24 votes

What is your favorite Final Fantasy game?

More importantly: why? Tell us precisely what makes your favorite so great!

(Also, if you can't pick just one, feel free to share your love for several.)

44 comments

  1. NonoAdomo
    (edited )
    Link
    Final Fantasy XIV, and it's no contest. I feel like everyone who likes it has a story on how it changed their lives in some way, shape or form. I'd like to take a moment for myself here and just...
    • Exemplary

    Final Fantasy XIV, and it's no contest. I feel like everyone who likes it has a story on how it changed their lives in some way, shape or form. I'd like to take a moment for myself here and just go over how it changed my life for me.

    I have always been someone who makes more friends online than in the real world. Growing up in the middle of nowhere with nobody your age around you puts you in a position to seek those bonds elsewhere. I tried with the online group I was rolling with at the time to play FFXI (the first MMO) and found that I was late to the party. For those who don't know, FFXI was horribly grindy in the early gen MMO way. It would take ages to go anywhere or do anything. Leveling was an atrociously long affair. I have yet to play another game that even comes close to the amount of effort it took to do that. I stuck around as long as I did because of friends, but after a while I realized I was just going from killing enemies in the dunes to killing enemies in the forest. Standing in a corner and just beating the hell out of digital mobs for pocket change levels of XP just wore away. It was around this time they announced that that FFXIV was in development. I knew my experience in FFXI, and I knew I wanted to get in on the ground floor to get the most of it.

    I built myself a new computer around this time, knowing that there was a graphical improvement from FFXI's PS2 era graphics. Eventually FFXIV came out into public beta testing and I was there. I wanted to be a part of that first wave! For those who don't know, this was is referred to as: FFXIV 1.0. This was also a game that was an abject failure by all accounts. It was super confusing to navigate due to the vast distances between places and littered with unnecessary daily and weekly caps because of a very prominent Japanese fear at the time of people turning into Hikikimori, or shut ins who just isolated themselves and played video games without a lick of real person-to-person interaction. Needless to say, many people (including myself) bounced off of it fast. It was REALLY pretty though (for it's time).

    Eventually, they replaced the Director with (the now legendary) Yoshi-P who took one look at the situation and made the bold move of just resetting the game. For those who don't know, they had a whole narrative event where the lesser moon Dalamud just crept closer and closer to the word, Majora's Mask style where eventually broke open, had a demi-god pop out of it and essentially destroy the world with an epic cutscene. A few years later, the team had rebuilt the game as FFXIV: A Realm Reborn and I was back in on the public alpha and beta.

    FFXIV ARR was awesome. An absolute night and day difference that scratched that itch of MMO that nothing had been able to successfully do in a long time. It was a big enough release that even some of the fellow gamer nerds at my office were eager to get in on it. I joined them, and we started a Free Company. It was exciting, and it was tons of fun. We met others in the game who joined our FC and made a big, happy online family that worked hard to beat the game's hardest challenges. My office friends eventually drifted away, but I stayed with the game. I made plenty of lifelong friends and also met my wife (we've been married for 6 years now) and even have moved from the US to Canada to be with her. This game literally changed my life in ways that I couldn't imagine. For this I will always be thankful. My user name online is now just my FFXIV character name, as it's the first time in my many years online that I feel that I have a name that actually fits me and who I am.

    Obviously, if you're wondering what this game is like for you, someone who just wants to play an interesting game, I would highly recommend this one. Think of this game as a long JRPG with a heavy multiplayer focus. Multiplayer is not required, as they have added tons of solo play NPCs that can help, but honestly I recommend leaning into it. Overall the community is full of helpful people who just want to enjoy themselves as well, so your negative interactions will honestly be minimal compared to other online multiplayer games.

    Each major expansion is essentially a whole JRPGs worth of content, full of story, cutscenes and locations to visit. Honestly, if I were to recommend this game (which I do), I wouldn't sell it as a game, but as a high quality story. It's like trying to convince someone to read your favorite fantasy novel series. Yes, it's going to take you a while to get through it, but the journey is so worthwhile. The emotional highs and lows, the visual designs of the world, the ambiance of the music... it all comes together in a way that, after Shadowbringers, solidified it as the best Final Fantasy story for me. I don't think my opinion will ever change, honestly. (Emet-Selch is the best FF antagonist, Sephiroth is a chump in comparison) Finishing the primary story arc in Endwalker, I felt an incredibly satisfying conclusion to a story that took nearly a decade of my life to finish and I implore anyone else interested to try.

    I haven't tried Dawntrail yet. I think my wife and I are going to wait a bit before we do. In our depths of FFXIV adventures, quite a few other games have built up that we wish to play and we have to chisel through our backlog more before we head back into FFXIV for a brand new adventure.

    14 votes
  2. [5]
    kingofsnake
    Link
    Tactics, only because it was a fresh approach to a big budget, story driven RPG with the best elements of Tactics Ogre attached. I'm playing Shining Force 3 right now -- a title that came out at...

    Tactics, only because it was a fresh approach to a big budget, story driven RPG with the best elements of Tactics Ogre attached.

    I'm playing Shining Force 3 right now -- a title that came out at around the same time -- and it's so evident how FFT took the philosophy of games like SF and deepened it immensely.

    14 votes
    1. [4]
      ebonGavia
      Link Parent
      Agree 100%. The story is unbelievably good, even if the translation suffers a bit Soundtrack is top 5 easily, amazingly good Gameplay is incredible. The Battle Mechanics guide can be found online...

      Agree 100%.

      • The story is unbelievably good, even if the translation suffers a bit
      • Soundtrack is top 5 easily, amazingly good
      • Gameplay is incredible. The Battle Mechanics guide can be found online which details everything. It gets a little unbalanced late game but it's balanced around regular players, not nuts like me who leveled the whole roster down and back up several times to min-max
      1. [3]
        kingofsnake
        Link Parent
        I loved breaking it back in the day. Before the internet and YouTube, you really felt like the only hacker in town

        I loved breaking it back in the day. Before the internet and YouTube, you really felt like the only hacker in town

        1 vote
        1. [2]
          ebonGavia
          Link Parent
          I assume your level 99 Calculator with 94 Faith was casting Holy on the whole enemy team just like mine was?

          I assume your level 99 Calculator with 94 Faith was casting Holy on the whole enemy team just like mine was?

          1. kingofsnake
            Link Parent
            Haha, basically. I'm amazed at how that job could be exploited

            Haha, basically. I'm amazed at how that job could be exploited

            1 vote
  3. Wafik
    Link
    FF6. I had played FF4 and loved it. I saw that FF6 was coming out and wanted it, but was a kid with no money. So I polished my parents entire brass bed frame to earn enough money to buy it. Then I...

    FF6. I had played FF4 and loved it. I saw that FF6 was coming out and wanted it, but was a kid with no money. So I polished my parents entire brass bed frame to earn enough money to buy it. Then I went on to play through it multiple times. Even playing it 4 players so my friends could play in combat. Beyond the memories, I loved the story and thought Kefka was the perfect villain. Even though I had the map, waking up in the World of Ruin blew my mind. I thought the esper system of learning magic was better than most. I love that each character has their own unique thing. I could go on but this is already long

    FF Tactics is a very close second. I had never played a game like tactics, so that alone was amazing to me. I thought the political story was amazing and one of the best in gaming. Also I find the job system near perfect and haven't found other versions of it near as good.

    14 votes
  4. [4]
    Lapbunny
    (edited )
    Link
    I have played 1, 2, 4, 4 DS, 5, 6, 7, 7R, 8, 9, 10, 14, Tactics, A2, Crystal Chronicles, and Dissidia all in some regard. ... I have not completed a single one of those games. I adore the...

    I have played 1, 2, 4, 4 DS, 5, 6, 7, 7R, 8, 9, 10, 14, Tactics, A2, Crystal Chronicles, and Dissidia all in some regard.

    ... I have not completed a single one of those games. I adore the aesthetic. I love Amano's style. I love the music to pieces. I love the weird mixes of mechs and magic. I love the lofty plots. I just cannot sit through the ATB system long enough, I stopped playing at Zeromus in 4 because I Action Replayed a bajillion Elixers to get to the end and he would wipe me out in one Big Bang, I lost to some endgame boss in 5 and just stopped, I found A2 to be horribly designed with the rules system, I died of embarrassment wiping myself on a Bomb in 14 in front of my friend, and I tried playing CC by myself... Eugh. I only really got into it via Kingdom Hearts, and when my friend bounced off the games he sold them to me for like $10 each, so I'd play the PS1 games every Saturday mornings on my PS2, and then stop after like. The first disc. No idea why, I guess I just didn't like the games themselves enough.

    I still think 4's story is so wonderfully melodramatic (everyone's dead! everyone's alive!), 5's job system is the most fun thing within the ATB system, 7's aesthetic is unparalleled, Dissidia feels great, and I found 14's community to be so wonderfully social and easygoing. I'd say 7 purely out of nostalgia; I spent $25 on its soundtrack off iTunes (I wouldn't DARE keep the mp3 files off Galbadia Hotel for more than 24 hours, George Bush was watching), and I downloaded it over a period of 3 overnights on a 56k connection. Then I listened to the entire thing on repeat because I loved the soundtrack so much. Still do.

    11 votes
    1. [3]
      thumbsupemoji
      Link Parent
      I feel you haha—I thoroughly enjoyed almost every second of Chrono Trigger, but FF is a different beast. Even octopath is too cutscene-heavy and convoluted for me.

      I feel you haha—I thoroughly enjoyed almost every second of Chrono Trigger, but FF is a different beast. Even octopath is too cutscene-heavy and convoluted for me.

      3 votes
      1. [2]
        Britimmer
        Link Parent
        I started Octopath on game pass and I keep wondering when I get to do something. Is it just walking from dialog heavy cutscene to dialog heavy cutscene?

        I started Octopath on game pass and I keep wondering when I get to do something. Is it just walking from dialog heavy cutscene to dialog heavy cutscene?

        1 vote
        1. thumbsupemoji
          Link Parent
          That’s as far as I made it at least haha

          That’s as far as I made it at least haha

          1 vote
  5. [4]
    Baeocystin
    Link
    FF VII. First game I played on my won-at-a-raffle PlayStation, something I could never have otherwise afforded as a broke student. It was my first exposure to JRPGs, and the music utterly...

    FF VII. First game I played on my won-at-a-raffle PlayStation, something I could never have otherwise afforded as a broke student. It was my first exposure to JRPGs, and the music utterly captivated me. Still get chills when I hear One-Winged Angel.

    8 votes
    1. [2]
      Mendanbar
      Link Parent
      I was once driving down a twisty forest road and starting to worry I was lost. Then a mariachi version of the FF7 battle theme came on. I nearly turned the car around right there.

      I was once driving down a twisty forest road and starting to worry I was lost. Then a mariachi version of the FF7 battle theme came on. I nearly turned the car around right there.

      2 votes
    2. ebonGavia
      Link Parent
      I first played this on one of those old demo consoles they used to have set up at Walmart. I bought a PS because of that game lol.

      I first played this on one of those old demo consoles they used to have set up at Walmart. I bought a PS because of that game lol.

      2 votes
  6. [3]
    Kawa
    Link
    I don't think I can realistically say anything other than 14 at this point. I mean, yeah obviously you can have a transcendant experience with a game that only lasts a certain amount of hours and...

    I don't think I can realistically say anything other than 14 at this point.

    I mean, yeah obviously you can have a transcendant experience with a game that only lasts a certain amount of hours and then it has run its course, and have that be higher value than something else you played a lot more... unless you decide to speedrun it for years and years or something.

    But we don't even have to get into the hypothetical because while I adore single player titles like FF7 and FF12, FF14 has brought me so much long-term joy, it has told me entertaining stories (and all I ever ask for is a good excuse to put me in an arena with a boss, at all difficulty levels, so even when narrative is not at its best there's still a whole lot of raiding to do when all the cutscenes are over), it has connected me with people all over the world, it has pushed me to accomplish things in gaming that I thought I might never have, and turned me into a more confident gamer overall. It turned me into a raider.

    It's not just because of the hours, it's because these are quality hours.

    I love this game!!!!!!!

    7 votes
    1. DesktopMonitor
      Link Parent
      As a cisgender male who plays a spritely girl with a curated collection of color-coordinated seasonal outfits and as someone who can now confidently compliment players on their adorable and...

      it has pushed me to accomplish things in gaming that I thought I might never have, and turned me into a more confident gamer overall

      As a cisgender male who plays a spritely girl with a curated collection of color-coordinated seasonal outfits and as someone who can now confidently compliment players on their adorable and handsome glams while grinding dungeons, I completely agree with this comment.

      3 votes
    2. Promonk
      Link Parent
      Holy shit! Well, at least Malcolm Gladwell can never question your bona fides.

      Holy shit! Well, at least Malcolm Gladwell can never question your bona fides.

      2 votes
  7. [4]
    fefellama
    (edited )
    Link
    2-way tie between FF Tactics Advance for the GBA and FFXII for the PS2 which has been remastered into FFXII: The Zodiac Age Final Fantasy Tactics Advance: just hooked me on the story of Ivalice....

    2-way tie between FF Tactics Advance for the GBA and FFXII for the PS2 which has been remastered into FFXII: The Zodiac Age


    Final Fantasy Tactics Advance: just hooked me on the story of Ivalice. The kids playing with snowballs. The little kid who was bullied IRL but then wakes up in a whole new world where he can do anything. It was an isekai before I even knew what an isekai even was. Pure nostalgia for me at this point and I still boot up a ROM of it from time to time. Endless customizations and options for characters and classes and jobs and missions and you even create your own map. I've tried the original tactics before but the story never gripped me like the GBA game did.


    FFXII: I'll never pass up an opportunity to talk up that magnificent gambit system. Nowadays I'm sure there are plenty of games that do similar things, but like twenty years ago that shit blew my mind. It's basically programming in an RPG world. You have characters in your parties, and can use different abilities and weapons and skills and whatever, just like other FF games. But the gambit system allowed you to set certain rules for how those party members would interact with each other, enemies, and everything else. For example, on a very basic level you can set things like 'IF [enemy, any] IS WEAK TO [fire] -> CAST [firaga]' or 'IF [ally, any] HIT POINTS [<60%] -> CAST [curaga]'. But you could have tons of these for each party member, and the level of granularity you could get with this system was incredible. Endless hours of customizing my team's gambits to make use of everyone's skills in a way that ensured as little input from me as possible.

    Oh and the gambits weren't just like options that you could just set from the get-go. They were items in the game that you had to find, buy, and unlock. So being able to craft the perfect team was just part of the fun and progression of the game, not just some menu that you set once and forget about. You are constantly editing your gambit loadout as you find new and better gambits that allow for an even more finely tuned and tailored system for your team.

    Like I'd have one guy dual-wielding a katana slashing the shit out of everyone he could see and the rest of the team just standing back and perpetually casting things like berserk and haste on him while healing and protecting him from damage. My proudest accomplishment in that game was managing to create an endless loop of gambits when I realized that there was this one slime enemy that regenerated, so I set my team to only target that slime until it broke off into smaller slimes, but then only attack some of the pieces until the rest healed back up, thus gaining xp while allowing the main slime to regenerate from the leftover pieces and then rinse and repeat, then leaving my PS2 going while I went to school (I was like twelve at the time) and coming home 8+ hours later to find a massively boosted party that had gained many levels without me having to lift a finger.

    6 votes
    1. [3]
      Akir
      Link Parent
      FFTA is not well liked by most of the public, but I genuinely think it's one of the best things Square or Square Enix has ever made. The art is fantastic, the music is even better than it's...

      FFTA is not well liked by most of the public, but I genuinely think it's one of the best things Square or Square Enix has ever made. The art is fantastic, the music is even better than it's predecessor (which is an achievement all on it's own), and it's probably the most fun and whimsical setting I've ever seen in any game that I've been able to take seriously - I don't get that "it's just a dumb kids game" energy from it.

      As much as people hate the Laws system it introduced, I actually really enjoyed it. It prevented players from trying to keep cheesing the same strategies over and over again, and it was fun to watch you opponents break the laws and be punished. It added a bit of controlled chaos into a genre that can often get very repetitive. Best of all, it was one more thing that helped enforce a balance and prevent players from breaking the game like FFT could be. The overall gameplay design is so much more polished in comparison.

      2 votes
      1. [2]
        fefellama
        Link Parent
        Agreed! I didn't know it was not well liked. In my small group of friends we all love it since we used to play it together at school. So maybe we are all just nostalgic for it. But like you said,...

        Agreed! I didn't know it was not well liked. In my small group of friends we all love it since we used to play it together at school. So maybe we are all just nostalgic for it. But like you said, the story, setting, music, art, and pretty much everything else in the game was fantastic.

        1 vote
        1. Akir
          Link Parent
          To be fair, opinion has softened on it, but the couple of years after it came out there was a vocal group of detractors. And then of course seemingly nobody bought FFTA2....

          To be fair, opinion has softened on it, but the couple of years after it came out there was a vocal group of detractors.

          And then of course seemingly nobody bought FFTA2....

          1 vote
  8. Mendanbar
    (edited )
    Link
    Final Fantasy 7 for PC. At the time it felt like a huge leap. The style brought something very different, and the scope of the world with all the extras to find was incredible. I first played it...

    Final Fantasy 7 for PC.

    At the time it felt like a huge leap. The style brought something very different, and the scope of the world with all the extras to find was incredible.

    I first played it one summer during a heatwave (Midwest US) and the extra strain on my graphics card would cause the whole PC to overheat and lock up. I ended up taking the side of my case off and setting a box fan next to the PC to keep it cool enough to progress. But it was 100% worth it for the satisfaction of calling in an airstrike using Cid's limit break. Epic.

    I have quite a few runners up: FF4, 5, 6, 9, and Tactics were all great. And the original has a certain charm as well all these years later. But 7 would be my pick if I really could only choose one.

    5 votes
  9. Thomas-C
    Link
    Final Fantasy IX I got that game as a Christmas gift from a family friend. It was totally unexpected; I had no idea he knew that I liked anything like that, and I also didn't know IX had come out...

    Final Fantasy IX

    I got that game as a Christmas gift from a family friend. It was totally unexpected; I had no idea he knew that I liked anything like that, and I also didn't know IX had come out yet. He gave me that and the guide book, so I spent around three straight days just playing that game. I got to the end after doing other stuff for a day or two. Probably, honestly helped with learning how to focus on something and get it done over a long stretch (follow the guide book to see the game). I found myself relating to the characters to that one in a way I think everybody who plays Final Fantasy feels about one particular entry, in general. There's always one that just hits you for one reason or another if you're meeting them where they're at.

    In IX, Vivi was always a character who stood out to me. I had played Final Fantasy VII, and a bit of VIII, but didn't really relate much to the characters in those. In Vivi I found that. Though I didn't grow up alone, I was very lonely, and as I was getting older the sci-fi novels meant I was pondering weird and large things. As a kid, I was someone who was trusting to a fault, pure in intent but often not able to see that such intent often gets used, getting pretty hurt when that happened. Vivi was like that. He didn't know where he came from, why he was there, and got suckered into stuff from time to time by folks who were just being shitty and self absorbed. The way Vivi meets up with Zidane, the way their friendship develops and the fiery kind of devotion Zidane has to his friends stuck with me. It was like seeing a glimpse of what could be, how things could work in a more detailed way than saying it that straightforwardly.

    As a kid I'm not sure how I picked up on it but it stuck with me. I felt like I was like Vivi, and that I wanted to be someone like Zidane. I felt a lot like i was alone, misunderstood, and I could not stand getting led astray. I wanted to be someone who was brave, whose strength came from how much he cared for folks. The sort of person who is both, kind and strong. The game didn't set things in motion, but it gave me an image, is the way I want to put it. Like being told "yeah, that's a thing you can do", it's not that things immediately shift and change, it's that you remember when the question comes up. Remember, you can tell that person you think they're good, that they did a good thing, that you like who they are. Much of the raising what happened with me was about protection - what you do to avoid different situations, kinds of behavior, defend oneself, stay safe. What I experienced in school was folks trying to constantly get away with shit, who usually disappeared when I punched them in the mouth, but i hated doing that. It's been through these occasional glimpses, and later on my own deliberate effort, that has kept that sort of sentiment alive.

    In some of the darkest moments, strangely it was something that hurt the most sometimes. That what I wanted to be and who I was were not coming together, they were driving apart. I would remember some of the same moments, and interpret them completely differently, which itself was not an easy thing to deal with. The process of undoing that never hinged on something like Final Fantasy IX - its role is small and accidental - but it would be wrong to say it was not part of my life in a significant way. It means something the others can't, so I can make all kinds of exceptions for it despite my significantly different and always changing taste. I don't really experience just the game when I play it: I remember things, feel old feelings, engage in something I don't feel like the word "nostalgia" adequately captures. Adding "deep" to it doesn't do the trick either.

    Better translation too, that really makes a difference. VII was good and all but awkward sometimes in a way IX just doesn't do as much. I didn't particularly enjoy VIII. The music is nicer to me too, the instruments sound nicer and I enjoyed the more flavorful parts of it. I prefer when the music is more suited to the context with unique stuff for unique moments. I never got that much into Final Fantasy after IX, so it's kinda where I left the series. I think it happening at the right place and right time meant I couldn't really get into the others after I played it. I played turn based games for a long time after but never had an experience like that again. I had other significant experiences, just can't be 12 or 13 twice kind of deal.

    My favorite to play is Tactics. There are mods for that game which tune the difficulty in ways that I like, so I've gotten a lot out of having that one around. I always have it, it's something I do when I have to wait in places for a while and share the save between devices. Just really good all around, in a fantasy novel kind of way.

    5 votes
  10. bgc
    Link
    FF6 was my favorite. As a kid from the suburbs without a car, it was my first taste of opera, casino / airships, rafting, mining and factory towns, etc. The world building was truly magical.

    FF6 was my favorite. As a kid from the suburbs without a car, it was my first taste of opera, casino / airships, rafting, mining and factory towns, etc.

    The world building was truly magical.

    4 votes
  11. GenuinelyCrooked
    Link
    Final Fantasy XIV, for sure, and it's because of the social element and the fact that I can literally play it as much as I want without running out of things to do. I try not to play it during the...

    Final Fantasy XIV, for sure, and it's because of the social element and the fact that I can literally play it as much as I want without running out of things to do. I try not to play it during the spring or summer time at all, because I'll get sucked in and end up not going outside, but in the winter when going outside is the absolute last thing I want to do, this game is great at keeping me from going stir-crazy. I'm interacting with friends that I actually know, which is a very different experience from social media. We're doing activities together, which is very different from just texting them. And the scenery does a decent job of reminding me of a beautiful, not-frozen world, with flowers and trees with leaves and things.

    I'm pretty picky about video games. I spend quite a few hours playing them when the mood strikes, but I can count the actual titles that I've played in the past 10 years on my fingers. The Dragon Age franchise takes up most of one hand and accounts for several thousand of the hours that I've played. FFXIV scratches most of the same itches for me, with the added bonus of a social aspect.

    3 votes
  12. [2]
    Carrow
    (edited )
    Link
    Ok I'll say it, the black sheep 8 has to be my favorite. I think the way they weave the multimedia aspects available to video games within the plot creates a spectacular love story that couldn't...

    Ok I'll say it, the black sheep 8 has to be my favorite. I think the way they weave the multimedia aspects available to video games within the plot creates a spectacular love story that couldn't have been told as well in any other way. The music is fantastic. I like the goofy draw and junction systems, though I understand the disdain for them too. Triple Triad is a top tier side mini game.

    I consider 6 to be one of the most impressive titles though. The way they moved story telling forward within the constraints of the SNES is just awesome, in addition to the cast of characters, breadth of their exploration, and the way they flipped the script later in.

    Notable mention for 10, it's really great. They took a huge leap forward with voice acting and did it well. To this day, I see JRPGs still struggle to incorporate voice acting and cutscenes near as well as 10.

    14 gets a mention as a great MMO -- but the MMO aspects ultimately hold it back from being an exceptional game outside the genre despite some superb characters, story arcs, boss fights, and music. But, for all my criticisms, it is the final fantasy that I've put the most time in by far and has been the most impactful to my life. My raid group has been a valuable part of my life, we've met up multiple times, some of them moved coast to coast... I've been a member of a fair number of online gaming groups, but none has been as tight knit or dear.

    At this point, I've played every mainline game except X-2, 11, 12, and 16 (though haven't beat every one of those I played).

    3 votes
    1. Akir
      Link Parent
      I'm not a big fan of Uematsu overall, but he occasionally knocks it out of the ballpark, and 8 has a number of songs that I think are his best (I particularly love Man with the Machine Gun, which...

      I'm not a big fan of Uematsu overall, but he occasionally knocks it out of the ballpark, and 8 has a number of songs that I think are his best (I particularly love Man with the Machine Gun, which has a fantastic orchestral version in Fethos Lusec Wecos Venosec). Most of his contemporaries I like because of their creativity within the constraints of the hardware they are using, but Uematsu is best when he doesn't have those constraints. Heck, even the original Final Fantasy had a better soundtrack due to it's support for FM sound. Weirdly enough, my favorite Uematsu soundtrack is actually for the Ah! My Godess movie.

      (Yes, you should track down and watch that movie. It's great. And you don't have to be familiar with the source material to enjoy it.)

      2 votes
  13. SpecialtyCoffeeDad
    Link
    My answer is constantly changing, but today I'm going to say Final Fantasy IX. It's an inherently nostalgic game -- a competent love letter to the playfulness of the NES and SNES era games,...

    My answer is constantly changing, but today I'm going to say Final Fantasy IX. It's an inherently nostalgic game -- a competent love letter to the playfulness of the NES and SNES era games, nestled in an era when the series was heading in a more self-serious direction -- and since my appreciation of the series mostly rests on nostalgia, this feels like the right choice.

    I like that the characters were generally a bit more lighthearted. Zidane is maybe not my favourite protagonist, but his upbeat attitude was a worthwhile change of pace after the broodiness Cloud and Squall. There are plenty of memorable supporting characters -- particular shout out to Vivi and Steiner -- and Zidane fits in his setting.

    I also appreciate that the characters are unique in terms of their abilities. In the games where any character can access any spell or ability, the party selection kinda just becomes about who had the Limit Break that does the most damage. In this game, there's some overlap with some characters, but each one has their role and some unique -- but not game breaking -- abilities.

    And the music is, as always, amazing. Ukulele de Chocobo and Vamo Alla' Flamenco are the best Chocobo songs.

    3 votes
  14. PraiseTheSoup
    Link
    The Legend of Dragoon Seriously though. Final Fantasy games of the time just weren't as engaging. I needed that button timing element that additions brought to make combat fun.

    The Legend of Dragoon

    Seriously though. Final Fantasy games of the time just weren't as engaging. I needed that button timing element that additions brought to make combat fun.

    2 votes
  15. Eji1700
    (edited )
    Link
    6. I just love the large cast, and that they all get their time in the sun. The mid game "twist" is also fantastic and its got a satisfying ending. Oh and the gameplay is great (as is the Brave...

    6.
    I just love the large cast, and that they all get their time in the sun. The mid game "twist" is also fantastic and its got a satisfying ending. Oh and the gameplay is great (as is the Brave New World gameplay mod)

    7 came out and suddenly they were almost all main character romance stories, which I like a lot less.

    2 votes
  16. Grayscail
    Link
    Final Fantasy 10 is probably my favorite game of all time. I really like the lore, and how Pyreflies tie the whole game together. Pyreflies are these little particles of aether that conduct spirit...

    Final Fantasy 10 is probably my favorite game of all time.

    I really like the lore, and how Pyreflies tie the whole game together. Pyreflies are these little particles of aether that conduct spirit energy, so they react to willpower and emotion. This forms the basis for most of the weird stuff in the game. Spheres, Aeons, Unsent, Fiends, Sin, its all pyreflies working in different ways. Each one is just a very slightly different application of the same thing, some done intentionally and some subconsciously. The whole game is about the power of belief and how it allows people to manifest their dreams and nightmares into reality. The game is written in this intentionally convoluted way so it all seems really confusing, but once you have all the information it fits together really elegantly.

    Beyond that, its one of the best designed turn based RPGs, in my opinion. The Conditional Turn-based Battle system is the best way to do turn based combat, the equipment setup is very simple and easy to understand at a glance, status effects really feel impactful, and if you know what youre doing you can beat the whole game without levelling up at all just by taking advantage of all the other mechanics available.

    The underlying plot about Sin and its commentary on institutional religion and generational trauma are really interesting and done in a subtle enough way that it doesnt feel too preachy.

    And I love all the side quests and content, aside from Lightning Dodger.

    2 votes
  17. Notcoffeetable
    Link
    I don't feel like I kept up with Final Fantasy enough to have a favorite pick. FFVI: Played an on emulator way back in the day. I don't really like playing console games with M+KB and couldn't...

    I don't feel like I kept up with Final Fantasy enough to have a favorite pick.

    • FFVI: Played an on emulator way back in the day. I don't really like playing console games with M+KB and couldn't hook up a controller at the time. I have some good memories but don't think I got very far.
    • FFVII: Nearly beat the game but glitched myself a bit. If I remember correctly you are given a save point you can drop where you'd like. I accidentally dropped it on a ladder near a final boss. I was under leveled and couldn't leave or beat the boss. Did enjoy the game though. Still have my memory card and OG discs in the crystal case.
    • FFVIII: At the time it was my favorite... mostly because Rinoa triggered a bit of an awakening.
    • FFIX: Bought it, didn't get very far. I didn't quite like the change in style compared to VII and VIII
    • FF Tactics: Absolutely loved the gameplay, story was good, I really liked the class system and the combat. At the time I was kid and kind felt confused because it didn't "feel" like Final Fantasy to me.
    • FFTA: Really liked FFTA, maybe the only FF game I actually beat? Being on a handheld was a big perk. I still think about the move Beso Tóxico my sniper had. I can vividly remember the animation and dealing some sick damage with it.

    I definitely messed around with FF games before these but I only experienced FFX second hand because I didn't have a PS2. Reading the above I guess I do have some decent Final Fantasy context. If I were to pick one... probably FFTA. I should revisit it, but it really pulled me in differently than the rest.

    2 votes
  18. Mopeybloke
    Link
    VII. Years prior I had a birthday party, and my friend forgot his sleeve of PSX games. It was full of RPGs I tried, including Chrono Cross, Legend of Legaia, and the like. It also had the PSX...

    VII.

    Years prior I had a birthday party, and my friend forgot his sleeve of PSX games. It was full of RPGs I tried, including Chrono Cross, Legend of Legaia, and the like. It also had the PSX ports of Final Fantasy IV and Chrono Trigger. CT was easily my favourite game from then on. Final Fantasy IV, which it was bundled with, I tried playing for a bit and never got far. It didn't intrigue me very much.

    Later on in 2004 or so, I ran into VII in a games store I frequented, and I remembered not finishing IV, but bought it on a whim. I was instantly floored by its presentation and the plot intrigued me a lot. It was like a more detailed, deeper version of CT. So I got my trusty English dictionary and braved it. The translation and the text's relative complexity made it challenging though.

    The themes of the nature of life, how we relate to the world we live in and all the sci-fi aesthetics were captivating, and the complexity of the plot made it so I learnt something new every time in the future I revisited it. It's the most important game to me.

    It's easy, and has a captivating plot and presentation, making it a good recommendation for people willing to try this style of game, though recently people expect games to be more technically demanding. Also, I love that fans have spent about 10 years giving this game a worthier English localisation.

    2 votes
  19. 0x29A
    Link
    I can find many things to love about most of the series. One of my favorite RPG series in general (especially the earlier ones - basically everything before X). But, it's no contest- FF6 is by a...

    I can find many things to love about most of the series. One of my favorite RPG series in general (especially the earlier ones - basically everything before X).

    But, it's no contest- FF6 is by a large margin my favorite Final Fantasy. The story, the graphics, the atmospheres/settings, the sprites, the music... everything comes together to make it something absolutely beautiful.

    1 vote
  20. [4]
    bengine
    Link
    The one where I buy it, play a couple hours only to get frustrated and move on to something else. So like 7,8, X maybe and a couple of the earlier ones (forget which ones, 4,5?) For some reason I...

    The one where I buy it, play a couple hours only to get frustrated and move on to something else. So like 7,8, X maybe and a couple of the earlier ones (forget which ones, 4,5?) For some reason I can't get into them, I've played other turn based games and liked them, and I've played through all Dark Souls games to multiple NG+ levels so I'm usually up for a challenge, but so far not so much. Maybe I'll look at XIV after this thread.

    1 vote
    1. [3]
      Mendanbar
      Link Parent
      What other turn based games have you tried and liked? Trying to suss out what it is about FF games in particular that doesn't hit right for you. :)

      What other turn based games have you tried and liked? Trying to suss out what it is about FF games in particular that doesn't hit right for you. :)

      1 vote
      1. [2]
        bengine
        Link Parent
        Some series I've liked are Civilization, Wasteland, Jagged Alliance, Xcom, Red/Blue Pokemon, et. al.. Recently really liked the lamplighters league when it wasn't crashing out. Not all the same by...

        Some series I've liked are Civilization, Wasteland, Jagged Alliance, Xcom, Red/Blue Pokemon, et. al.. Recently really liked the lamplighters league when it wasn't crashing out. Not all the same by any means. It could all stem from my first try with VIII not working out on my PS1 back in the day, who knows.

        1. Mendanbar
          Link Parent
          So most of the games you mentioned are very much tactics games, whereas a lot of the FF games are more traditional JRPGs. It's possible that you just aren't compatible with JRPG style games in...

          So most of the games you mentioned are very much tactics games, whereas a lot of the FF games are more traditional JRPGs. It's possible that you just aren't compatible with JRPG style games in general. I would think that Final Fantasy Tactics might be more inline with what you prefer in a game, if you ever get a chance to check it out.

          1 vote
  21. Akir
    Link
    Hmm, probably 6, 8, or 9. Those are the games I think did the best job of making the stakes more than just save the world, and they were filled with very compelling characters driving the plot....

    Hmm, probably 6, 8, or 9. Those are the games I think did the best job of making the stakes more than just save the world, and they were filled with very compelling characters driving the plot. Everything beyond that felt too much like a movie, and in spite of the more realistic characters and impressive setpieces, it actually made them feel more disconnected from them. The last game actually bored me with how much it makes you stand around and wait for people to stop talking. That kind of thing can be great at times, but if I'm going to sink an untold number of hours into a game, I damn better be able to spend most of that time actually playing it when I want to.

    I know everyone loves 7, but I thought it had tone issues, was extremely distracted by the terrible character models used outside of battle and at times rather clumsy presentation. It lacked the beautiful sprite art of previous games, and Square wasn't yet capable of the CGI wizardry they would later become famous for.

    1 vote
  22. JCPhoenix
    Link
    I have played all of the mainline FFs, except for I and II, I think. This includes the online XI and XIV, the latter which I'm currently playing. I've also played some of the spinoffs (FFT,...

    I have played all of the mainline FFs, except for I and II, I think. This includes the online XI and XIV, the latter which I'm currently playing. I've also played some of the spinoffs (FFT, Tactics Advanced, X-2, among others). That said, I haven't played them all equally, nor even beat most of them. For some reason, I get to the end and then just stop. That says something about me, Idk what, but I digress.

    My favorite is probably Final Fantasy VI. Part of it might be the fact that it was first Final Fantasy I played, back on the SNES (as "Final Fantasy III"). But I also loved the steampunk setting of it. And that really set the tone for which FFs are my most and least favorite. I think it's because I like sci-fi more than fantasy. So if a game (or any form of media) can merge sci-fi with some fantasy elements, I'll be interested.

    As such, my favorites in the non-online games are VI, VII (both original and remake), VIII, and XIII. XV should be in that list, but Idk, I couldn't get into it for other reasons. XV aside, that doesn't mean I disliked the others -- X and XVI were pretty decent; X's sphere grid has gotta be the best upgrade system in the whole series -- they're just not my favorites in the series. Unpopular opinion: XV aside, IX is my least favorite FF. Because it's a return to the more fantasy side of things.

    Of the two online games, XIV hands down. One of the best MMOs I've ever played (and I've played/tried many). Those who've mentioned XIV elsewhere in this thread basically cover everything and why it's so good!

    1 vote
  23. Nihilego
    Link
    Played: FF6 FF7 FF8 FF12 FF13(-2?) FF13-LR FF14 FFT FFTA Finished: FF7 FF12 FF14(Started Dawntrail, but being an MMO the end goal always changes) Not a lot, I know But of these I liked FF7 the...

    Played:
    FF6
    FF7
    FF8
    FF12
    FF13(-2?)
    FF13-LR
    FF14
    FFT
    FFTA

    Finished:
    FF7
    FF12
    FF14(Started Dawntrail, but being an MMO the end goal always changes)

    Not a lot, I know
    But of these I liked FF7 the most.
    FF14 needs its own thread.
    FF12 I had expectations but I can’t see myself ever replaying it, it’s just Proto-Xenoblade, gambits are cool though.
    FFT is my next FF that I want to finish, not counting Dawntrail.

    1 vote
  24. zod000
    Link
    sorry to resurrect this thread, but I just stumbled across it and I've been a fan of the series since the first game. I've played nearly all of them other than the MMOs, and it is really hard to...

    sorry to resurrect this thread, but I just stumbled across it and I've been a fan of the series since the first game. I've played nearly all of them other than the MMOs, and it is really hard to rank some of them because how I feel about them now versus when I played them is obviously very different. I think my favorite is still probably FF6, it was a masterpiece and it has aged very well compared to the PS1 era games. After that I'd have to say FF7, FF9, and FF10 in that order.

    I haven't seen many people mention FF16, but I really thought it was great.

    If we're including non-mainline or traditional FF games, I'd like to give a shout out to Final Fantasy Legend 2 (aka Saga 2). I think I spent more time playing that game on my gameboy than every other game combined.

    1 vote
  25. Dr_Amazing
    Link
    I've only played a handful of them but 6 was easily the best.

    I've only played a handful of them but 6 was easily the best.