-
6 votes
-
How the UN migration pact got trolled
5 votes -
A basic analysis of the 2018 US midterm elections suggests it was less gerrymandered than other recent elections for the House of representatives
Now that the ballots for the 2018 House of representatives election have been counted, how badly was the vote gerrymandered? Gerrymandering is the creating of political districts to maximize the...
Now that the ballots for the 2018 House of representatives election have been counted, how badly was the vote gerrymandered?
Gerrymandering is the creating of political districts to maximize the number of representatives a political grouping gets per vote.
The degree of gerrymandering can be approximated by calculating the difference between the outcome of a proportional voting system and the actual districted representatives each party gains.
Here's a look at the last 5 elections to the House of representatives.
In this congress, the Democrats have 235 representatives, the Republicans have 199 and there's 1 other representative.
Voter turnout was 50,3%, the highest for a midterm election since 1914.
The Democrats got 53,5% of the popular vote and 54,0% of the seats. The Republicans got 44,8% of the vote and 46,0% of the seats. Others got 1,8% of the vote and a single seat.
Since the Republicans are no longer getting vastly outsized representation, is gerrymandering dead?
If the US would have had a proportional voting system, 7 of the 435 seats would have been distributed differently in 2018.
The Democrats would have had 3 fewer representatives, the Republicans would have had 4 fewer and others would have had those 7 seats.
Here are the similar figures for the last five elections.
Year Votes per seat ('000) Dem diff. Rep diff. Other diff. 2010 199 -3 +18 -15 2012 281 -11 +27 -16 2014 179 -10 +24 -14 2016 295 -15 +27 -12 2018 261 +3 +4 -7 The change from getting 27 seats "wrong" in 2016 to 7 seats "wrong" this year is large and changes the historic trend.
Turns out that higher turnout led to more accurate representation in 2018. Who would have guessed.
(There are many other additional possible explanations for why this has changed too)
If we just look at the two major parties, what does this mean in real terms?
Here's an overview of the average difference in the number of voters the Democrats have needed for each seat they actually got in the last five elections compared to the Republicans.
Year Additional Dem voters for a seat 2010 8,6% 2012 19,4% 2014 16,6% 2016 21,4% 2018 0,8% There are other ways of trying to engineer specific election results.
This basic overview only looks at people who actually vote. Therefore it obviously doesn't consider those who are prevented from voting in the election process, whether that's from voting requirements, accessibility of polling places, registration requirements, etc.
It will be interesting to see what happens in 2020.
Is this a trend that'll continue?
Is it just a blip because those gerrymandering haven't been able to predict what party voters vote for in today's political climate?
What about turnout?
15 votes -
Ontario is under one-man rule. Who will stop Doug Ford?
13 votes -
Donald Trump Was Never Vetted
20 votes -
Noam Chomsky - The Right Turn (1986)
9 votes -
A 1950s TV show had a fear-mongering conman named Trump who wanted to build a wall.
7 votes -
The noisy dispute over the meaning of populism is more than just an academic squabble – it’s a crucial argument about what we expect from democracy
12 votes -
Danish government to improve conditions for prostitutes
9 votes -
Build the US wall? It could take at least ten years, even with 10,000 workers.
11 votes -
How an emerging African megacity cut commutes by two hours a day
11 votes -
Ocasio-Cortez’s seventy percent top tax rate is a moderate, evidence-based policy
23 votes -
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez keeps firing back at her haters
19 votes -
What America can learn from the fall of the Roman republic (Interview with historian Edward Watts about his book "Mortal Republic")
10 votes -
Is capitalism worth saving?
9 votes -
Donald Trump administration officially bans bump stocks
22 votes -
I was a cable guy. I saw the worst of America
42 votes -
Is "identity politics" standing in the way of a concerted attack on capitalism?
19 votes -
This Little-Known Libertarian Training School Is Making Federal Judges More Conservative
11 votes -
A new book describes Hunter S. Thompson’s prescience. “Trump is present on every page, even though he’s never mentioned once,” the author says.
8 votes -
How Mark Burnett resurrected Donald Trump as an icon of American success
5 votes -
Inside Facebook’s secret rulebook for global political speech
10 votes -
Russia contemplates constitution changes as Putin faces term limits
8 votes -
'It's going to be chaos': Thais to vote in February for first time in eight years
6 votes -
Thailand approves medical marijuana in New Year's 'gift'
8 votes -
Ex-NATO commander: Allies wondering if US President Donald Trump was blackmailed to pull troops out of Syria
16 votes -
The rise of Ksenia Sobchak - from TV presenter to politician | Unreported World
4 votes -
The question for France: Where do the Yellow Vests go from here?
8 votes -
Susan Moylan-Coombs to run as an independent against Tony Abbott in Warringah
2 votes -
Australian Prime Minister urges voters to 'get shopping' as retailers sweat on last-minute sales
2 votes -
Warning to Democrats: Most Americans against US getting more politically correct
13 votes -
Mattis to step down as defense secretary over differences with Trump
27 votes -
Slack is banning users who have visited US-sanctioned countries (including Iran and Cuba) while using its app
20 votes -
Mark Blyth Global Trumpism
5 votes -
Potential impact of two IoT security and privacy laws on tech industry
6 votes -
We know Michael Flynn lied to the FBI. But why?
7 votes -
A.G. Underwood Announces Stipulation Dissolving Trump Foundation Under Judicial Supervision, With AG Review Of Recipient Charities
11 votes -
A Texas elementary school speech pathologist refused to sign a pro-Israel oath, so she lost her job
18 votes -
Nationals MP Andrew Broad used taxpayer funds for part of his bombshell Hong Kong 'sugar baby' trip
3 votes -
Kindertransport children to get 2,500 euros in compensation from German government
4 votes -
New report on Russian disinformation, prepared for the Senate, shows the operation’s scale and sweep.
18 votes -
Angola expels thousands of Congolese migrants in crackdown on illegal diamond mining
7 votes -
The social ideology of the motorcar
6 votes -
The real roots of American rage - How anger became the dominant emotion in our politics and personal lives—and what we can do about it
22 votes -
Australian government to unveil new laws to guard religious freedom but stalls on LGBT students
10 votes -
Russian spy pleads guilty to engaging in conspiracy against the United States
7 votes -
Theresa May has won a vote of confidence in her leadership of the Conservative Party by 200 to 117
21 votes -
Troubled by lapses, government’s voice to the world (Voice of America) braces for new Trump management
6 votes -
Michael Cohen sentenced to three years in prison
28 votes -
Brexit ruling: UK can cancel decision, EU court says
37 votes