-
7 votes
-
The case for legal magic mushrooms
8 votes -
In Lebanon, Palestinians protest new employment restrictions
6 votes -
Small problem: An encounter with refugees and the legal system of Greece
7 votes -
What's the community's opinion on "The Right to be Forgotten?"
This is kind of a question for Tildes as well as a discussion topic on Social Media more generally. For context, "The Right to be Forgotten" is an idea being kicked around in international law and...
This is kind of a question for Tildes as well as a discussion topic on Social Media more generally. For context, "The Right to be Forgotten" is an idea being kicked around in international law and human rights circles. It's kind of a corollary to the "right to privacy" and focuses on putting some guardrails around the downsides of having all information about you being archived, searchable, and publicly available forever and ever. It's usually phrased as a sense that people shouldn't be tied down indefinitely by stigmatizing actions they've done in "the past" (which is usually interpreted as long enough ago that you're not the same person anymore).
This manifests in some examples large and small. Felony convictions or drug offenses are a pretty big one. Another public issue was James Gunn getting raked over the coals for homophobic quotes from a long time ago. Even on a smaller scale, I think plenty of young people have some generalized anxiety about embarrassing videos, photos, Facebook statuses, forum posts, etc. that they made when they were young following them around the rest of their lives. For example, Alexandria Ocasio Cortez had people try to shame her for dancing to a Phoenix song in an amateur music video. An even darker version of this happens with people who might be the victims of targeted harassment. Often doxxing happens by people digging through peoples' histories and piecing together clues to figure out who they are or at least narrow down where they're from, where they work, etc.
In the context of Tildes, this would basically be a question of how do we feel about peoples' comment history lingering forever? Do we care about/agree with this "right" in principle and if we do, what should be done about putting it into practice?
The root of the issue is the existence of archives of data about yourself that is 1.) searchable, 2.) publicly viewable, 3.) under someone else's control, 4.) forever. Even if the ability to delete comments exists, it's infeasible for any individual to pore over the reams of data they create about themselves to find the stuff that might be problematic. The solutions would revolve around addressing any one of those numbered items. Unfortunately, hitting any of those has upsides and downsizes. Some examples:
Some people like being able to look back on old contributions and having them get deleted after a period of time (hitting problem #4) would be a bummer unless there is a system to selectively archive stuff you want to save from atrophy, which would be a function/feature that would take a ton of thought and development. What's more, there is no point in just saving your own comment if everyone else's stuff is gone because comments without context are indecipherable. It could work in a more selective way, so rather than a blanket atrophying of posts, but then you have the context issue again. Someone you were having a discussion with might choose to delete their entire comment history and there goes any sense of logic or coherence to your posts.
We could address the searchable bit by automatically or selectively having posts pseudonymed after a period of time. But in a lot of cases a pseudonym won't work. People tend to refer to each other by username at times, and some people have a distinctive enough style that you could probably figure it out if they're well known and long-tenured.
That's just some general food for thought. I'll yield the floor
38 votes -
Breaking up is harder to do in Denmark after divorce law changes
10 votes -
Thirteen years ago, a Montana rancher found two skeletons in combat – the Dueling Dinosaurs. But who do they belong to, and will the public ever see them?
7 votes -
Honor-related crime could become a specific offence in Sweden
4 votes -
Space law is inadequate for the boom in human activity there
8 votes -
While cities are trying to reform their criminal-justice systems, smaller, more far-flung locales are struggling to provide basic legal services
4 votes -
New York landlords call rent control laws an 'illegal taking' in new Federal lawsuit
3 votes -
Microsoft 365, Google cloud and Apple cloud deemed illegal in Schools of Hesse
13 votes -
Domestic workers have little legal protection. This bill could change that.
3 votes -
Danish government will consider tabling a bill which would define sex without explicit consent as rape
10 votes -
The most important Supreme Court cases of 2019 review
8 votes -
Prenda Law porn-troll saga ends with prison for founder
5 votes -
“I did not die. I did not go to heaven.”: How the controversy around a Christian bestseller engulfed the evangelical publishing industry—and tore a family apart.
10 votes -
Americans shouldn’t have to drive, but the law insists on it
23 votes -
'Protesters as terrorists': Growing number of states turn anti-pipeline activism into a crime
10 votes -
New Zealand—one of three remaining developed countries without vehicle fuel emissions standards—proposes scheme to hike cost of gas guzzling vehicles in exchange for EV rebate
8 votes -
Sweden's government wants to look into a ban on plastic cups and food containers
8 votes -
Can animals commit crimes?
8 votes -
The troubling business of bounty hunting
11 votes -
Mississippi is forbidding grocery stores from calling veggie burgers “veggie burgers”
21 votes -
Judge to review claims of US census citizenship question's 'discriminatory' origins
7 votes -
The first socialist
7 votes -
A ban on smoking in many public outdoor spaces in Sweden comes into effect on July 1st
5 votes -
San Francisco bans sales of e-cigarettes
16 votes -
Illinois becomes eleventh state to allow recreational marijuana
25 votes -
Secrets and lies at Guantanamo Bay: Listening devices, FBI informants, and gag orders… these are just some of the ways that the US is mishandling classified information in the Al Qaeda trials
5 votes -
New York is sixth state to outlaw gay and trans 'panic defenses'
13 votes -
There’s a Legal Loophole That May Leave Some of Rock’s Greatest Riffs Up for Grabs
5 votes -
Canada passes Bill C-68, overhauling the Fisheries Act and banning import and export of shark fins
9 votes -
Hackers, farmers, and doctors unite! Support for right to repair laws slowly grows
6 votes -
'We're on the right side of history': Victoria’s assisted dying laws come into effect for terminally ill
News article: 'We're on the right side of history': Victoria’s assisted dying laws come into effect for terminally ill Legal outline: Voluntary assisted dying laws commence in Victoria - Voluntary...
News article: 'We're on the right side of history': Victoria’s assisted dying laws come into effect for terminally ill
Legal outline: Voluntary assisted dying laws commence in Victoria - Voluntary Assisted Dying Act 2017 (Vic)
6 votes -
‘The Saudis couldn’t do it without us’: The UK’s true role in Yemen’s deadly war
5 votes -
Ireland to ban new petrol and diesel vehicles from 2030
13 votes -
US Supreme Court Justices split along unexpected lines in three cases
10 votes -
The loophole: He held her down, choked her, and masturbated onto her. The law said it wasn't sexual assault.
22 votes -
Hong Kong leader delays extradition bill "indefinitely" amid protest pressure
16 votes -
8chan is raided by the FBI regarding California synagogue shooter
@swodinsky: lmaooooooo 8chan just got search warranted
13 votes -
Nextcloud signs public letter, opposing German plan to force decryption of chat
23 votes -
New York ends religious exemptions for required vaccines
14 votes -
Chelsea Manning against the grand jury
8 votes -
Maine Governor signs strictest internet protections in the US
8 votes -
Hong Kong police use tear gas, rubber bullets in clash with protesters
6 votes -
Botswana decriminalises homosexuality in landmark ruling
11 votes -
New York could become the first state to fully decriminalize sex work
5 votes -
France bans judge analytics, five years in prison for rule breakers
9 votes -
Canada to ban single-use plastics as early as 2021
13 votes