66 votes

Manifestos, fear, and ‘loser thinking’: inside Proton’s AI reckoning

62 comments

  1. [28]
    JCAPER
    (edited )
    Link
    Still recuperating from the very first paragraph: I'm not someone who changes services whenever a negative story comes out - or else by this point I wouldn't be using the internet at all - but...

    Still recuperating from the very first paragraph:

    Andy Yen, the CEO of Proton, had a message for an employee in the company’s security Slack channel who urged the company to at least take a few days to pentest newly written code before pushing it live. “That’s bullshit and loser thinking. Of course it’s possible to be fast and secure,” Yen wrote in the channel at the end of August. “Stop thinking always of how to be slower, and focus more on how to be faster.”

    I'm not someone who changes services whenever a negative story comes out - or else by this point I wouldn't be using the internet at all - but even if just half of this article is true... It's bad.

    I was going to quote some more but like... Just read for yourselves or ask some LLM to summarize it. Like @snake_case said, this guy is the embodiment of all the worst traits of 2020's CEO's, and I don't trust that he's the best person to lead Proton.

    When it's time to renew my yearly sub, I'm going to seriously consider jumping ship if he's still at the helm

    Edit: sent an email to Proton Foundation asking them to use their position to pressure Andy Yen to step down. Not sure how much good that will do, but it's done anyway. And also cancelled the renewal explaining why.

    Edit 2: Proton cancels the AI interviews: https://www.404media.co/protons-ceo-cancels-ai-re-interviews/

    “I don’t think he will change anything, and I think the only reason we had this meeting is because he has a rebellion on his hands,” one employee told 404 Media after the all-hands meeting on Friday.

    Near the start of the meeting, Yen said, “I want to acknowledge myself, personally, that there was a communication failure on my part and there are many things that probably could and should have been communicated differently, and this is something that I’ll have to reflect on and improve over time. So I will do that.”

    “So what does that mean going forward? Going forward, I'm still going to push,” he added.

    Yen said leadership gathered in the last couple of days to talk about the re-interviews, and spoke to the Proton board too. “They’re closely monitoring the situation,” Yen said. (Proton is owned by the Proton Foundation, whose board of trustees includes Yen, Sir Tim Berners Lee, Prof. Carissa Veliz, Dingchao Lu, and Antonio Gambardella.)

    After those discussions with leadership and the board, “We’ve decided to actually cancel the re-interviews,” Yen said. “Why? Well, I think actually in a, let’s say, unintentional way, they have actually already served their purpose.” As in, employees are now talking and learning about AI.

    58 votes
    1. [11]
      LukeZaz
      (edited )
      Link Parent
      I dunno if this is being said in jest, but enough people here do this unironically that I gotta say: Can we stop suggesting this? Nobody needs an LLM to develop their opinion for them. If you're...

      or ask some LLM to summarize it.

      I dunno if this is being said in jest, but enough people here do this unironically that I gotta say: Can we stop suggesting this?

      Nobody needs an LLM to develop their opinion for them. If you're short on time, then please, find a human-written summary, skim the article, or just don't read. All of those are better than surrendering thought to a sycophantic penny-slot.

      32 votes
      1. [10]
        Pepetto
        Link Parent
        How is a human summary any less "surrendering thought" than an AI summary? I find LLM summary valuable to much more effectively find and assess online resources. If LLM are still sycophantic to...

        How is a human summary any less "surrendering thought" than an AI summary?
        I find LLM summary valuable to much more effectively find and assess online resources. If LLM are still sycophantic to you in 2026, then you haven't learn how to use them, they got much better about that (not perfect, hence the "know how to use it"). Also, it's hard for a summary to be overly sycophantic... and why would I need my summary machine to be anything more than a penny-slot?
        Sorry, but this sounds like ideologically driven hate against one of the legitimate good use case of LLMs.

        13 votes
        1. [3]
          Halfloaf
          Link Parent
          In my opinion, the LLM isn’t the problem. The problem is instead that a company controls the LLM, and in specific cases, that company will put its thumb on the scale. The same is certainly true...

          In my opinion, the LLM isn’t the problem.

          The problem is instead that a company controls the LLM, and in specific cases, that company will put its thumb on the scale.

          The same is certainly true for a human summary, but people are more used to understanding what biases and incentive structures that person has (to a small degree, at least). I can tell you that I wouldn’t trust Fox News’ analysis of Trump’s actions, for example, due to obvious ties. However, I can’t tell you anything about Anthropic’s investors, or what their goals may be.

          It’s worth noting that Anthropic (among other LLM-owners) has yet to turn anywhere near a profit. At some point, that bill will come due, and then, the reliance on LLMs will have a very different value proposition.

          23 votes
          1. [2]
            Pepetto
            Link Parent
            So... self hosted / "open source" LLMs are fine?

            So... self hosted / "open source" LLMs are fine?

            2 votes
            1. Halfloaf
              Link Parent
              Yeah, I don’t have as much of a problem with it, but it’s still a little messy if you’re not controlling the training of those LLMs. If someone else sets the network weights, then it doesn’t...

              Yeah, I don’t have as much of a problem with it, but it’s still a little messy if you’re not controlling the training of those LLMs.

              If someone else sets the network weights, then it doesn’t really matter who hosts it.

              8 votes
        2. [4]
          sparkle
          Link Parent
          Personally for me, I don't use AI summaries any more because I found the information wasn't sticking. Sure it takes me longer to read things on my own, but I'm absorbing the full context and that...

          Personally for me, I don't use AI summaries any more because I found the information wasn't sticking. Sure it takes me longer to read things on my own, but I'm absorbing the full context and that makes me much more effective at relaying information to my teammates over a long period of time than if I relied on AI to summarize it once, regurgitate it, then completely forget it a week later.

          For me, forming connections while reading to other familiar things creates, I don't know, like a "sticky web" in my head that makes it so I recall what I read much more reliably. When I try to recall AI summarized anything, it just doesn't stick - maybe because I didn't put the effort in to understand and engage with the material.

          Don't get me started on Teams summaries. Those are some hot unreliable trash. To be fair, we're about 50/50 on native English speakers and many people refuse to use proper microphones. Thankfully there's still people that take actual notes to share with others who can't be in attendance.

          I don't hate AI, I'm just pretty meh on it

          10 votes
          1. [3]
            Pepetto
            Link Parent
            Oh absolutely, but thats problem would also arrise from human summary... If you don't actively engage your brain on a concept, you memorize it less. If you read a summary in 5 minutes then go play...

            Personally for me, I don't use AI summaries any more because I found the information wasn't sticking. Sure it takes me longer to read things on my own, but I'm absorbing the full context and that makes me much more effective at relaying information to my teammates over a long period of time than if I relied on AI to summarize it once, regurgitate it, then completely forget it a week late

            Oh absolutely, but thats problem would also arrise from human summary...
            If you don't actively engage your brain on a concept, you memorize it less.
            If you read a summary in 5 minutes then go play videogames, you'll learn less than if you read the full article in 45 min. But if you read 3 summaries to pick which text you'll read more intentionally for the remaing 30 min, (or even if you just read 9 x 5 min summaries) then I'd wager you'd actually learn a lot more and in a quite durable way.

            "Just read a bunch of abstract" is a very valid first step of any academic research.

            And reading a summary is definitely better than not reading anything, which I think is the spirit of the advice "or just ask for an AI summary".

            5 votes
            1. [2]
              FlippantGod
              Link Parent
              Ehh, I'm inclined to argue that this is considerably less meaningful without the next step of: spend a fair bit of time day and night thinking about that bunch of abstract and asking questions,...

              "Just read a bunch of abstract" is a very valid first step of any academic research.

              Ehh, I'm inclined to argue that this is considerably less meaningful without the next step of: spend a fair bit of time day and night thinking about that bunch of abstract and asking questions, and eventually following up on at least some of those questions.

              1. Pepetto
                Link Parent
                You're absolutely right! and nothing is stopping you from spending a fair bit of time day and night thinking about a bunch of AI summaries and asking questions. If anything, AI's are more...

                You're absolutely right!
                and nothing is stopping you from spending a fair bit of time day and night thinking about a bunch of AI summaries and asking questions. If anything, AI's are more available to enthusiastically discuss/answer any follow up question.

                1 vote
        3. [2]
          LukeZaz
          Link Parent
          This is a rare scenario where the questions I'm being posed are best answered with brevity, for the simple fact that more detail isn't really necessary and just weighs things down. That comes with...

          This is a rare scenario where the questions I'm being posed are best answered with brevity, for the simple fact that more detail isn't really necessary and just weighs things down. That comes with the unfortunate side-effect of possibly coming off snarky — apologies in advance if that's the case.

          How is a human summary any less "surrendering thought" than an AI summary?

          If you think that human work is no better than LLM output, I'm sorry, but you've been using them too much.

          they got much better about that

          I've heard that before.

          why would I need my summary machine to be anything more than a penny-slot?

          You sound like you're asking me why you'd need something to be reliable?

          9 votes
          1. Pepetto
            (edited )
            Link Parent
            No worries I didn't say that. I said reading a human summary is surrendering though just as much as reading a machine summary. Reading a summary instead of reading the full article is the...

            possibly coming off snarky — apologies in advance if that's the case.

            No worries

            If you think that human work is no better than LLM output, I'm sorry, but you've been using them too much.

            I didn't say that. I said reading a human summary is surrendering though just as much as reading a machine summary. Reading a summary instead of reading the full article is the surrendering if anything is.

            I've heard that before.

            Well... They do continue to be improve rapidely like most new tech... You seem to imply many claims of improvment turned out to be a lie, which kind of confirms the "ideologically driven" allegation, as I've seen it improve a lot... I didn't say it was perfect, but I'd have to be blind not to recognise most benchmark of capabilities keep getting blown past one after the other.

            why would I need my summary machine to be anything more than a penny-slot?
            

            You sound like you're asking me why you'd need something to be reliable?

            Ok, my bad, I didn't know what a penny-slot is, I thought you meant the usual "it's just a glorified autocomplete" talking point.
            For summary, reliability is adequate now, so no, not a slot machine.
            Not entirely deterministic, but neither would a human summerizer be....

            4 votes
    2. [7]
      derekiscool
      Link Parent
      Yikes. This is not a good look for a company whose sole focus is privacy and security. I hadn't been that worried after the last article posted here, but I'm definitely in the same boat as you...

      Yikes. This is not a good look for a company whose sole focus is privacy and security.

      When it's time to renew my yearly sub, I'm going to seriously consider jumping ship if he's still at the helm

      I hadn't been that worried after the last article posted here, but I'm definitely in the same boat as you now. Going to start looking at alternatives asap

      31 votes
      1. [6]
        merovingian
        Link Parent
        Yeah, me too. This sucks, I’ve basically been a user since 2015 and a paid subscriber since probably 2016. They’ve upgraded me with several perks over the years, to the point where I’m now an...

        Yeah, me too. This sucks, I’ve basically been a user since 2015 and a paid subscriber since probably 2016. They’ve upgraded me with several perks over the years, to the point where I’m now an “unlimited” user with 580gb of Drive storage (that I don’t use anyway, but still). I guess I need to at least have a game plan.

        Others have said you can use your own domain name for email, and doing so makes it easy(ier) to switch hosting providers in cases like these. I have one that I use for my own site. Would someone please explain to me how that works, or at least point me toward a resource or guide?

        6 votes
        1. [3]
          Kremor
          Link Parent
          Basically, you'll need to open your domain registrar's DNS admin panel and set up the MX records, plus other ones like DKIM and DMARC that help validate your identity. The exact records you'll...

          Basically, you'll need to open your domain registrar's DNS admin panel and set up the MX records, plus other ones like DKIM and DMARC that help validate your identity. The exact records you'll need depend on your email provider.

          Despite how intimidating this may sound, it's actually pretty easy. You just need to copy and paste the values your email provider gives you into your DNS admin panel. The "hard" part is making sure you select the right record type. MX for the MX records, TXT for basically everything else, maybe a CNAME record to redirect to one of their servers.

          I found this video by tutanota that explains the gist of it, but once again, the basics are the same for everyone else but the UI will change depending on your providers.

          6 votes
          1. [2]
            merovingian
            Link Parent
            Okay thanks (and to @preposterous) for the advice. So I think what this means is that changing records at the provider is half of the solution, and it allows you to easily switch an email address...

            Okay thanks (and to @preposterous) for the advice. So I think what this means is that changing records at the provider is half of the solution, and it allows you to easily switch an email address from one provider to another by just deleting those records from a current provider and adding them to a new one. Thus I can still keep something like "merovingian[@]mysite.org" in both places, instead of having to switch my emails from "merovingian[@]provider1.com" to "merovingian[@]provider2.com" for every one of my logins. Makes perfect sense.

            What this doesn't do is solve anything about the integrity (a la Proton, or at least what Proton seems to be losing) and features of the provider itself - e2ee, aliases, that stuff. I still have to determine which provider comes next and whether they provide the features I want. Then, if I deem they do, I update my records to them.

            Do I have that right?

            1 vote
            1. preposterous
              Link Parent
              Basically yes. The aliases and other settings are provider dependent. They don’t all support the same set of features and if they do there is no standard migration path. So the MX records are...

              Basically yes. The aliases and other settings are provider dependent. They don’t all support the same set of features and if they do there is no standard migration path.

              So the MX records are telling any server wanting to send you mail where to forward it exactly. Similar to how dns resolves a domain name to an actual IP (which corresponds to a specific server). DKIM DMARC etc is to prevent spam, in a nutshell.

              But to everyone else sending you mail, they never know the difference. They still send mail to you@example.org before and after you change servers.

              4 votes
        2. preposterous
          Link Parent
          Sibling went into more detail than I will in this reply, I just wanted to echo how intimidating it looks but how simple it is in practice. Virtually all email providers will tell you what to put...

          Sibling went into more detail than I will in this reply, I just wanted to echo how intimidating it looks but how simple it is in practice.

          Virtually all email providers will tell you what to put in which record, so you just have to find your DNS console and then copy paste the values.

          4 votes
        3. Banazir
          Link Parent
          I'm in basically the same position as you, just minus a couple of years. I only really use Proton Drive when I want to share a large file and don't want someone to deal with my abysmal residential...

          I'm in basically the same position as you, just minus a couple of years. I only really use Proton Drive when I want to share a large file and don't want someone to deal with my abysmal residential upload speeds. My wife and I both use Proton, I was about to switch us from two individual plans to a single Duo plan, but I definitely want to hold off on that now.

          I'll be interested to see what you choose to switch to. Mail and calendar matter most to me, if I really need to send files I can make people use my Nextcloud.

    3. [2]
      winther
      Link Parent
      Geez, I am not a Proton user but that isn’t exactly reassuring from a company that markets themselves as the high priest of security. Many mistakes in software development leads back to something...

      Geez, I am not a Proton user but that isn’t exactly reassuring from a company that markets themselves as the high priest of security. Many mistakes in software development leads back to something being done too fast.

      17 votes
      1. Banazir
        Link Parent
        I'd argue that they market themselves toward privacy more than security. Yes, you need security to implement privacy, but their brand definitely pushes the privacy angle more.

        high priest of security

        I'd argue that they market themselves toward privacy more than security. Yes, you need security to implement privacy, but their brand definitely pushes the privacy angle more.

        1 vote
    4. Grzmot
      Link Parent
      Hahahahahahahahahahaha. Yeah good luck I've seen the code our PMs generate and it's always a mess. AI is an occasionally functional accelerant but if you have no knowledge to work off then it'll...

      "[...]This will be the last year that we hire engineers, and starting next year we hire what we used to call product managers, to build things with AI.”

      Hahahahahahahahahahaha. Yeah good luck I've seen the code our PMs generate and it's always a mess. AI is an occasionally functional accelerant but if you have no knowledge to work off then it'll accelerate you straight into a ditch.

      I'm gonna start shopping for alternatives.

      10 votes
    5. [6]
      snake_case
      Link Parent
      It kinda sounds made up honestly. Like this is exactly what someone would say to torpedo a company on purpose.

      It kinda sounds made up honestly. Like this is exactly what someone would say to torpedo a company on purpose.

      6 votes
      1. glesica
        Link Parent
        At the same time, though, it sounds exactly like something a narcissistic tech CEO would say. Like the Uber guy ranting at an Uber driver. I don't believe everything I read, but I also struggle to...

        At the same time, though, it sounds exactly like something a narcissistic tech CEO would say. Like the Uber guy ranting at an Uber driver. I don't believe everything I read, but I also struggle to discount anything about tech executives for being too outlandish or self destructive.

        16 votes
      2. [4]
        Deely
        (edited )
        Link Parent
        This is interesting take, on HN i saw a lot of negativity regarding Proton.. Im not familiar with 404media, how trustworthy they are as a company? Upd: uff... looks like I will stop renewing my...

        This is interesting take, on HN i saw a lot of negativity regarding Proton..

        Im not familiar with 404media, how trustworthy they are as a company?

        Upd: uff... looks like I will stop renewing my Proton subscription.

        2 votes
        1. [3]
          snake_case
          Link Parent
          Trustworthy enough I guess? I see them all the time but I don’t really know anything about their journalists or where their news actually comes from. The implication in the article, and the...

          Trustworthy enough I guess? I see them all the time but I don’t really know anything about their journalists or where their news actually comes from.

          The implication in the article, and the timing, suggests that the info comes directly from an employee, but they don’t say that.

          I would trust it more if the source was obvious and verifiable, but I assume whoever it is doesn’t want a defamation suit against them which kinda makes me wonder, is it factual.

          6 votes
          1. [2]
            Deely
            Link Parent
            Eh... Proton CEO made a comment on reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xilgwk/comment/19ru2qt4r4r5u/ I don't know, "taken out of context" for me looks like is a typical CEO...

            Eh... Proton CEO made a comment on reddit:

            https://www.reddit.com/r/ProtonMail/comments/1xilgwk/comment/19ru2qt4r4r5u/

            Happy to answer actually, since the quote above was taken out of context.

            I don't know, "taken out of context" for me looks like is a typical CEO bullshit. I feel really dissapointed.

            18 votes
            1. snake_case
              Link Parent
              From the rest of that quote it sounds like there was no context. He said what he said To think if only he would have talked to his employees in a calm collected way none of this would have...

              From the rest of that quote it sounds like there was no context. He said what he said

              To think if only he would have talked to his employees in a calm collected way none of this would have happened.

              This is kinda what I was looking for, can always depend on someone like that to go and continue sounding unhinged all over the internet

              8 votes
  2. [2]
    balooga
    Link
    Well congratulations Andy, now everyone perceives you as a stupid loser and it’s entirely of your own doing. I’ve never been a customer of Proton but I’ve always had a high opinion of them as a...

    “Perception is more important than truth, the truth doesn’t matter if you don’t win on perception.”

    One employee told 404 Media, “Whatever persona Andy [Yen] has out of Proton, he’s a straight up bully inside. He routinely breaks his little facade in Slack and calls people losers and stupid, often for stuff he’s paying them for.”

    Well congratulations Andy, now everyone perceives you as a stupid loser and it’s entirely of your own doing.

    I’ve never been a customer of Proton but I’ve always had a high opinion of them as a company. Not anymore. There’s nothing to respect about a reckless, hurried company driven by a cocksure exec who creates a hostile work environment by belittling his employees and mocking their commitment to quality and care.

    What a hot mess.

    34 votes
    1. Grzmot
      Link Parent
      Hurried is a great word for it. I pay for Proton and the amount of shit they come up with and release finally makes sense when their CEO and CTO are both tech dipshits that can't stay still, can't...

      Hurried is a great word for it. I pay for Proton and the amount of shit they come up with and release finally makes sense when their CEO and CTO are both tech dipshits that can't stay still, can't stay on one project to make it good and have to "keep winning".

      Except for Mail, all their services are so damn barebones it's laughable. Of course it would be, when the CEO wants to release more and more products instead of nurturing the ones they already have. Their Google Docs competitor was released and I don't think it's seen an update since. They managed to add a file browser to it which is weird because all the files are hosted inside Proton Drive (cloud storage) which already has a web UI...

      Then they opened a whole new can of worms by releasing an Excel competitor which is a wild thing to do given how famously ingrained Excel is to the business world, and I don't think they have done anything since with it but hey they released a Zoom competitor! Still no Linux client for Proton Drive though. That thing got announced over 2 years ago it feels like.

      I'm sorry for the employees that have to follow these constantly moving goal posts and produce half-baked results to meet them just before they shift again.

      6 votes
  3. [3]
    snake_case
    Link
    Man it’s like the worst instincts of every company Ive ever worked for all wrapped up in one person.

    Man it’s like the worst instincts of every company Ive ever worked for all wrapped up in one person.

    31 votes
    1. [2]
      Narry
      Link Parent
      That's quitter talk, snake_case, you gotta pump it up and synergize the verticals with the KPI and ensure our go to market solution has integration with the zeitgeist. (I always start to lose my...

      That's quitter talk, snake_case, you gotta pump it up and synergize the verticals with the KPI and ensure our go to market solution has integration with the zeitgeist.

      (I always start to lose my handle on corpospeak towards the end of the sentences.)

      8 votes
      1. snake_case
        Link Parent
        My skip level who I interviewed with unironically used the word synergize during the interview and I actually laughed Luckily I don’t think he caught on why I was laughing

        My skip level who I interviewed with unironically used the word synergize during the interview and I actually laughed

        Luckily I don’t think he caught on why I was laughing

        4 votes
  4. post_below
    Link
    Yikes, well that clears up any questions we had in the other thread. The article quotes an employee saying the CEO was in full "AI psychosis" and everything else seems to back that up. He seems to...

    Yikes, well that clears up any questions we had in the other thread.

    The article quotes an employee saying the CEO was in full "AI psychosis" and everything else seems to back that up. He seems to have dangerously unrealistic and ungrounded ideas about what agents are currently capable of. The "interviews" strategy now looks a lot more like a blatant attempt to bully their engineers to get on board.

    Mass customer exodus incoming if this keeps getting coverage.

    There were also a quotes from a manifesto another of their execs posted on slack which included:

    Proton needs to get to the point where most code is not reviewed by humans but by AI

    The tech is not there yet, and unlikely to get there in the near future. You can get closer if it's human in the loop the whole way, but that goes against their "faster losers!" mentality.

    I'm shocked by this from a privacy and security company, it might turn out to be the worst case of AI delusion in the C suite that's played out publicly so far.

    22 votes
  5. [3]
    LukeZaz
    Link
    I was softly considering leaving Proton as a result of Yen's last few bad takes, but this is nuclear-grade for me. I've had an annual subscription that I now have to migrate before it renews. This...

    I was softly considering leaving Proton as a result of Yen's last few bad takes, but this is nuclear-grade for me. I've had an annual subscription that I now have to migrate before it renews.

    This is why I hate the "unintrusive and optional" AI offerings at so many companies; when that's around, it makes it all too likely that delusional behavior like this is hiding under the surface. How the hell do I know that Kagi, for example, isn't being exactly like this and we just haven't seen it yet?

    17 votes
    1. [2]
      DynamoSunshirt
      Link Parent
      Do you know what you'll switch to? I got a ProtonVPN black friday deal a couple of years back and it's finally expiring. IVPN seems to tick most of the boxes I need for modest volumes of Linux ISO...

      Do you know what you'll switch to? I got a ProtonVPN black friday deal a couple of years back and it's finally expiring. IVPN seems to tick most of the boxes I need for modest volumes of Linux ISO downloading, and they seem pretty ethical. Mullvad seems fine but their far right controversy from earlier this year does not inspire much faith.

      1. LukeZaz
        Link Parent
        I can't help you with VPNs as I didn't really use ProtonVPN myself, but for email and the little cloud storage I use, I've been looking at this comparison tool, which seems to be pointing me at...

        I can't help you with VPNs as I didn't really use ProtonVPN myself, but for email and the little cloud storage I use, I've been looking at this comparison tool, which seems to be pointing me at Tutanota. Unfortunately likely to be more expensive and I don't think Germany's privacy laws are nearly as good as Switzerland's, but I'll take it considering how bad this has been.

  6. [11]
    WhistlePig
    Link
    I'm a paid Proton user and generally like the service, but this is seriously making me think about how much of a pain it would be to switch. There are plenty of good, private email providers if...

    I'm a paid Proton user and generally like the service, but this is seriously making me think about how much of a pain it would be to switch. There are plenty of good, private email providers if you're not locked into Proton's full suite of services.

    13 votes
    1. [10]
      Barney
      Link Parent
      I think that's generally a good indicator that you (or anyone) might be relying on a given provider too much. "Don't put all your eggs in one basket" as they say. We can never know what the future...

      this is seriously making me think about how much of a pain it would be to switch.

      I think that's generally a good indicator that you (or anyone) might be relying on a given provider too much. "Don't put all your eggs in one basket" as they say. We can never know what the future holds and whether the companies we trust today will remain trustworthy tomorrow.

      For email in particular, as long as you have and use your own domain (which I would very highly recommend), switching providers is trivial.

      4 votes
      1. [2]
        WhistlePig
        Link Parent
        I only have Proton email and mainly use my domain for email addresses, but not exclusively. Considering all of the services they offer and how many I self-host, I think my use is a far cry from...

        I only have Proton email and mainly use my domain for email addresses, but not exclusively. Considering all of the services they offer and how many I self-host, I think my use is a far cry from putting all my eggs in their basket.

        The pain is having to audit a couple years worth of emails to figure out which services, accounts, subscriptions, etc. I used which email address for, and then worrying that I missed an important one.

        8 votes
        1. Barney
          Link Parent
          Ahh, I misinterpreted your initial post then. Thought that with "how much of a hassle it would be" you implied that it wouldn't be easy, instead of the literal interpretation.

          Ahh, I misinterpreted your initial post then.

          Thought that with "how much of a hassle it would be" you implied that it wouldn't be easy, instead of the literal interpretation.

          2 votes
      2. [6]
        Nihilego
        Link Parent
        Been thinking of getting a domain just because I saw a domain with a name I like, but couldn’t think of what to actually do with it

        Been thinking of getting a domain just because I saw a domain with a name I like, but couldn’t think of what to actually do with it

        1 vote
        1. [4]
          WhistlePig
          Link Parent
          I had the opposite problem: I have a lot of use for a domain, but I couldn't come up with one that made sense for that use. I landed on a silly one, which is great for self-hosting services, but...

          I had the opposite problem: I have a lot of use for a domain, but I couldn't come up with one that made sense for that use. I landed on a silly one, which is great for self-hosting services, but not as good when you have to explain to someone in person that your email is actually poop@clownpenis.fart

          9 votes
          1. lostwax
            Link Parent
            Slashdot.org was deliberately chosen as a joke domain that was difficult to communicate verbally. It worked out OK for them, for a while at least.

            Slashdot.org was deliberately chosen as a joke domain that was difficult to communicate verbally. It worked out OK for them, for a while at least.

            1 vote
          2. [2]
            Nihilego
            Link Parent
            I’ve been looking into porkbun for a domain and while registering for a domain, they ask for a fair bit of PII. Do these get shown when someone looks up who has the domain or do they stay hidden?...

            I’ve been looking into porkbun for a domain and while registering for a domain, they ask for a fair bit of PII.

            Do these get shown when someone looks up who has the domain or do they stay hidden?

            They do have an email hosting service as well for $36/year (Which is a lot) or a website hosting for 2.5 a month.

            Do I need to pay them $36 to use the domain in say, Proton?

            1 vote
            1. WhistlePig
              Link Parent
              I'm not an expert on this, I'm just a guy who has used youtube videos and trial and error for years to create the setup I have now, so I'll let others weigh in and correct me. You don't need email...

              I'm not an expert on this, I'm just a guy who has used youtube videos and trial and error for years to create the setup I have now, so I'll let others weigh in and correct me.

              You don't need email hosting, you just need a domain. Once you have a domain, just follow your email provider's instructions for using your own domain (here's mailbox.org's instructions for example). I think my Porkbun domain is something like $11 a year, and I just followed Proton's instructions for creating the appropriate DNS records to use that domain with their servers.

              2 votes
        2. Barney
          Link Parent
          Email addresses are the main use case for the average person I'd say. If you ever feel like it, you can always hook it up to Codeberg / Github / Cloudflare pages and host a static site of...

          Email addresses are the main use case for the average person I'd say. If you ever feel like it, you can always hook it up to Codeberg / Github / Cloudflare pages and host a static site of something.

          A blog, photos of your cats etc. It's pretty cool, and completely free.

          3 votes
      3. Gourd
        Link Parent
        100% agreed. I switched off of Google services last year, and that was a massive pain in the ass. Switched to Proton on a custom domain for email. I've been extremely busy lately, but as soon as I...

        I think that's generally a good indicator that you (or anyone) might be relying on a given provider too much.

        100% agreed. I switched off of Google services last year, and that was a massive pain in the ass. Switched to Proton on a custom domain for email. I've been extremely busy lately, but as soon as I get a chance I'm going to be switching off of proton. Not sure what I'll be switching to yet, though.

  7. [2]
    blastedheath
    Link
    I'm now 100% confident that all those people trying to argue against critics of his pro-Trump tweet were put up to it by him. There was a huge reverse backlash towards the people who criticized...

    He then told a member of the team that made it to “go on Reddit.”

    “So go on there with your personal account and comment to set the record straight,” he wrote. “Perception is more important than truth, the truth doesn’t matter if you don’t win on perception.”

    I'm now 100% confident that all those people trying to argue against critics of his pro-Trump tweet were put up to it by him. There was a huge reverse backlash towards the people who criticized Yen saying that we were "falling for propaganda" or "being tricked".

    What propaganda? I read the fucking Tweet myself and made my own decision about it. Dude is a loser. I cancelled immediately and my instincts were clearly right.

    10 votes
    1. IIIIIIIIII
      Link Parent
      The statement after that by an an official Proton account was highly upvoted, before being deleted due to non-reddit backlash. At that point I thought it was just far more likely than not that...

      The statement after that by an an official Proton account was highly upvoted, before being deleted due to non-reddit backlash.

      At that point I thought it was just far more likely than not that paid or unpaid vote manipulation was going on.

      Their attempts to walk it back were extremely silly.

      But yeah, he tweeted in support of Trump, who does not respect domestic or international privacy law in the actions of his administration, and is pushing LLMs as 'super intelligence'. All of these reports of his subsequent actions towards his staff back up that Yen is performing the same actions as the other Trump-supporting tech-CEOs do.

      Even if you can ethically excuse financially supporting a company that publicly supports Trump (and now just quietly does, because it was unpopular), surely a privacy conscious person would look at the push to adopt LLM tools to increase speed as undermining the value proposition as the most secure, and the most safe service to purchase.

      13 votes
  8. JCAPER
    Link
    Proton cancels the AI interviews: https://www.404media.co/protons-ceo-cancels-ai-re-interviews/

    Proton cancels the AI interviews: https://www.404media.co/protons-ceo-cancels-ai-re-interviews/

    “I don’t think he will change anything, and I think the only reason we had this meeting is because he has a rebellion on his hands,” one employee told 404 Media after the all-hands meeting on Friday.

    Near the start of the meeting, Yen said, “I want to acknowledge myself, personally, that there was a communication failure on my part and there are many things that probably could and should have been communicated differently, and this is something that I’ll have to reflect on and improve over time. So I will do that.”

    “So what does that mean going forward? Going forward, I'm still going to push,” he added.

    Yen said leadership gathered in the last couple of days to talk about the re-interviews, and spoke to the Proton board too. “They’re closely monitoring the situation,” Yen said. (Proton is owned by the Proton Foundation, whose board of trustees includes Yen, Sir Tim Berners Lee, Prof. Carissa Veliz, Dingchao Lu, and Antonio Gambardella.)

    After those discussions with leadership and the board, “We’ve decided to actually cancel the re-interviews,” Yen said. “Why? Well, I think actually in a, let’s say, unintentional way, they have actually already served their purpose.” As in, employees are now talking and learning about AI.

    8 votes
  9. LukeZaz
    Link
    The CEO Andy Yen has made a post on the ProtonMail subreddit responding to this. It's, er, well... Suffice to say it's not great.

    The CEO Andy Yen has made a post on the ProtonMail subreddit responding to this. It's, er, well...

    [...] I take responsibility for the failure of communications that has led to such uncertainty, confusion, and hurt within the staff.

    Suffice to say it's not great.

    8 votes
  10. [4]
    Protected
    Link
    I'm not the kind of person who obsessively keeps track of this sort of thing when I'm not proactively shopping for a service, but enough stuck in my brain from casual reading in recent years that...

    I'm not the kind of person who obsessively keeps track of this sort of thing when I'm not proactively shopping for a service, but enough stuck in my brain from casual reading in recent years that when I was looking into changing e-mail services earlier this year I knew Proton was a risk because the CEO is an asshole. So when I read stuff like this my thought is "oh, yeah, checks out! I already knew that!" And I will keep on avoiding Proton for anything that matters.

    I still think this doesn't fully invalidate Proton as a valid choice for a lot of people, though. Let's compare Proton with Google. Is Google in any way better than Proton? Arguably only if you trust in the perceived stability of having a very large customer base. Google's CEO is also an asshole. It's more privacy-hostile, more predatory, more expensive even (with caveats related to how you are using the service). They love AI and hate encryption. Yet so many of us stuck with them for so many years. I think keep an eye out for alternatives but there's no need to rush to leave Proton.

    7 votes
    1. [2]
      stu2b50
      Link Parent
      Is he? What did Pichai do?

      Google's CEO is also an asshole.

      Is he? What did Pichai do?

      6 votes
      1. Akir
        Link Parent
        I wonder if @Protected may have meant Google’s founders, who are currently spending millions of dollars in California on a campaign to mislead its people into not taxing them and the other...

        I wonder if @Protected may have meant Google’s founders, who are currently spending millions of dollars in California on a campaign to mislead its people into not taxing them and the other billionaires in the state.

        9 votes
    2. Sheldon
      Link Parent
      There’s options beyond Pronton and Google though; it’s not a binary choice between two bad options. For example, I’m a big Fastmail fan and user. No, their privacy protection argument isn’t as...

      There’s options beyond Pronton and Google though; it’s not a binary choice between two bad options.

      For example, I’m a big Fastmail fan and user. No, their privacy protection argument isn’t as strong, but I don’t really care about it as much as some of the other features like using my own domain. Also, Thundermail looks somewhat interesting. And there’s dozens of other providers too.

      2 votes
  11. [3]
    mellowminx
    Link
    This sucks :( I don't use Protonmail much but I've been using and loving Protonpass. This doesn't make me feel confident about their data privacy and cybersecurity... will have to look around for...

    This sucks :( I don't use Protonmail much but I've been using and loving Protonpass. This doesn't make me feel confident about their data privacy and cybersecurity... will have to look around for other password manager options

    3 votes
    1. [2]
      JCAPER
      Link Parent
      Before I came to proton pass, I used 1password. Highly recommend them, only reason I swapped was just because I was subbing to proton unlimited, so it didn't make sense to keep both subscriptions

      Before I came to proton pass, I used 1password. Highly recommend them, only reason I swapped was just because I was subbing to proton unlimited, so it didn't make sense to keep both subscriptions

      1 vote
  12. Kremor
    Link
    Proton's CTO has published the AI manifesto in the official Proton blog. (link)

    Proton's CTO has published the AI manifesto in the official Proton blog. (link)

    2 votes
  13. patience_limited
    Link
    The announcement of the Thundermail beta can't possibly be a coincidence.

    The announcement of the Thundermail beta can't possibly be a coincidence.

    1 vote