to @user who didn't make it into my notes!
- 'Still in Russia' tag added. The tag (and a companion list) covers all companies in the database that are still doing business in russia. Thanks to @crulife
- Opt in email updates. Thanks to @Kilcundas. You didn't suggest it, but your comments reminded me I hadn't done it yet. RSS updates are on the list!
- Barcode scanning improvements. Right now there are about 3 million barcodes covered, with fallbacks for codes that aren't.
There's also a new blog post: Fossil fuel against the world (you'll need an invite read it, still trying to avoid bot traffic for now). This post is based on the research for the Climate Deception and Climate Policy Obstruction tags which I did just before round 1. The goal is to make it easier to identify and avoid companies that have worked against sane climate policy and action. You might be interested in these @crulife
Thanks also to everyone else who participated by testing, commenting or DMing, including: @Eric_the_Cerise @ThrowdoBaggins @phoenixrises @SleventhTower @Mikie @ajwish @jmpavlec @ilTofa @Sycamore @vord @Drynyn @ogre @polle @Deely
Sorry if I missed anyone, there were a lot of signups from invite links I posted in the thread before I realized that was drawing a lot of bot traffic. Any of those who never commented or messaged are probably missing.
Finally, a note about scoring: If scores didn't exist at all, I believe the app would still serve the purpose of giving people an easier way to choose companies to support and avoid via the lists and tags features. Especially once there's a community creating and sharing lists. Or I guess at this point, if there's a community. I've spent a lot of time thinking about the scoring system since round 1 because for some users it was more distracting than useful. Tweaking the user experience so that the purpose and functionality of the app is more intuitive is still a work in progress.
As before all feedback is welcome, good or bad. And even just playing with the app without commenting at all helps. Seeing how people interact with it is invaluable. In round 1 there was exactly one barcode scan, so if anyone feels inspired to scan a few barcodes you'll have the undying gratitude of an internet stranger. Your chances of a scan giving you useful results will be higher with well known brands. There are currently about 15,500 brands and companies covered.
Wait, I was the only person in the whole test who scanned something? It was just to show my wife how it worked. Which I guess is kind of the point. I showed my wife Mondelev's poor score, and she said she didn't need a website to tell her that a large food corporation was going to be shady as shit. For me it best serves a purpose when I run across something novel.
Yep just you! Fortunately some of my personal invites have done a lot of scans so it's not entirely untested.
Re: Mondelēz, yeah it's not a surprise that they suck. And they actually likely suck more than their current score, it hasn't had a full scoring run yet. The useful thing with a conglomerate like that is tying their 100+ brands to them (i.e. Nabisco). They also own brands you wouldn't expect like the highly health focused, erstwhile family owned Perfect Bar.
Reply here for an invite (or send me a DM)
I'd be interested in an invite!
Sent, thanks for checking it out!