-
14 votes
-
The first Tildes Short Story Exchange is now open to submissions! (May 2025 edition)
1. Announcement The first Tildes Short Story Exchange is now open to submissions! As previously announced, the first edition of the Tildes Short Story Exchange is now open to submissions! Click...
1. Announcement
The first Tildes Short Story Exchange is now open to submissions!
As previously announced, the first edition of the Tildes Short Story Exchange is now open to submissions!
Click here for all the information!
1. Introduction
I have, on many occasions, considered creating a fiction writing and feedback exchange workshop on Tildes. As these things often go, I exaggerated my plans, detailing them endlessly without ever putting them into action. This post is an attempt to break the cycle of procrastination, and I am doing so by forcing myself to adopt a much simpler approach.
2. Goals
The main goal of the Tildes Short Story Exchange is to allow people to get feedback on their short stories. Is it any good? How can I improve it?
3. Why only short stories?
Although there are many writing genres people like to share, short stories are among the most practical. They can be read much more quickly than novels and novellas, and their evaluation is simpler than what poetry requires. A simple, defined, and easy-to-understand prompt is conducive to creation. Every month, participants will know that the Tildes Short Story Exchange is a place to get feedback on short stories. They will feel compelled to write as a result.
4. Position on LLMs
This is a workshop for humans. Producing human connection is one of its main goals. Because of that, all submissions must be human-generated, both in full and in part. That said, LLMs can be used for the same things traditional tools such as Google Docs or Microsoft Word have been used for in the past: proofreading. Additionally, it is allowed to use LLMs to assist in translating into English text that you wrote yourself.
5. About the submissions
For the purposes of the TSSE, a short story is a work of fiction with 7,500 words or fewer. This is based on the classification by both the Hugo and Nebula awards. Stories that go a little above that will, of course, be accepted within reason. All submissions must be in English.
6. How to submit your short story
You may use any website, blog, format, or platform to share your story!
If you are inclined to share a PDF, please also share your story in a format that is open, allowing it to be easily converted and better displayed on mobile devices such as phones, tablets, Kindles, etc. Some good formats for that are
.docx, .rtf, .odt, .epub, .mobi, .txt, .md (markdown)
.If you are sharing your story on something like Google Drive or Microsoft Office Online, make sure to set the appropriate permissions!
I will make an effort to read and provide feedback on as many submissions as I can, and if you share it in an open format, it will at the very least have me as a reader!
You may also use detail markdown blocks to paste your story on Tildes itself (see "Expandable sections" in the Tildes docs here).
7. Example submissions
All short story submissions should be top-level comments on this post.
I drafted below an example submission that I encourage you to use. There are a few additional suggestions in there!
Title: My Super Cool Story Genre(s): Science fiction, romance Expected feedback: In this story I need feedback on story, language, everything. You can be as ruthless as you want. I can take it! File: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ffWEjR7qP3Gfn693cLvOaRujetl6b_5x/ Title: The Day My Dog Died Genre(s): Drama Expected feedback: I'm really insecure about the ending. This is a very personal story—be gentle with me! File: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ffWEjR7qP3Gfn693cLvOaRujetl6b_5x/
8. How to provide feedback?
All feedback should be a direct response to short story submissions.
Feedback should always follow the guidelines put forth by the writer, but anything that is not explicitly prohibited can be understood to be allowed. There will be no strict rules on how feedback must be written, but I would suggest that everyone provide something potentially helpful to the improvement of the story. That is, of course, highly subjective.
9. How are rules going to be enforced?
Given that I am a regular Tildes user with no administrative privileges, all rules in this project will serve merely as guidelines that I suggest participants follow. There will be no enforcement or consequence for not following the guidelines. That means there will be no score, and no “feedback points” will be awarded. It is suggested that everyone seeking feedback provide at least one piece of feedback prior to posting their own story. But that will be entirely based on the “honor system,” and no admonitions will be made toward those who seek feedback without providing it.
10. What will be the schedule?
The TSSE will feature one post on the 1st day of each month. This is to help with mnemonics so people always remember when it will happen. That will help them get their “creative mojo” working every month.
Exceptionally for this first edition, given that it is already May 3rd, the Tildes Short Story Exchange – First Edition will go up next Monday (May 5th) and remain as the current post until June 1st, when it will be replaced.
Within that period, everyone will be free to post their short stories and their feedback at their own leisure.
The schedule may change to once every two months if there is not enough activity.
2. Quick info
This is the beginning of a permanent short fiction workshop on Tildes! Anyone is welcome to post their short stories and get feedback on them. For more information, please click on the information box above or visit the introduction post.
The TSSE will feature one post on the 1st day of each month. Exceptionally, this first edition will be up from today (Monday, May 5th) until June 1st, when it will be replaced.
During that period, everyone will be free to post their short stories and their feedback at their own leisure.
3. How to submit your short story
You may use any website, blog, format, or platform to share your story!
If you are inclined to share a PDF, please also share your story in a format that is open, allowing it to be easily converted and better displayed on mobile devices such as phones, tablets, Kindles, etc. Some good formats for that are
.docx, .rtf, .odt, .epub, .mobi, .txt, .md (markdown)
.If you are sharing your story on something like Google Drive or Microsoft Office Online, make sure to set the appropriate permissions!
You may also use detail markdown blocks to paste your story on Tildes itself (see "Expandable sections" in the Tildes docs here).
4. Example submissions
All short story submissions should be top-level comments on the TSSE posts.
I drafted below an example submission that I encourage you to use. You are not forced to follow this model—feel free to add any information you want in your submission.
Click for the examples
**Title**: My Super Cool Story **Word count**: 949 **Genre(s)**: Science fiction, romance **Expected feedback**: In this story I need feedback on story, language, everything. You can be as ruthless as you want. I can take it! **File or link**: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ffWEjR7qP3Gfn693cLvOaRujetl6b_5x/ **Title**: The Day My Dog Died - **Word count**: 1500 **Genre(s)**: Drama **Expected feedback**: I'm really insecure about the ending. This is a very personal story—be gentle with me! **File or link**: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ffWEjR7qP3Gfn693cLvOaRujetl6b_5x/
5. How to provide feedback?
All feedback should be a direct response to short story submissions.
Feedback should always follow the guidelines put forth by the writer, but anything that is not explicitly prohibited can be understood to be allowed. There will be no strict rules on how feedback must be written, but I would suggest that everyone provide something potentially helpful to the improvement of the story. That is, of course, highly subjective.
35 votes -
Anyone have baking pan recommendations?
Long story short, I’ve gotten very tired of buying junky pans that start getting rusty, etc. really quickly. At the moment, I’m trying to find some good metal pans for baking things like brownies...
Long story short, I’ve gotten very tired of buying junky pans that start getting rusty, etc. really quickly.
At the moment, I’m trying to find some good metal pans for baking things like brownies and focaccia, so probably 8x8 and/or 9x13.
Anyone have any good brand recommendations?
7 votes -
How do you comfort people?
Hello everyone! I had a realization recently spurred by ongoing work stress that my partner is going through. I don't think I'm really good at providing comfort to people. For one, I always feel...
Hello everyone! I had a realization recently spurred by ongoing work stress that my partner is going through. I don't think I'm really good at providing comfort to people.
For one, I always feel very awkward when people other than close friends or romantic partners open up to me. I never quite know what to say. Something like "there there. I'm sorry you're going through that" feels really trite and rehearsed. However the other mode that I have is problem solving, which most people don't appreciate when they're going through something hard.
Secondly, I have this internal feeling about constantly providing comfort for the same thing over and over forming a sort of codependency. I went through this with a previous long term relationship. She hated her job, she would come home, cry, I'd do my "there there" thing, she'd cheer up just enough to force herself through another day, and the cycle would repeat ad nauseum. At a certain point it began to feel like I was enabling a sort of self-harm, and I was bearing much of the fallout from that self-harm. Her job would make her miserable, she'd make me miserable, eventually I'd bear enough of that misery for her to make herself miserable again. Would it have been better to just put my foot down, say I'm no longer going to comfort you for this job that is stealing all of your joy, and I will help you fix this problem, but I won't continue to soothe the pain it causes you? Maybe, but I don't know if I could bring myself to do that. Also, what happens if it's a problem without a solution? What if it's a problem that most people deal with, and you just need to sort of build emotional resilience to deal with?
I don't know the answers to these questions, and I'm not sure if anyone really does for sure, but I'm curious how other people feel about comforting people. What strategies have worked for you? Does it feel awkward? Is it something you've consciously worked on? Do you believe there's such a thing as too much comfort? Even for the people you love?
34 votes -
Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery | Teaser
28 votes -
How do fast fashion clothes vary in quality so much?
I understand that fast fashion brands aggressively cut costs to mass-produce as much trendy clothing as possible, so I'm not surprised when I see a low quality fast fashion item. However, what is...
I understand that fast fashion brands aggressively cut costs to mass-produce as much trendy clothing as possible, so I'm not surprised when I see a low quality fast fashion item. However, what is surprising to me is that the clothes actually significantly vary in quality, even within the same brand. So in a fast fashion store you may find a garment made from the worst synthetic blend ever, with messy stitches that'll definitely tear apart after a single wash cycle. And then on the same shelf there'll be a fairly well-made item, from a sturdy natural fabric, with very precise seams and details. And oftentimes, those two garments will be sold at the same price point.
How does this happen? Do the fast fashion brands just randomly decide to spend more money on some of their clothes? Why don't they just make all of their clothes equally low-quality to cut costs, or make them all a bit better to increase satisfaction? How can a single company have such different quality standards for different products?
17 votes -
Midweek Movie Free Talk
Warning: this post may contain spoilers
Have you watched any movies recently you want to discuss? Any films you want to recommend or are hyped about? Feel free to discuss anything here.
Please just try to provide fair warning of spoilers if you can.
10 votes -
Google's new AI video tool floods internet with real-looking clips
57 votes -
Global ferry electrification accelerates: 70% of new orders go electric
12 votes -
Is Mr. Beast cheating his progress bars?
34 votes -
Where have all my deep male friendships gone?
56 votes -
May 2025 Backlog Burner: Week 5(ish) Discussion
Only a few days left! Post your current bingo cards. Continue updating us on your games! Finish your Backlog Burning by June 1st! Quick links: Backlog Bingo Site Week 1 Discussion and Event...
Only a few days left!
Post your current bingo cards.
Continue updating us on your games!
Finish your Backlog Burning by June 1st!Quick links:
- Backlog Bingo Site
- Week 1 Discussion and Event Guidelines
- Week 2 Discussion
- Week 3 Discussion
- Week 4 Discussion
Week 4 Recap
8 participants played 7 bingo cards and moved 29 games out of their backlogs!
There were t̵̳̒h̵̡̫͊r̷̘̼̎é̴̪̕e̶͙̭̓̿ bingo wins!
Congratulations to u/SingedFrostLantern, u/kfwyre, and ų̷̪̭̖͚̮̃̃̃̅̉͒͑̀͊͜/̸͙͇̿͒́̋̽̈̈́ą̷͈̠͍̪̯̩͕͛́̐̈́̾͠p̶͔͕̭͓̫͕͓̬̫̗̉̅̽̈́̇́͘͝ḫ̸̠̤̫̦͖̘̙̣̦͗͜ǫ̴̯̪̣͚̥̝̞̘͊̏͠ȩ̷̛̖̭͕̗̹̹̌͛͌͆̋̈́n̸̯̮͕͂̄̀͗͐̋̈́̿̂͆i̷̱͉̰̻͈̦̗̤͋͌̂̍̋̿͜ͅẋ̶̡̛̘͖͎̰͓̫̼̀͂͗͒̉͑͝͝ͅ28% of games played this week started with the letter S.
There was a 5 letter stretch of the alphabet for which there were no games played: H-I-J-K-L
At least 2 Linux distributions were installed by participants this week.
Coincidentally, at least 2 bingo cards were deleted by participants this week.
Thus far, a total of 136 games have been played for the May 2025 Backlog Burner.
Game List:
- Against the Storm
- Arcade Paradise
- The Binding of Isaac
- Celeste
- Chef: A Restaurant Tycoon Game
- Divinity: Original Sin - Enhanced Edition
- Foundation
- Garshasp: The Monster Slayer
- Goat Simulator 3
- Grand Theft Auto V
- Machinarium
- Neon Noodles
- Nina Aquila: Legal Eagle
- Noita
- OneShot
- PixelJunk Eden
- Potion Craft: Alchemist Simulator
- Shadow Warrior (2013)
- Shing!
- Shoot Many Robots
- Spacerat Miner
- Splice
- The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe
- The Swapper
- Stray Gods
- Tapeworm Disco Puzzle
- Tau
- Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales
- The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
Week 3 Recap
10 Participants played 7 bingo cards and moved 38 games out of their backlogs!
There were 0 bingo wins.Participants played as at least 7 animals:
- a dolphin
- a frog
- a martian
- a rat
- two cats
- a squirrel
At least 1 of those animals possessed a gun.
68% of the games played this week started with a letter in the first half of the alphabet.
Thus far, a total of 107 games have been played for the May 2025 Backlog Burner.
Game List:
- Amnesia: The Dark Descent
- Astral Ascent
- BEEP
- Blue Prince
- Brothers - A Tale of Two Sons
- A Case of Distrust
- Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow
- Celeste (randomizer)
- CrankVenture Capitalist
- DETOUR
- Doc Louis's Punch-Out!!
- Dordogne
- DREDGE
- Ecco the Dolphin
- Echo: The Oracle's Scroll
- Endless Alice
- Erenshor
- Fable Anniversary
- Frog Fractions: Game of the Decade Edition
- From Dust
- Griftlands
- I and Me
- Inscryption
- Legend of Mysteria
- Mars After Midnight
- MAZE
- Neverending Nightmares
- Nomad Survival
- Pool Panic
- Propeller Rat
- Sea of Stars
- Shadows of Doubt
- Squirrel With a Gun
- SteamWorld Quest: Hand of Gilgamech
- Tales of the Neon Sea
- Tactical Breach Wizards
- Timelie
- Zero Zero: Perfect Stop
Week 2 Recap
9 participants played 8 bingo cards and moved 46 games out of their backlogs!
There was 1 bingo win. Congrats to u/Durinthal!
Games were played at at least 1 major gaming convention.
8 games played had at least five words in their titles.
Game list:
- The 7th Guest
- Albion Online
- Animal Crossing
- Balatro
- Baldur's Gate 3
- Bang Bang Racing
- Berzerk Boy
- Bob Came in Pieces
- Choice of Robots
- Core Fault
- ctrl.alt.DEAL
- Diplomacy Is Not an Option
- Epigraph
- Fretless - The Wrath of Riffson
- Golfing Over It with Alva Majo
- Gravity Circuit
- Grotesque Tactics: Evil Heroes
- The Hungry Lamb: Traveling in the Late Ming Dynasty
- JoustMania
- Kismet
- Mage's Tower
- MLEM: Space Agency
- Monster Prom
- Naheulbeuk's Dungeon Master
- Nocturne
- Orna
- Pacific Drive
- Perfect Tides: Station to Station
- Puzzle Agent
- Puzzler World 2
- Recettear: An Item Shop's Tale
- Recommendation Dog
- Revenge of the Titans
- Ricochet
- Royalty Free-For-All
- Shining Gadget
- A Short Hike
- Simple Pinball
- Steel Battalion
- Tales of the Neon Sea
- TUNIC
- Virtua Cop 2
- While Waiting
- Workers & Resources: Soviet Republic
- Yoku's Island Express
- ZeroRanger
Week 1 Recap
10 participants played 7 bingo cards and moved 23 games out of their backlogs!
At least 6 different platforms were used: Nintendo DS, PC, Playdate, Switch, Wii U, Wonderswan
There were 0 bingo wins.
- 4 people played Flow bingo cards
- 1 person played a Flow Golf bingo card
- 2 people played Flux bingo cards
- 3 people played free choice
Game list:
- Advance Wars: Dual Strike
- beatmania
- The Botanist
- Braid
- Chicory: A Colorful Tale
- Costume Quest
- Cranky Cove
- DREDGE
- The Farmer Was Replaced
- Fire Emblem: Three Houses
- The Letter
- Life is Feudal
- Lugaru HD
- Match-o-3000
- Ratropolis
- Resident Evil 2
- Roundguard
- Shelter
- Shelter 2
- Suzerain
- Theresia
- Trackminia
- Trauma
14 votes -
First of Kind, Season 1 (intimate conversations with design pioneers)
4 votes -
Citing illegal pollution US racial justice nonprofit NAACP calls for emergency shutdown of Elon Musk's supercomputer in Memphis
21 votes -
Most new cars in Norway are EVs – how a freezing country beat range anxiety
11 votes -
Ireland gets world’s first printed social houses
11 votes -
Holger Rune reached the fourth round of the French Open 2025 with an eventful win over Quentin Halys
4 votes -
Japan Post launches 'digital address' system
31 votes -
How I started studying ways to put seaweed to use
4 votes -
Frankenstein | Official teaser
11 votes -
Anzv - Edimmu (2025)
4 votes -
Hikaru Nakamura had winning chances in both classical and armageddon against Arjun Erigaisi, but blundered a winning position in round five of Norway Chess 2025
5 votes -
End of 10: Replace Windows 10 with Linux
98 votes -
What in your opinion is the greatest guitar solo?
From time to time, i think about great solos in music. And when i do i always want to make a compilation playlist with songs featuring these beautiful solos. Some of the solos that come to mind is...
From time to time, i think about great solos in music. And when i do i always want to make a compilation playlist with songs featuring these beautiful solos.
Some of the solos that come to mind is the building crescendo of Unforgiven by Metallica, that ends in a beautifully unforgettable cacophony of sound that elevates the song to another level.
Or Sultans of Swing by Dire Straits, which have a fantastic wonder-scene that gives great attention to the incredible mastering of the song.I would love to hear what song featuring what you believe is the most unforgettable solo.
Thank you all in advance, and have a great day!36 votes -
Havukruunu – Tavastland (2024)
10 votes -
What have you been watching / reading this week? (Anime/Manga)
What have you been watching and reading this week? You don't need to give us a whole essay if you don't want to, but please write something! Feel free to talk about something you saw that was...
What have you been watching and reading this week? You don't need to give us a whole essay if you don't want to, but please write something! Feel free to talk about something you saw that was cool, something that was bad, ask for recommendations, or anything else you can think of.
If you want to, feel free to find the thing you're talking about and link to its pages on Anilist, MAL, or any other database you use!
9 votes -
My experience running my phone in greyscale for the past several weeks
So for the past several weeks, I have been running my phone almost exclusively in greyscale. This is a tactic that is normally recommended for reducing phone usage, and can be easily done in iOS...
So for the past several weeks, I have been running my phone almost exclusively in greyscale. This is a tactic that is normally recommended for reducing phone usage, and can be easily done in iOS and Android through accessibility settings. The primary argument is without the colours to grab your attention, the phone looks less enticing.
My experience has been mostly positive, with a few drawbacks. Overall, it has made me use my phone less, although it is not the only change I have done.
Benefits:
- I do find my phone less distracting. It is less appealing.
- Text based content still works great.
- Images are normally readable, although sometimes I miss subtlety in images.
- If needed I can toggle it off, but I rarely do so.
Drawbacks:
- It took me several days to adjust, and it was a hard adjustment period.
- Some apps use colour for organization. The biggest offender in my use case for this is Three Cheers for Tildes. Overall the app is great, but new comments being denoted by an orange line is not readable for me. However, this just at times leads me to wait until I am at a desktop to look at the thread. I do think both on website and in apps Tildes should look at putting new comments with a dotted line, to not rely only on colour for accessibility reasons.
Surprises:
- The biggest surprise for me is how unappealing my phone is in colour, since the use of colour everywhere is jarring. Most people do not realize how bright and colourful even phone menus are, until they run greyscale for an extended period of time. It has become more obvious to me how much app developers (and even OS developers) are using colour to grab our attention and suck us in.
67 votes -
TV Tuesdays Free Talk
Warning: this post may contain spoilers
Have you watched any TV shows recently you want to discuss? Any shows you want to recommend or are hyped about? Feel free to discuss anything here.
Please just try to provide fair warning of spoilers if you can.
13 votes -
Using Rust backend to serve an SPA
6 votes -
Five years later, Deep Rock Galactic has gotten far by rejecting modernity
27 votes -
Intelligent Agent Technology: Open Sesame! (1993)
7 votes -
Closed captions on DVDs are getting left behind
14 votes -
Why did the UK government nationalise this pub?
10 votes -
What have you been listening to this week?
What have you been listening to this week? You don't need to do a 6000 word review if you don't want to, but please write something! If you've just picked up some music, please update on that as...
What have you been listening to this week? You don't need to do a 6000 word review if you don't want to, but please write something! If you've just picked up some music, please update on that as well, we'd love to see your hauls :)
Feel free to give recs or discuss anything about each others' listening habits.
You can make a chart if you use last.fm:
http://www.tapmusic.net/lastfm/
Remember that linking directly to your image will update with your future listening, make sure to reupload to somewhere like imgur if you'd like it to remain what you have at the time of posting.
9 votes -
Capital One US settlement: Here's who's eligible for $425 million payout
23 votes -
MiniPC home server recommendations
Hello Tildes! I've been trying out a lot of open-source apps these past few months but I've always hosted them on a VPS. It's been great and educational so far. However, I started considering to...
Hello Tildes!
I've been trying out a lot of open-source apps these past few months but I've always hosted them on a VPS. It's been great and educational so far. However, I started considering to host my very own server on-prem so that my data is absolutely physically with me and nowhere else.
With that short intro, I'd like to say I'm in the market for a home server. I can install OS's, docker containers, etc. And that's how I managed to install Jellyfin, Immich, Paperless, Portainer, etc on my VPS right now.
What out-of-the-box miniPC can be good for someone dipping their toes in the home server scene? I feel like I might need the storage to be extendable somehow? And it must be able to stream music and video through Jellyfin.
The choices in YouTube videos are overwhelming that I keep jumping from saying "ooh I'll get that" to "oh wait maybe I'll get that other one".
I also am not very handy in terms of hardware so I would prefer something out-of-the-box (if possible). Maybe a max budget of 500? But around 400 euros would be preferred. (Edit: In EU also, if possible)
Thanks for reading! Hope to hear from you guys!
33 votes -
Weekly thread for casual chat and photos of pets
This is the place for casual discussion about our pets. Photos are welcome, show us your pet(s) and tell us about them!
4 votes -
What games have you been playing, and what's your opinion on them?
What have you been playing lately? Discussion about video games and board games are both welcome. Please don't just make a list of titles, give some thoughts about the game(s) as well.
24 votes -
'The Wheel of Time' cancelled after three seasons
39 votes -
Loretta Swit, Emmy-winner who played Maj. Houlihan on pioneering series ‘M.A.S.H.,’ has died at 87
28 votes -
New device lets homeowners test tap water for lead easily
17 votes -
Duolingo is replacing human workers with AI
34 votes -
What are some good vegan substitutes for cheese?
I've been slowly transitioning my diet away from meat and dairy products. Cutting meat out has not really been an issue for me, and most dairy has been easy (I find the idea of milk gross anyway,...
I've been slowly transitioning my diet away from meat and dairy products. Cutting meat out has not really been an issue for me, and most dairy has been easy (I find the idea of milk gross anyway, never liked sour cream much, and butter substitutes are plentiful), but so far the idea of cutting out cheese seems like it will be my biggest hurdle. It's a central ingredient in many things I enjoy (mac and cheese, pizza, grilled cheese, sprinkling it on pasta, queso with chips and salsa, cottage cheese with jam, pretty much any Mexican dish). One of my sons is allergic to dairy so I've had plenty opportunities to try some of the small selection of vegan cheeses (mostly wheat based, I believe) we can get around here and they just don't do it for me at all--I find the texture and taste of every one I've tried actively repulsive (Daiya and Violife are the two that spring to mind).
Has anyone had better luck with vegan cheese--maybe brands or styles that I'm unaware of that come closer to replacing the real thing? Any tips on how to make cheeseless pizza that doesn't taste like sadness and despair? Or will there be a cheese-shaped hole in my soul I'm going to have to live with when I finally give it up?
25 votes -
Alaska man survives after being trapped face-down in creek by 700lb boulder
28 votes -
Danish coach of Mainz 05, Bo Henriksen, has been voted Coach of the Year in German football ahead of Bayern Munich's Vincent Kompany
5 votes -
Predator: Killer of Killers | Official trailer
9 votes -
Electric Universe - Lakshmi (2019)
10 votes -
I miss D&D
This is a long mind dump of my history with D&D, my love of it, etc. tl;dr - I love D&D. I liked DMing briefly. My group broke apart. I miss D&D. Around 6 or 7 years ago a friend invited me to...
This is a long mind dump of my history with D&D, my love of it, etc.
tl;dr - I love D&D. I liked DMing briefly. My group broke apart. I miss D&D.
Around 6 or 7 years ago a friend invited me to play D&D for the first time. I met a bunch of new people through this group and while a lot of people came and went throughout our two campaigns, there was always a core group of 3 of us that were always present.
At first it was very nerve-wracking. Not only because I was still learning the mechanic, but also because there's a certain amount of performance and vulnerability in getting into your character. While at home I'm always dropping into silly voices to make my wife laugh and I've gotten pretty good at doing various accents, cartoony voices, etc., at the table I couldn't do any of it. I had stage fright in front of a group of very accepting and kind friends. And it took me a few sessions (and beers) to push through it and be my authentic, goofy self in-person like that. In a way, it helped me grow as a person.
Eventually our DM moved far away and a bunch of players were left without anyone to lead our games, so we just didn't play for about a year. During that year I began thinking about DMing. My grasp of D&D's mechanics have never been great, but in that year Baldur's Gate 3 came out. And I hear some of you groaning because I know it's not a 1:1 match with 5e's rules. But it helped fill my knowledge gaps enough that I felt sorta okay DMing. So I offered to DM.
My first session was a premade campaign from the Starter Kit. Almost immediately I wanted to tweak the story, insert old characters of mine, throw in a few references my friends might get, stuff like that. I think we made it like 2 sessions in before I announced I'd be making my own damn campaign (with the group's support, mind you). But again, between my friends support and pushing myself, I was able to tackle some of my social anxiety because the challenges of running the entire game are completely different from the challenges of being a player.
I dove head-first into this new campaign. I wanted to do this massive campaign as a love song to puppetry because I grew up around my parents running a puppet ministry at church. So between that and Sesame Street, The Muppets, Lambchop, etc. I have this deep love of puppetry as an art form. And somewhere along the way, someone suggested a pirate theme, so I combined them. Thus I began working on a Muppet Treasure Island inspired D&D campaign.
I don't think I realized my capacity for creativity until I began working on this campaign. I never thought of myself as someone who needed a creative outlet, but holy shit was creating the D&D campaign a wonderful outlet for my creativity. I spent hours during and after work just writing and making maps. It was so fulfilling, even though the story itself was, in retrospect, kind of all over the damn place. Yet again, D&D helped me grow a little bit as a person. It gave me a creative outlet. It gave me fulfillment that I was critically lacking at work.
And then we started running the campaign. Session 0 was via Zoom and we all got excited about it. Session 1 was a pretty standard "you wake up as felt creatures on a mysterious beach and are quickly taken prisoner by King Friday, but let loose by his royal advisor X The Owl to help him solve a global problem because reasons" plot. But it was fun and I felt so alive.
Then session 2 one of the players had to bail...and I was not going to let that prevent the session from happening, so we just worked around it. Then by the time I was scheduling session 3 that player bailed completely. Session 4 was a bit messy/rushed on my part...and then everything just started to fall apart. Weeks went by, then months, now it's been nearly 2 years I think? We never even got off the starting island...all the story I wrote...all the maps I'd created...just completely unused. And it was soul-crushing. I felt like I'd wasted my time. I felt stupid for having put so much effort into something that fell apart so quickly.
But that was a bad attitude on my part, in retrospect. It wasn't a waste. I enjoyed every second of it. It was fulfilling. It was fun. So I'm thinking about returning to it and just fleshing out the rest of the campaign a bit more. I'm hoping to watch a lot of Dimension 20 in the coming weeks to get me back in the mood and take what I learn from it and just get back into D&D. Honestly I don't know that I want to DM again because I think that core group is done for when it comes to D&D. And it's hard to imagine finding another group I feel that comfortable with, but maybe? I think it's okay to just worldbuild for worldbuilding's sake, ya know?
But I do miss playing. I miss being in-character. I miss coming up with silly backstories and goofy premises for a character. I miss talking in funny voices for other adults (my kids get the bulk of it, these days). I miss making people laugh and contributing to them having a good time. And D&D was a perfect outlet for all of that. One of these days I'm going to find the motivation and courage to just find a group of strangers to join and try to quiet the social anxiety enough to enjoy it.
42 votes -
Save Point: A game deal roundup for the week of May 25
Add awesome game deals to this topic as they come up over the course of the week! Alternately, ask about a given game deal if you want the community’s opinions: e.g. “What games from this bundle...
Add awesome game deals to this topic as they come up over the course of the week!
Alternately, ask about a given game deal if you want the community’s opinions: e.g. “What games from this bundle are most worth my attention?”
Rules:
- No grey market sales
- No affiliate links
If posting a sale, it is strongly encouraged that you share why you think the available game/games are worthwhile.
All previous Save Point topics
If you don’t want to see threads in this series, add
save point
to your personal tag filters.13 votes -
Do not try this at home: Medieval medicine under the spotlight in major new project
16 votes