-
7 votes
-
Hey parents, how many of you read vs. tell stories before bedtime for your kids?
My son loves reading time before bed, but he’s only 3.5 so the books have mostly been picture books until now. Lately though he’s been getting more into stories with plots and an extended...
My son loves reading time before bed, but he’s only 3.5 so the books have mostly been picture books until now. Lately though he’s been getting more into stories with plots and an extended narrative, but entirely in the form of movies. There aren’t a lot of kid’s books to go around with the sorts of dramatic stories he likes, they’re more like “caterpillar eats food” and “train engine climbs a hill with grit and determination” type stuff. And whenever I’ve tried to have him just lay down and listen to me read a story without any pictures to stare at he has absolutely no interest. He really likes having pretty visuals to look at.
I know when I was a small child these sorts of board/picture books weren’t really a thing in India. The pre-sleep ritual was usually “storytime” instead, where my parents would tell us stories. I’m a little bit concerned that my kid has been so accustomed to always having visual cues presented to him that it’s stunting his imagination a bit, like failing to exercise his capacity to visualize ideas and concepts for himself without being anchored by some artist’s depiction.
So I’m curious to hear from other parents or caregivers/educators (@kfwyre?). Did you find there was a natural transition point between going from picture books to telling/reading stories? Was there any sort of work you had to do to enable it? Are there “exercises” I can work on to help my son exercise his imagination? I have been working with him to have him tell me stories about his day, which he does pretty well. But his stories are always quite grounded and he’s usually telling me what he’s actually done and seen. When my nephews and nieces were his age they tended to spin out a lot of random stories that pretty obviously did not happen, and I assume this is because they had more experience being told stories themselves rather than just factual reporting about the happenings around them.
25 votes -
What were some artists, groups or albums that had an influence on you before you were old enough to choose for yourself?
The cutoff age would be different for different people. Early music shapes us. I have read that even people with dementia respond to music from their early life. I thought of a few for me, and I...
The cutoff age would be different for different people. Early music shapes us. I have read that even people with dementia respond to music from their early life. I thought of a few for me, and I was curious about people here.
21 votes -
What adults lost when kids stopped playing in the street
44 votes -
In Norway, children walk to school aged six, or even travel across the country. Why do these kids have so much independence, while other countries are so risk-averse?
30 votes -
The great deterioration of local community was a major driver of the loss of the play-based childhood
26 votes -
The costs of a phone-based childhood
35 votes -
Anyone else who don't care much for their past?
I'm 46 years of age. My childhood and youth and post-youth life wasn't traumatic or anything. I had an okay life. I guess I might even have had a good life. But for some reason, reminiscing about...
I'm 46 years of age. My childhood and youth and post-youth life wasn't traumatic or anything. I had an okay life. I guess I might even have had a good life. But for some reason, reminiscing about it just doesn't feel pleasant. Some folks find talking about their past highly enjoyable. So why don't I like it? Is this normal?
23 votes -
Cousins are disappearing worldwide, according to new study
34 votes -
Growing up broken
27 votes -
The Summer Book (1972) – Tove Jansson's novel about love, family and nature, will make you nostalgic for your own childhood
5 votes -
What impact, if any, did being raised as a woman have on you?
Through the years I have struggled with perfectionism, low self worth, and an overwhelming need to make everyone else happy at my own expense. Recently I've begun wondering if this is related more...
Through the years I have struggled with perfectionism, low self worth, and an overwhelming need to make everyone else happy at my own expense. Recently I've begun wondering if this is related more to my own personal upbringing (my mom and sister share a lot of these traits) or if it's a wider experience of being a woman in modern society.
Growing up in a world where women had successfully entered the job market, there was still an unspoken urging that I had to be better than my male peers to earn my place in the world. There still felt like there were expectations that women would follow all the rules, keep the peace, and maintain the home/workspace. Is this an off base interpretation of societal pressures, or do any of you find yourselves still struggling with some of these messages?
ETA: Also, what are some positive ways being raised as a woman has impacted you?
37 votes -
What non-lullaby songs were you sung as a child?
I have a new niece and I'm making a list of songs which we can play for her naptime when we babysit. I have some Raffi songs and my childhood lullabies (Edelweiss from my mom and Moonshadow from...
I have a new niece and I'm making a list of songs which we can play for her naptime when we babysit. I have some Raffi songs and my childhood lullabies (Edelweiss from my mom and Moonshadow from my dad), as well as some calm songs from my Spotify playlist.
But it made me wonder, what songs did your parents sing when you were young? Children's songs? Disney? Pop? Metallica?
I'm also interested in whether you think it's best to keep a small list and rotate through, for comfort's sake, or if it's also okay to have a wider variety of songs as lullabies.
13 votes -
Poor teeth - If you have a mouthful of teeth shaped by a childhood in poverty, don’t go knocking on the door of American privilege
13 votes -
What childhood beliefs or misconceptions took you an embarrassing time to figure out?
I'm talking about silly harmless stuff like "I believed in Santa Claus till I was 13", and not deep existential stuff like "It took me till adulthood to realize that my parents were doing their...
I'm talking about silly harmless stuff like "I believed in Santa Claus till I was 13", and not deep existential stuff like "It took me till adulthood to realize that my parents were doing their best despite their their failings".
24 votes -
Bullying can make children's lives a misery and cause lifelong health problems – but scientists are discovering powerful ways to fight it
17 votes -
Can kids navigate their way across London alone?
9 votes -
How'd y'all grow up?
If you care to explicate your personal situation... I'm interested! So, in what circumstances did you grow up and how did that effect you in terms of the person you are now???
15 votes -
How were you as a child/young-person?
Did you obey your parents? Tortured small animals? Did we’ll school? Popular or outcast? Bully our bullied?
10 votes -
My family’s slave
10 votes -
Before the Easy-Bake Oven, toy stoves were beautiful and deadly
11 votes -
How Ayn Rand ruined my childhood
21 votes -
Cheating on my parents: My own abusive mother and father were being replaced, and they knew it
11 votes -
Why your kid loves the garbage truck so much
17 votes -
See how global warming has changed the world since your childhood
11 votes -
The play deficit
3 votes -
Coming of age in cohousing: Growing up communally brings exposure to the world of adults—and lessons in interdependence
7 votes -
'I'd rather go to heaven than live here as a boy': Inside the lives of Australian trans children
9 votes -
My childhood in a cult
6 votes -
World health officials take a hard line on screen time for kids. Will busy parents comply?
8 votes -
The first ever World Health Organisation physical activity guidelines for under-fives, recommend no screen time for one-year-olds and no more than an hour for two- to-four-year-olds
An article on a parenting website: Guidance recommends no screen time for under-twos An article in Time magazine: World Health Organization Issues First-Ever Screen Time Guidelines for Young Kids....
-
An article on a parenting website: Guidance recommends no screen time for under-twos
-
An article in Time magazine: World Health Organization Issues First-Ever Screen Time Guidelines for Young Kids. Here's What to Know
-
The WHO's press release: To grow up healthy, children need to sit less and play more
26 votes -
-
Advocacy group alleges Oregon's foster care system 'revictimizes children'
4 votes -
Move back to your dying hometown. Unless you can’t.
28 votes -
What did your parents do right?
I'm curious to know what you think your own parents (or the people who raised you) did right. What actions, mindsets, or philosophies did they operate by that had a positive effect on you? What...
I'm curious to know what you think your own parents (or the people who raised you) did right. What actions, mindsets, or philosophies did they operate by that had a positive effect on you? What techniques of theirs would you use with your own children? What important lessons did they teach you?
22 votes -
Growing up in a house full of books is major boost to literacy and numeracy, study finds
15 votes -
What style of parent are you? It affects how much your children remember.
10 votes -
How learning science is catching up to Mr. Rogers
4 votes -
Growing up in the Baldwin Village ‘Jungle’
3 votes